7 Best American Restaurants near Elkhart Lake

Paddock Club American • $$
61 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Panacotta with Fresh Berries
Mushroom Risotto Fritters
Eggplant Caprese Salad
Rock Shrimp Linguine
Grilled Hanger Steak
Roasted Duck Breast
Spaghetti Carbonara
Spaghetti Bolognese
Grilled Broccoli
Potato Gnocchi

“We few friends of mine and I drove from out of town to try this place based off a recommendation. We were blown away!!! The service was incredible. All the food was delicious. The hanger steak was the most tender steak I've ever tasted. More than worth the drive.“

4.7 Superb67 Reviews
Siebkens Resort American • $$$
284 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

“Siebkens has been our home away from home for the past two years in the fall and winter.The team is amazing, and everyone is so friendly making us feel right at home while traveling for work!Rooms are modern and well kept, and Siebkens is a short walk away from anything you could want to do in Elkhart Lake. If staying in the area, absolutely consider this for your next trip!“

4.5 Superb61 Reviews
Brown Baer Bar • $
181 E Rhine St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Baer Burger and Kettle Chips
Giant Pretzel

“We stopped in for a Friday night dinner with our two children. There was some seating available since it was the off-season for tourism. The giant pretzel, served with beer cheese and brown mustard for dipping, was crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Delicious! Buffalo cauliflower was roasted to perfection with just enough spice. My daughter and I had the build-your-own chicken sandwich which was just great, too. I especially liked it’s toasted ciabatta bun. My husband enjoyed his southwest chicken sandwich, and my son loved his cheeseburger. I would add that the staff were super friendly, and the blueberry cider was awesome, too. We love the variety of food options here. A wonderful dinner all around!“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
Stop-Inn Tavern Pubs • $
264 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Wisconsin Cheese Curds GF V
Prime Rib Sandwich

“One of the best fish fry’s in Wisconsin. Plenty of seating to accommodate parties of all sizes. The cocktails were strong, local, and refreshing after a hot summer day. This is a true Wisconsin watering hole, and the cheese curds are the best we’ve ever had. If you’re looking for a good time, why don’t you “stop inn” to this tavern? While this place is fabulous for dinner, it also has a wonderful late-night scene as night fades to dawn.“

4.3 Superb35 Reviews
Three Guys & A Grill Restaurant American • $
W7039 County Rd S R, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Surf and Turf Ribeye Perch Dinner
Turkey Pot Pie Soup
Philly Cheese Steak
Steak Sandwich
Grilled Walleye
Cheese Curds
Gator Bites
Deep Fried
Blue Gill
Fish Fry

“We hired Three Guys & A Grill Catering for our community, Village Pointe Commons, Grafton for a very special "Neighborhood Block Party"! We hosted over 200 Residents, Family & Friends! We could NOT have been more pleased! We had NOT ONE complaint which is a real challenge with so many tastes. Hot & delicious food! Moist pulled pork, delicious coleslaw and potato's! Thank you! Scott was great to work with!“

4.2 Good48 Reviews
The Social American • $$
283 Victorian Village Dr, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Mushroom Pizza
Eggs Benedict

“If you can get a seat out on the patio, then do it. You'll be looking out onto Elkhart Lake while eating some tasty food. It doesn't really get better than that. Unfortunately, I didn't get a seat out on the patio because it was hella cold the day that I visited. Instead, I dined inside the warm and eclectically decorated dining room at The Social. There's a popcorn machine in one corner. Church glass and electronic slots machines in another corner. Leather couches and a bar that takes up one whole side of the room. To enter the joint, you need to walk down a flight of stairs and walk in as though you're entering a dungeon. It's kinda dark and cozy and relaxing in The Social. It's a nice vibe.They have a great lunch and dinner menu, as well as snacks and drinks at the bar. I was here one morning for a breakfast buffet, which I think is not typically served on most days, but you might want to check their menu. I also had a fabulous steak dinner one evening, with a pumpkin soup and double chocolate brownie for dessert. Every single thing I put in my mouth was divine, including the signature Old Fashioned.“

3.9 Good14 Reviews
Lake Street Cafe Inc American • $$
21 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Tenderloin Shiraz 10oz
Homemade Potato Chips
Lake Street Burger
Lake Street Pizza
Tomahawk Pork Chop
Soups of the Day
Persistent Lou
Lobster Bisque
Grilled Cheese
Smoked Salmon

“I've not only loved consistently dining at this restaurant with my husband and in-laws, but have also felt very supported and valued as a server here. The chefs truly do a fantastic job creating tasty and quality dishes, and the array of options on the menu makes for a unique experience every time. Lynn was a wonderful manager to work for, and a wonderful hostess to my family whenever we've dined, always treating us with kindness and respect. She truly cares about all of her customers and employees, and you can really feel that with how delicious the food is!10/10 recommend!“

3.9 Good71 Reviews
Loading...
map Map