Browse menus, reviews and photos of New American Restaurants near Sheboygan.
Bar · $
1702 South 17th Street, Sheboygan
Customers’ favorites
“Great beer, great drinks, great music, great people”
American · $$
2427 Calumet Drive, Sheboygan
Customers’ favorites
“Some friends and I made reservations before a comedy show. Once we got there we quickly realized we didn't give ourselves enough time to thoroughly enjoy the atmosphere and eat at leasure, which is what Bomallies does best,try,eat ,try something new again. We meantioned to our server, the amazing Holly, our time restraints, she then helped us though the menu on what we could get in time, while still enjoying ourselves. Not only did we have an amazing meal and delicious crafted drinks but we checked out and got to our show (in Kohler) with minutes to spare. THIS MY FRIEND, it what sets BoMallies aside. Not only have I never had a bad meal, I have always had the customer service that made me walk away loving my time with them and ALWAYS leaving with a strawberry shortcake to go. No matter how full I am. You won't be disapointed .”
American · $
1635 Indiana Avenue, Sheboygan
Customers’ favorites
“Had the perch today and it was excellent- no bones that I found which was great!!! Excellent breading - not greasy- the best around honestly.”
Bar & Grill · $
811 Indiana Avenue, Sheboygan
Customers’ favorites
“😎 great cheese burgers, good service”
German · $
1502 South 12th Street, Sheboygan
Customers’ favorites
“Went to Al and Al’s for their St Patrick’s day buffet on Tuesday! The corned beef and the eggrolls were so delicious! I’ve never had corned beef that literally melted in your mouth! I highly enjoyed the 2 different soup options too! The crew in the kitchen is wonderful and does a great job!”
Hamburger · $
5533 Superior Avenue, Sheboygan
Customers’ favorites
“Food is usually great but they have changed the pizza crust. The new crust is awful. Please bring back the old crust! The service is always wonderful!”
American · $
930 Center Ave, Oostburg · 9.75 miles
Customers’ favorites
“its a friendly place for you and your family and friends and your wallet”
American · $$
1111 West Riverside Drive, Kohler · 3.45 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Ok. It's not fair that I live so far away. This place makes me want to move into a hotel room and just turn my life into a Cheers episode. Max and Michele made the bar so cozy, I decided to eat there too. Max was working on some creations for the seasonal bar menu and Michele was zooming around and keeping everyone happy, too. I had the Dyehard Wagyu Burger which had to be a half pound or more. So many layers of flavors that belonged together, I don't want to finish this thing. Parmesan and truffle oil fries to top it off on the side. What in the actual f#$%. Soooooooo delicious! I recommend this place to anyone that is expecting $40 to $60 per person, and knowing that it's worth it. I am pretty tight on my wallet, but I'm looking forward to coming back just to really treat myself like I'm special and the crew here makes it feel like home. The Cliffhanger Amber Ale was a solid choice! Such a great night to make new friends!”
Wine Bar · $$$
419 Highland Drive, Kohler · 3.52 miles
“Favorite spot on the resort to grab a drink. There is often live music, but the real show is behind the bar. The bartenders work together well, it was quite impressive considering how busy they were. They also have a great assortment of wine (obvs), spirits, and beers. Highly recommend.”
American · $$$
6018 Superior Avenue, Kohler · 3.64 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Granary bourbon bar is exceptional, from bourbons available, food, cocktails and especially the staff. Absolutely incredible, very knowledgeable, friendly, personable and fun”
American · $$
419 Highland Drive, Kohler · 3.41 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Fantastic experience! I recently dined at the Horse & Plow in Kohler and had an amazing time. The food was absolutely delicious, and the drinks were just as good! Our server was friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. The cozy atmosphere and quality service make this a must-visit spot — I’ll definitely be coming back!”
Sports Bar · $
1142 Plankview Green Boulevard, Sheboygan Falls · 5.39 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best chicken wings I’ve ever had!”
Fine Dining · $$$$
419 Highland Drive, Kohler · 3.52 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Our dinner at The Immigrant Restaurant was truly outstanding from beginning to end! We enjoyed the five-course tasting menu with wine pairings, and every course was beautifully presented, thoughtfully prepared, and absolutely delicious. The wine pairings were spot on, perfectly complementing and enhancing each dish. The service was impeccable, with an attentive, knowledgeable, and professional staff who made the entire evening feel special. The attention to detail, quality of the food, and overall dining experience were exceptional. The Immigrant exceeded our expectations and was one of the highlights of our stay at The American Club.”