New American Restaurants in Madison, WI

Heritage Tavern New American • $$$
131 E Mifflin St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom & Juniper Crusted Grilled Striploin & Braised Beef Short Rib
Tempura Bacon-Wrapped Cheese Curds
Maple Lamb Sausage & Savory Toast
Old Fashioned Ham Cinnamon Roll
Market Vegetable Benedict
Bacon Wrapped Cheese Curds
Foie Gras & Lardo Poutine
Crispy Pork Belly & Tuna
Heritage Tavern Benedict
Heritage Pork Schnitzel

“Had a great dinner on a Saturday night. Dined at a late seating and staff was very friendly and welcoming. Dishes were great, the deviled eggs were a great starter for our table and the entrees were big portions with a lot going on (on a good way). The farm to table and seasonal ingredients really accompanied the main proteins. I had schnitzel which was great. Others had the massive ribeye for 2 and boullabaisse and everyone enjoyed their meals.
Would done here again next time we visit Madison.“

4.6 Superb166 Reviews
Mint Mark New American • $$
1874 E Washington Ave, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Egg Benedict and Fries
Biscuits and Gravy
Preserved Mushrooms
Mint Mark Burger
Brussels Sprouts
Cauliflower Salad
Friday Fish Fry
Skillet Cookie
Bread Pudding

“Good drinks menu but the food was so-so. Flavors unremarkable. No information on the menu for those who are lactose or gluten intolerant which is easy to flag on menus these days. And the random delivery of small plates, which was to be expected, could have been a little bit more even for our table of four. And worth letting us know, when we order, which dishes might take quite a bit longer to prepare and deliver. Nice ambiance and good lighting. 3/5.“

4.3 Superb185 Reviews
3

CIRC

CIRC New American • $
1 W Dayton St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup
Espresso French Toast
English Breakfast
Salads

“The Carryout home kits!!💙 just did our first order with them and everything is packed so nicely. Everything has been delicious, staff was very nice, very reasonably priced, and I’m just so happy we ordered from them. Thank you! (If you order, please remember to tip on top of your order).“

4.3 Superb63 Reviews
Kettle Black Kitchen American • $$
1835 Monroe St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Icelandic Cod with Mushrooms and Potatoes
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Grilled Flat Iron Steak
Cod and Roasted Potatoes
Sweet Potato Medallions
Fire Roasted Oysters
Faroe Island Salmon
French Onion Soup
Shrimp and Grits
Charleston Shrimp

“The spicy salmon and prickly pear margarita were amazing!“

4.7 Superb130 Reviews
5

RED

RED Sushi • $$$
316 W Washington Ave #100, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Tiger Roll Spicy Tuna Roll Tempura Roll
Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice
Shiitake Tempura Roll
Bigeye Tuna Tartare
Vegan Sushi Dinner
Sushi Restaurant
Hamachi Jalapeno
California Roll
Sashimi Dinner
Spicy Godzilla

“Had a business trip in Madison, WI this week. The restaurant is close by so we reserved the seats here. Gosh, it certainly didn’t disappoint us. The sushi rolls were amazing and the sashimi was fresh and delicious. It was pleasant to dine outdoors there and the service was excellent too. Great food to try!“

4.6 Superb164 Reviews
Madison's American • $$
119 King St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Pork Carnitas with Corn Soft Shell Tacos
Nacho and Wing Appetizers
Blackened Tuna Sandwich
Shrimp Cocktail Solo
The Madison Burger
Biscuits and Gravy
Biscuits N' Gravy
Breakfast Burrito
Lunch Size Burger
Chicken Sandwich

“They had a glitch with their online order; let me order Prime Rib on a day that they did not serve; when I arrived to pickup, they had no online order for me, even though I received a confirmation. They prepared another steak meal - but it was excellent!! Great flavor!! When ordering online, may want to double check they received the order.“

4.5 Superb229 Reviews
L'Etoile Restaurant Fine Dining
1 S Pinckney St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Wine Pairing
Duck Confit
Duck Breast
Doughnuts
Ravioli
Sorbet
Halibut

“My ex boyfriend took me here for my birthday once and I fell in love with it. The king salmon and the chocolate babka are amazing! 10/10“

4.8 Superb78 Reviews