“Had a great time when we stopped in. Frankie behind the bar was welcoming and fun but not intrusive. Also, she cheffed up some excellent food for us. Steak sammie was a hit! I’ve only been there once and live 1200 miles away, but if I return to Sheboygan, I’ll be returning here. And *fingers crossed* it will be an equally amazing night!“
“Their wings are the best. Unbelieveably crunchy and juicy. Sure, it takes about 20-30 minutes after ordering to get them, but that’s because they are made to order. So you can sit at the bar with a cold beer and watch them fry them. We sometimes get the wings to go. The Thai chili sauce is great. Servers are also very friendly.“
“Awesome local spot in between Milwaukee and Green Bay. In town to watch a chiefs game and dropped into Sly's for a brat and some local culture. Excellent friendly bar with quick service and a staple double brat sandwich. Sly swung by the table and we spoke about baseball. He gifted us a bottle of Dr. McGillicuddy on our way out. If I'm passing through again, definitely stopping at Sly's!“
“My fiancé and I stopped in tonight for the first time. We will definitely be back. I’ve spent about 7 months of a pregnancy being repulsed by the idea of eating fish, and out of nowhere had the hankering today. The cod absolutely hit the spot & baby’s been kicking up a storm since I took my first few bites. The pieces are a good size, the beer batter is phenomenal. Good NA’s, good service, great food & atmosphere. We’re definitely going to be frequenting this spot.“