14 Best Ice Cream Shops near Milton

“ice cream is the creamy type. the flavors have great smell and taste.“

“The customer service was excellent! I am very indecisive and the cashier was very patient and helped me choose. My friend also ran into an issue with payment and the manager was very nice and flexible. I will definitely be back!! :)“

“Burgers, chicken, onion rings are all great. My favorite is their Blizzard! I love my Butterfinger Blizzards. They are much better than Culver's Concrete Mixers.(Weird name for an ice cream treat)

Parking: Lots of parking available.

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy to get in and out.“

“My mangonada was so delicious!! I can’t stop raving about it. We also got ice cream and popsicles which were delicious. The shop was very clean and the staff member was friendly. Highly recommend!“

“This place is crazy. I was all ready to pull out a $20 and only had to pull out a $10 to feed a family of 5 desert. Also parking is crazy. I have to park across the street since the lot is full and there are 5 cars in the street waiting to get in. Anyone who would rather go down the street to another establishment is crazy. The one and only downside about this place is that it is only open March through October.“

“This is a cute little ice cream/candy shop! I love that they now have few different options for ice cream! I am allergic to dairy so this is a home run for me! Hope that they add more dairy free options!

Dietary restrictions: Dairy free options“

“I’ve been getting iced lattes here everyday they are open for over 2 years. Absolutely the best! All the baristas are quick and kind. The bakery selection and breakfast paninis are also great.“

“I love The Sugar Exchange! I ordered the chocolate covered strawberries for Valentines Day and they were the best I have had! Strawberries were ripe and the chocolate was delicious! I highly recommend!“

“Thank you 🙏🏻 to the Friday night crew in Janesville your hospitality of welcoming everyone and fast service to making our trip the most enjoyable and satisfying experience!! Everyone working together as a team and getting customers served fast and correctly!! Thanks 🙏🏻 again!!👍🏻❤️💪🏻🍔🍟🍗“

“The food is always hot and fresh. Really too bad they don't make the salad with fresh greens like advertised on their website. I believe a couple of years ago they switched to bagged lettuce. Don't really get the salads anymore due to that. Sometimes overcook the shrimp but otherwise a very good experience with great food“

“Huge shout out to Joe for coming in clutch and saving the day when I made the worst mistake! I accidentally put the wrong date for pick up (a whole week later than our party) so when my husband went to pick it up, it obviously wasn't ready. Joe was able to get things figured out to have the cake made tonight and picked up first thing in the morning...quite literally just in time for my son's 4th birthday party. Thanks to the crew at Cold Stone and thank you SO much Joe for literally saving my son's birthday party!!“

“This is a fabulous location! The staff is always so nice, and knowledgeable. The food is fresh and delicious (although I do wish one dipping sauce was included with the value basket). They updated the parking lot and upgraded the landscaping, it looks great! It's a must try spot on the westside. Thank you for enhancing our community.“

“best shaved ice I have had!!“

“Do I recommend Culver’s? Yes! Of course! I’m from the Midwest…. What I recommend more is that the twat nugget that was working the custard area tonight, (4/12/25), find a new job. Complaining about the fact that I ordered a concrete mixer with only butterfinger by saying I should “go to McDonald’s”…. 2 things… #1 Literally your board advertises a butterfinger concrete mixer and #2 Custard and ice cream are different… 🙄 lort“