New American Restaurants near Mukwonago, WI

“Shanahan’s has been my favorite place to treat myself since we moved to Mukwonago. I had to give up dairy several years ago temporarily and that was how I found them but I continued to visit when I discovered that everything is delicious! Recently I treated myself to a GF/Vegan Key Lime pie, which I had never tried. “Regular” key lime pie is one of my favorite desserts and I’ve never had a GF/vegan version. It was the best key lime pie I’ve ever had anywhere! My kids saw the GF/vegan label and said “eh no thanks mom” but when I opened the box they changed their mind. That pie didn’t last 24 hours in our house! My go to drink is their Azteca but their oat milk chai is also delicious! Oh and if you’re looking for catering, try them! We had a small meeting catered about a year and a half ago where people from all across SE Wisconsin attended and I still get comments about the food from Shanahans!“

“This is the very 1st place I've ever eaten breakfast that has cooked eggs EXACTLY as ordered! Everything was reasonably priced and delicious! They use Farmers Brothers Coffee too making this the best breakfast place ever in my book! Thank you for a job well done!“

“Great place to stop at and enjoy a nice cocktail with good company 😁 From the other Tiffany and her Mom“

“Great food!!!! Great bar tenders and waitresses.“

“Probably the best coffee I had in a long time It's Stone Creek offee and it is amazing. The food was delightful and will have us coming back for more soon!“

“The best fish fry I have ever had! The walleye was delicious. It’s our new favorite Friday destination. Excellent service“

“Let’s start with 5 stars***** We visited Tally’s Tap on Wednesday October 8, 2025. This was our first visit. We spoke to a man on the way in, and he recommended the BBQ Ribs which was the ‘Homemade Dinner’ special - his name was Stan (a once a week regular). Inside we were promptly seated, and it was busy, with a full parking lot. Mike was our great waiter, and we also met Chad (another super friendly and knowledgeable waiter). I ordered a full rack of ribs, with Mac and cheese, fresh green beans, and corn bread for $24 (I think). Stan and Chad were right - the ribs were super tender, great BBQ sauce. I shared them with my husband and daughter and we all felt they were absolutely outstanding. Corn bread was very tasty as was the Mac and cheese. My husband ordered a wrap with grilled portobello, and a cilantro sauce - he said it was good. My daughter ordered a salad, with fried chicken sliced on top, and substituted the menu dressing for the green goddess. Everyone enjoyed their food. It was a lovely first visit, and we will be back! Thanks to the employees, and owners for making this such a great experience. By the way - I am very picky. I know good food because I worked in some great restaurants on the East Coast. It is tough to have me really love a meal - but you guys made that happen!“

“We love The Blue Heron & usually go on a Weds night for fish. This past Saturday we went to celebrate our 20 year anniversary. We ordered the Sat Special. 2 ,8oz strips steaks, soup, salad, garlic mashed potatoes & a dessert to split, $54.99. Wow! Not only was the food awesome for a great price, the staff was awesome too. In my opinion this is the best place for quality cocktails, food & service at a great price. Special shout out for their home made blue cheese salad dressing. Might be the best I have ever had. Make yourself some reservations & enjoy!“