New American Restaurants in Oshkosh, WI

“5 stars. Joe is one of a kind. We enjoy the Chalice any day of the week and today we had the chance to host a baby shower there (believe this is a Sunday only thing? FYI). He and his daughter took great care of us, they helped with everything from the minute we walked in. We knew this place was special and today just took it to another level. Thanks for the great food, company, hospitality, and everything you did you make the day special. Know the food is just as special and unique as the people who will serve you when you visit. We are already looking forward to our next visit. Thanks again!“

“One of my favorite restaurants in Downtown Oshkosh! The staff is friendly, the seasonal drink menu is always fun -- and I absolutely love the cauliflower manchurian & the butternut squash salad!“

“I love this place! We had a group of 10. They were quite busy (as usual) For a Monday Night. Menu has actually Dinners. Not just Bar and Grill food like most places in town these days. Food came out fast and hot! Very reasonable prices! Great drinks and superb service. (Franko and Haley). We will definitely be back! Thank you!!!“

“Good experience with good food“

“I NEED to shout out this restaurant and I WISH I caught the servers name but she wasn’t our server. I came in to eat with my boyfriend and my toddler daughter about a month ago, two weeks after I had a hysterectomy. My daughter needed her diaper changed, I took her to the bathroom then immediately realized I forgot I’m unable to carry or lift her yet. I ran out to ask my boyfriend if we could ask if he could come in just to lift her onto the changing table for me, though he told me to try to ask someone for assistance bc there was also people in the restroom as well. As absolutely EMBARRASSING as that was I kindly asked the man at the front if there was a female available at that moment and I explained the situation for her. She didn’t even hesitate and helped me lift her up onto the changing table. I was so embarrassed but I had literally gotten sepsis already from the surgery and had to also have an extra procedure due to the infection and I couldn’t risk any further near-death experiences from this surgery. She was so sweet and I was so happy with not feeling absolutely judged or looking incapable outside of the circumstances. Thank you!“

“Food was good, we had service for 7 and had great service! Lots of different food options. Place is loud which was surprising since we thought a place with a reservation would be quieter. Cheese curds were hands down some of the best (photo attached). Ribeye special was amazing (sister had that dish). Side salads are a hefty portion (Attached photo). Daughter had chicken curry soup and said it was delicious. I had the sirloin with mushroom sauce, mashed potatoes and string beans (photo attached) it was delicious and a large portion. Cocktails were not our favorite, they didn't taste that good.“

“Ate here today for the first time and we’ll definitely be back. I had the Sweet Corn Cappelletti today and it was FANTASTIC! The side salad was so fresh and delicious. Great food and service!“

“Ate here today for the first time and we’ll definitely be back. I had the Sweet Corn Cappelletti today and it was FANTASTIC! The side salad was so fresh and delicious. Great food and service!“

“Four of us had drinks and dinner on Tuesday. The staff are all top notch! Friendly and professional bartender, waitress and chef. Our steaks and seafood were all cooked perfectly. The chef paid a visit to every table to get direct feedback. Nice neighborhood supper club experience!“

“The tenderloin steak sandwich is the BEST in the Valley!!“

“Came to this place in 1993, had the best time on my trip of the USA from Australia, took me ages to find my hotel the Pioneer inn, got stuck at the rail crossing with some long train a thought I was never gonna get back to the hotel until the sun came up. Good memories.“

“Friendly staff, great 2/1 daily special for happy hour. Great Friday fish fry, wraps are delicious and their soups are so good!“

“The service and food were fairly good The atmosphere was nice and casual. The servers were tentative. The place was clean and I definitely would consider it in the future. It’s not a chain and it looks like they take a little bit of pride in the food that they put out and how it’s presented and most of all how it taste.“