36 Best American Restaurants in Sheboygan

“Had the perch today and it was excellent- no bones that I found which was great!!! Excellent breading - not greasy- the best around honestly.“

“Absolutely incredible experience! The food was amazing — every single thing we ordered was delicious. But what really made the night unforgettable was the service. Our waitress was hands down the sweetest, most attentive, and genuinely kind person we’ve ever had… and we were shocked to find out she was actually the owner! You can truly tell how much love and care goes into this restaurant. We were just passing through on a trip, but if we lived here we would definitely come here often!“

“good eats friendly staff“

“Great atmosphere, large portions… awesome for family get together!“

“great atmosphere great servers great company“

“Drinks were fantastic, service was impeccable, got a brief history of the restaurant along with recommendations. Food was delicious and well worth it. we will definitely be back.“

“I've eaten there numerous times and everything is fantastic! waitresses attentive for refills of water and coffee. Always needed a doggie bag. 5 stars!!“

“Five stars for the restaurant at Whistling Straits, where the whiskey bar appears to have been assembled by people who looked at the concept of “enough” and decided it was a coward’s word. There is not much this place is lacking in the whiskey department. You could wander in looking for one good pour and emerge several hours later with a philosophical problem and a strong opinion about Kentucky.

And then there are the fish & chips, which arrived looking innocent enough and proceeded to completely destroy any argument against eating fried food beside a magnificent golf course. Superb fish, righteous crunch, proper chips, and the kind of meal that makes you briefly consider abandoning civilization and living permanently within walking distance of the kitchen.

A dangerous combination: excellent whiskey, superb fish & chips, and a golf course outside that looks like it was designed by a committee of beautiful lunatics. Five stars, no complaints, and a firm recommendation to arrive hungry and leave your better judgment somewhere in the parking lot.“

“Some friends and I made reservations before a comedy show. Once we got there we quickly realized we didn't give ourselves enough time to thoroughly enjoy the atmosphere and eat at leasure, which is what Bomallies does best,try,eat ,try something new again. We meantioned to our server, the amazing Holly, our time restraints, she then helped us though the menu on what we could get in time, while still enjoying ourselves. Not only did we have an amazing meal and delicious crafted drinks but we checked out and got to our show (in Kohler) with minutes to spare. THIS MY FRIEND, it what sets BoMallies aside. Not only have I never had a bad meal, I have always had the customer service that made me walk away loving my time with them and ALWAYS leaving with a strawberry shortcake to go. No matter how full I am. You won't be disapointed .“

“great food, awesome old diner feel. great place to check out. Cash only!“

“Had the chicken bacon panini and cheese curds and both were amazing!“

“Jamie was our waitress and we had a party of 10, she was pleasant and friendly and our food was fantastic. The prices are very reasonable considering what your portions you are getting. We are from another state and when we come back it sure will be a place we will return to.“

“fast, friendly service & the food is exceptional“

“Great Antique Wooden Bar… if it’s still there ! Great Atmosphere! Good People. Located a hop, skip, and a jump from the Harbor District and beaches. Fishing on the Sheb River literally almost out the back door 🐟 🎣“

“the food is great I eat there all the time“

“The best fresh cocktails in town! We've loved going to Urbane for their pear mojitos and food options, so we took our bridal party there for cocktail hour! The staff is always so professional, and make the best cocktails. Additionally, the bartenders always get creative with mocktails and they exceed expectations each time. The bar was decorated so beautifully for Christmas, it was the perfect stop for our bridal party before our reception. Thank you for having us!“

“On the coldest night in January, we enjoyed the juiciest biggest burger, about 5" tall and the most delectably crafted and flavored flat bread. We'll be back!“

“My boss ordered lunch for us today and we all got the classic cheeseburger with fries! Everybody loved it and the burger really was as big as our heads! LOL Awesome burger on the perfect bun, thank you!“

“Great beer, great drinks, great music, great people“

“Tommy's is a great place to visit. They have a very friendly staff and owner!“

“it's a wonderful places to hang pit with friends good music 🎶“

“The bartender is absolutely fantastic! He has a way with making people smile and laugh. The food was good. Next time… I’ll take a medium rare steak-sandwich without cheese, please! That’s my only complaint about the sandwich, had I not ordered the cheese…“

“All the bartender is amazing, super friendly and attentive.“

“Had a great time today. The waitress was great and Mark… I think that was the hosts name was very cool. Such a great guy and was great to us. Appreciate it.“

“Friendly staff and great food.“

“😎 great cheese burgers, good service“

“Had a great time when we stopped in. Frankie behind the bar was welcoming and fun but not intrusive. Also, she cheffed up some excellent food for us. Steak sammie was a hit! I’ve only been there once and live 1200 miles away, but if I return to Sheboygan, I’ll be returning here. And *fingers crossed* it will be an equally amazing night!“

“Absolutely amazing. Burgers were great, fries were absolutely phenomenal. We picked this place in a hat draw for where to take our warning siren group after Tom Dieners funeral. They were so accommodating of our large group and made such a great ending to such a sucky day. Thank you so much. We might have to make this an annual trip to see our late friend.“

“Excellent shrimp dinner. Portions were over the top. Service and waitress were excellent. Highly recommend!“

“Fast and friendly service and the food as always is fantastic!“

“good brew selection and open atmosphere. i just dont reccomend sitting by the door to the smoking room“

“Food is usually great but they have changed the pizza crust. The new crust is awful. Please bring back the old crust! The service is always wonderful!“

“Great service and great food“

“Sly's looks a little rough from the outside but don't let that scare you. The food is excellent and the service is very good. It has a great local atmosphere and there are lots of specials! Bonus was they had the brewer game on!

Wheelchair accessibility: Front door is no steps to the street“

“Went to Al and Al’s for their St Patrick’s day buffet on Tuesday! The corned beef and the eggrolls were so delicious! I’ve never had corned beef that literally melted in your mouth! I highly enjoyed the 2 different soup options too! The crew in the kitchen is wonderful and does a great job!“

“Normally a good value. Our last trip everything was extremely salty. Not sure what happened there. We are not in a hurry to go back.“