18 Best American Restaurants near Palmyra

“Great service, great food!!“

“We made an impromptu stop here while leaving a campground. The food was good and the prices were pretty fantastic. Melissa was our sever and she was extremely patient and kind to our children. She kept drinks filled (which is one of the main things I watch for) and made sure we had everything we needed through our meal.“

“On Friday, I arrived right when they opened at 4pm. There was a little crowd, and I was pleasantly surprised to see that there was a couple who arrived on horseback and tied up to the hitching post. (Yes, Nite Cap still has a hitching post for their guests!) You place your order upon entering and then head to the bar to grab a drink and wait for your table to be ready. When they call your name, you get seated at your table to enjoy your family style, all-you-can-eat fish fry.? The fish was amazing! It completely lived up to the hype. I was surprised that it wasn’t a beer-batter, but the batter was still nice and crisp. The famous potato pancakes were also delicious! They weren’t greasy and had crispy edges and soft centers. I understand why the recipe has held the test of time! The meal also came with tartar, coleslaw, applesauce, and bread.?? Highly recommend a visit to Nite Cap Inn!“

“The staff is very polite and very friendly and helpful, would advise going there .“

“Great drinks, and great people. !“

“been going to Squids 2 for quit a long time my sense was 25 im 45 now use to be me and my uncle and sometimes parents now it's just me and wife go on Friday. Love all you can eat Fish on Friday with buffet and there homemade Tatar sauce, me and family use to go all around to all you can eat fish frys been to at least 10 all you can eat places in this neck of the woods and I want to say honestly for price and quality it's one of better places to get all you can eat fish. I enjoy a pitch of spotted cow with me fish here..“

“Always a good time and the food is great“

“Our new favorite place to go! Friday fish is amazing!! Best potato pancakes around. Friendly service with a ton of laughs! Can’t wait to try the broasted chicken, it looks delicious! Can’t beat $2 Tallboys either. I highly recommend this place!“

“I've gotten food from Rustix probably like 20 times, but tonight is the first time I had the shrimp and fish tacos. So good!!! Highly recommend!“

“First time hereJenny was amazing and professional gave me recommendations...came here after an event and when we saw chocolate chip pancakes we were sold ... The atmosphere based on appearance never occurred to me that this would be a grill it has that tense 1880s bar saloon vibe. All jokes aside. the menu is simple and not complicated the food is exceptional the black frog grill is quite the beaute“

“Swung in for a quick beer and bite to eat after hiking in Kettle Moraine. Everything was great!“

“Been coming for 20 years. Love the food and service!!! Clean the seating area up! Hodge podge okay, dirty no., especially in back area. Weeds and Dandelions growing through mulch, tables unwiped. Broken furniture, some furniture is needing a coat of paint.“

“Amazing fish fry, steaks are always cooked to perfection, a fully stocked salad bar (supper club style) truly amazing specials. This place is a perfect hidden gem. Service is always good.“

“Living only several miles from the Suhmer's Motel in the Town of Eagle, and the apparent very nice rustic accommodations as per the photos, me and Sally will visit for a weekend relax getaway, now that the Confederate flag has been removed from the front walkway. This is most appreciated...“

“Best evet“

“Great food and prices. Friendly staff in a cozy town staple“

“First time here. food was delicious. They were very busy and we were still able to get our food quickly. Had the fish fry. So delicious. Highly recommend this place.“

“Their Cheeseburgers and milkshakes are the BEST in southern Wisconsin !!! We drive an hour out of our way home from vacation just to get them. Don't get me started about their fries and Tots!!!“