New American Restaurants near Kohler, WI

“First time here. Reservation was for 7pm for five people. We were early and were seated right away. So many drink choices on the menu. My son loved his waygu burger, I ordered the wild mushroom ravioli and it was to die for. The ribeye was cooked perfectly! Service was awesome. Waitress was attentive. Bartenders were personable. Great experience!“

“Favorite spot on the resort to grab a drink. There is often live music, but the real show is behind the bar. The bartenders work together well, it was quite impressive considering how busy they were. They also have a great assortment of wine (obvs), spirits, and beers. Highly recommend.“

“Atmosphere and service was exceptional. Ribeye was very disappointing. Lack of seasoning. Ordered medium. Came out rare. Expected a better grade quality meat for $60. Paired with sidewinders… I love Sidewinder fries but not with steak. I would still recommend this place. Avoid the steaks.“

“Fantastic experience! I recently dined at the Horse & Plow in Kohler and had an amazing time. The food was absolutely delicious, and the drinks were just as good! Our server was friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. The cozy atmosphere and quality service make this a must-visit spot — I’ll definitely be coming back!“

“What a great dinner experience! This was our first Immigrant dinning experience and we had a lovely server who brought the best attitude and knowledge to the evening. The sommelier was equally as knowledgeable about the wines being served, and also had a great sense of humor. The restaurant itself was such a fun sight! Bold colors, wild combination of antique and contemporary designs. The only downside is the dress code. Guys, be sure to wear a long sleeve button up, which is absurd in 2026. For a place that prides itself on being modern and innovative, they could do to make some revisions to their dress-code rules. Especially considering that the rules didn't really seem to apply to the women... Otherwise, amazing.“

“Granary bourbon bar is exceptional, from bourbons available, food, cocktails and especially the staff. Absolutely incredible, very knowledgeable, friendly, personable and fun“

“its a friendly place for you and your family and friends and your wallet“

“Had the perch today and it was excellent- no bones that I found which was great!!! Excellent breading - not greasy- the best around honestly.“

“Great beer, great drinks, great music, great people“

“😎 great cheese burgers, good service“

“Some friends and I made reservations before a comedy show. Once we got there we quickly realized we didn't give ourselves enough time to thoroughly enjoy the atmosphere and eat at leasure, which is what Bomallies does best,try,eat ,try something new again. We meantioned to our server, the amazing Holly, our time restraints, she then helped us though the menu on what we could get in time, while still enjoying ourselves. Not only did we have an amazing meal and delicious crafted drinks but we checked out and got to our show (in Kohler) with minutes to spare. THIS MY FRIEND, it what sets BoMallies aside. Not only have I never had a bad meal, I have always had the customer service that made me walk away loving my time with them and ALWAYS leaving with a strawberry shortcake to go. No matter how full I am. You won't be disapointed .“

“Food is usually great but they have changed the pizza crust. The new crust is awful. Please bring back the old crust! The service is always wonderful!“

“Best chicken wings I’ve ever had!“

“Went to Al and Al’s for their St Patrick’s day buffet on Tuesday! The corned beef and the eggrolls were so delicious! I’ve never had corned beef that literally melted in your mouth! I highly enjoyed the 2 different soup options too! The crew in the kitchen is wonderful and does a great job!“