25 Best American Restaurants near Kiel

“This is the best place for the best food, service, and apmerspire for everyone! You must try this place. So easy to get to. An easy drive, you can't miss it!“

“Great food . Wonderful people.“

“Quite the interesting interior. Definitely takes you back in time. Was able to go up to the tower. Friend caught orbs on her pictures. Definitely spirits here. Dinner was great. Had chicken Marsala and German Potato salad. Both hot and delicious“

“Food & service was great will be back there again“

“Once again amazing food & service. My inlaws from Texas loved the place & Ethan was fantastic!!“

“Nice clean place , bar tenders where very nice!“

“Any and every thing tastes excellent here! Love this place and the staff especially! Jim and Ann“

“stopped for breakfast for the first time being in New Holstein. Excellent, hot food! Very friendly staff. We will be back!“

“They catered my wedding and a week later we are still talking about how amazing the food was! We got to keep the leftovers and those disappeared fast! We had the macaroni, twice baked mashed potatoes, marinated tenderloin and bbq chicken as our show stoppers. AMAZING!“

“Great Food/Service Vy Server Elsi L! The Best In Elkhart Lake ! Johnny V (Madison Visitor)“

“Wow… Delicious Food And AMAZING SERVICE!!! We Will Be Back Soon… 💖“

“I have a hard time rating places like this because I enjoy Wisconsin bar vibes, but it wouldn't be something everyone would enjoy. The food was amazing, Wisconsin bar grub. The hamburger was great, the sides were great, and the price was reasonable. My kids loved the food too, but they're boys with my sense of taste and they genuinely like bar grub too. If you like the Wisconsin bar feel and food, this is an easy recommendation. If you're looking for a more refined experience, best to keep driving.“

“Excellent food and service.“

“Heard so many good things about it. Husband and I were in area today thought we'd stop for a drink and a snack. Stepped into a beautiful old building, into a bar of about 10 ppl-- but no bar tender. Sat down, looked around, 2 women and a baby having food next to us, an older couple next to them and a group of women at a table top. Waited about 2-3 min a taller middle age gentleman came from a room off the bar, walked right over to group with baby. Then moved on to elder couple. Never getting anything for anyone. My husband walked down the bar looking at bottled beers. Tender asked what he wanted, my husband said looking at beers...then came back to me. We sat another 5 min while the tender walked up and down the bar never fixed a single drink. I went to the restroom, when I came back my husband had still not been served. We waited another 3-5 min waiting while the tender chatting with older couple. we got up and walked out. on our way out the door the bartender yelled HAVE A GOOD DAY! TOTAL IN INSIDE 15-20 MIN NO SERVICE, NO ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. 0 OUT OF 10. WILL NOT GO BACK.“

“The burgers are amazing! Definitely will be back when we come back to Wisconsin!!💚💛“

“The new owner is awesome! Very accommodating and nice to our local homeschool group! Great food too, highly recommend!“

“👍👍First time fish fry, certainly won't be the last! Excellent job!!!“

“I saw all the great reviews so we decided to try it for ourselves. We got there at 5 and they were out of the ribs so I tried the brisket and my husband had the pulled pork. Both meats were covered in fat and gristle. The macaroni and cheese was a bright yellow and didn't taste like any macaroni and cheese I've ever had. Overall it was one of the worse dining experiences we've ever had.“

“theres this guy named Chris that makes this bar an experience you wont forget. Funniest guy ive ever seen!!! Bartenders are pretty friendly..I would strongly advise stopping in! Maybe have a vodka bomb!“

“I have been a regular for years and have always ordered to go. Tonight I called to place an order and you're not doing to go's. by no means am I saying people shouldn't go there they absolutely should your food is great. I've just never had this happen before in years of ordering and I definitely think it's a flaw to the business. yall missed out on a good $100 order. lol the reason for no to go's was on busy weekends you dont do togos. totally fine. but could you maybe include that in a post in the future? I'm honestly so bummed I'm missing your dinner. I'm just super autistic when it comes to eating. lbvs so I'm struggling now to figure out how to feed myself and my dad who I care for 😭😭😭 food is always awesome, workers are always great. a heads up of no to go orders would make you perfect 💜 also love your non alcoholic options for people who don't drink.“

“We got the steak sandwich, a salad, and the fish fry. All were quite good. The salad dressing is the same one Mom (also from Wisconsin) has made for the past 60+ years. Classic, old-school Wisconsin.

You order drinks and food at separate bars. Bloody Mary was an excellent choice given that I was in Wisconsin and on vacation.

You can eat on their patio, inside a screened porch, or inside. They also have some picnic tables in the grass if you have a dog with you. We didn't at this moment.

Every place in and around Siebkens is a must-try.“

“We were there yesterday and as usual, the food was spectacular! However, this time we had my sister and brother in law from Coloma with us (their first time) and they couldn't stop raving about the atmosphere, the cleanliness but most importantly, the food and the amount of it! Nobody goes home hungry, for sure! Great impression! They want to go back the next time they're visiting!“

“What a great place for me to walk into for the first time not knowing what it would be. Atmosphere was great, plenty of TVs playing sports, and some of the best wings I've ever eaten. Service was spot on all around and the locals were very friendly with me knowing that I was out of state. And.... the spotted cow beer draft was amazing as advertised!“

“we Do Not recommend this resteraunt. We had reservations last night at 6:00pm, we had planned to eat before a 730pm show at the hotel. We arrived 15 min early and were seated almost immediately. Our waitress brought water and took our drink order and appetizer order. When she returned with drinks she then took our food order. All was good and she checked back with us periodically. The appetizer took forever to get but with a busy evening we were understanding. We ordered more drinks and waited, and waited. By 7:00pm we still did not have our meal, we finally asked for the bread that other tables were given and she immediately brought them. She said our food should be up soon while we saw other tables seated after us getting their meals. At about 730pm she came back with food, but it was not ours. Our show started at 7:30 pm. we finally called the host over and explained we had not gotten our meal and we were now late for a show we had paid for. We settled up for our drinks and appetizers and left without our meal. We do not believe it was our waitresses fault she was very apologetic, but nobody else said a word or even tried to explain why after 1 hour and 45 minutes they could not provide the meals we ordered, we will not go back, very dissappinted.“

“food was very good and service was great!“