8 Best American Restaurants near Elkhart Lake

“Any and every thing tastes excellent here! Love this place and the staff especially! Jim and Ann“

“Visited there this Friday afternoon, had bloodys and perch dinners, couldn't be better! Everything was so good! Very Impressed!!“

“First timers last night as we won a gift certificate and it did not disappoint! Excellent menu, amazing food and service! Will definitely be back!“

“Authentic. This is the real deal for lodging in Elkhart Lake. You can go old style in the historic lodge or the new building filled with all the amenities that you might need. Great location - near downtown restaurants and right across the road from its own private beach on the lake. Great bar/restaurant on property and the service is brilliantly, undeniably Midwest nice. Historic, authentic, and perfect in all the right ways.“

“The food that we got (hummus plate and salad) was really good! I was disappointed, though, that the online menu didn’t match the menu in restaurant. As a vegetarian, I was really counting on the mushroom flatbread being available and it was not so we skipped entrees and stuck to appetizers.

Good service, though, and they were running a 25 cent beer deal!“

“Amazing food for a diner/bar style restaurant! Good portion sizes, homemade chips tasted not burnt, and the hard left burger was to die for. You have to go up to the bar to order food (didn’t realize at first), but staff was very friendly.

Parking: Not much parking besides a couple street spots. There’s parking for the hotel on the street as well so it was a little tricky finding a spot.“

“The grilled Wedge salad was absolutely Delish!!!!!!!! I'm already wanting another. Add the cornbread!!!“

“we Do Not recommend this resteraunt. We had reservations last night at 6:00pm, we had planned to eat before a 730pm show at the hotel. We arrived 15 min early and were seated almost immediately. Our waitress brought water and took our drink order and appetizer order. When she returned with drinks she then took our food order. All was good and she checked back with us periodically. The appetizer took forever to get but with a busy evening we were understanding. We ordered more drinks and waited, and waited. By 7:00pm we still did not have our meal, we finally asked for the bread that other tables were given and she immediately brought them. She said our food should be up soon while we saw other tables seated after us getting their meals. At about 730pm she came back with food, but it was not ours. Our show started at 7:30 pm. we finally called the host over and explained we had not gotten our meal and we were now late for a show we had paid for. We settled up for our drinks and appetizers and left without our meal. We do not believe it was our waitresses fault she was very apologetic, but nobody else said a word or even tried to explain why after 1 hour and 45 minutes they could not provide the meals we ordered, we will not go back, very dissappinted.“