22 Best Italian Restaurants near Pleasant Prairie

“So my husband and I visited other Olive Gardens. One in gurnee which I loved the waitress, one in racine which I was not happy with the service and our first time today in kenosha. Our waitress Cassie was so wonderful. She asked the right questions, the salad plates were cold for the salad, the food was nice and hot. But what I liked the most was when Cassie asked if we liked anything else before she brought our food out. So this will be our place from now on. Thank you Cassie for your service. I give you a 10 as a waitress“

“My husband and I stopped here on our way back home from a day to trip to Illinois - and I'm so glad we did! Amazing food and outstanding customer service. We were able to chat with the owner Cathy to learn more about the restaurant and who also made sure we felt welcome and went above and beyond. We live an hour and 30 minutes away but will definitely be back soon. So many things on the menu to try 😋“

“We recently discovered Renzo’s and have dined in a few times already. In addition to excellent food, Rosie (the owner) and her daughter are so welcoming. We feel like we are eating at a family member’s house rather than a restaurant. Being there brings back wonderful memories of Sunday dinner at my Gram’s house. Portions are very generous and everything we have tried has been excellent! Make sure you try the Renzo’s fries (they are similar to a breadstick made from pizza dough with marinara sauce for dipping), the popovers (similar to a calzone and loaded with whatever ingredients you select and topped with their delicious marinara sauce), and of course their amazing pizzas. Renzo’s has become our favorite restaurant for Italian food and we visit often. Rosie greets us with a big hug and we love taking to her about Italy and our travels there.“

“Our family has appreciated some wonderful meals at the IA. Their servers are very attentive, their food is delicious, and their bartender Caleb is the best at his trade! A message for my fellow IA members: please bring your families there to take pleasure in some of the best Italian fare you will ever enjoy!!🍝“

“We were here on Friday and the service and food were amazing. Zachery is a wonderful server and extremely knowledgeable on the food/drinks. We will be back again!“

“We decided to try this place since I’ve bought their frozen Italian beef meat and we did like it. Fresh is even better! I’m glad we did go, bread, beef, fries delicious!! A great surprise was the meat arancini - I need a case of those only!! Please freeze and sell those too, so people that are around the store can try this awesome snack!“

“Great food and service! The eggplant Parmesan was awesome!“

“Just finished an incredible Fat Tuesday/early Valentine’s dinner at Sturinos! The eggplant Parmesan was the best I’ve ever had! The eggplant was sautéed and seasoned perfectly with a nice topping of Parmesan and mozzarella. Usually the eggplant has so much breading that you hardly taste the eggplant itself. This was just perfect. My husband had the meatloaf special and loved it. The mashed red-skin potatoes were delicious and the meatloaf was flavorful and moist. Everything is homemade and fresh. One of our favorite restaurants in the area!“

“Ordered via delivery and the pizza was phenomenal. Highly recommend....support local!“

“Hard working and excellent dining experience PLUS the food is tasty 😋“

“Walked out of this place, hit with scent of drugs being used as I opened the door. No need to spend my money at an establishment who has no regard to regulations.“

“We tried Cut Stone in Kenosha last night. We started with the meatballs which were good. I would skip them and get either the bruschetta or stuffed mushrooms next time. I had the Crab Ragoon pizza made of cream cheese mixed with crab topped with mozzarella wonton strips, green onions and sweet chili sauce. It was creative and very tasty. My hubbt had a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. His was a bit floppy from all the toppings. Once it cooled off it was easier to eat a slice. The crust is more of what I'm use to which was delicious. The kind you can fold. Over all it was a bit pricy but I think it was worth it. He wishes he got a more creative pizza. We will be going back.“

“I haven’t eaten at Ferraro’s in over 30 years and I have no idea why. This pizza is amazing!!! The crust is thin and crispy, sauce is very flavorful, and the meat and cheeses are primo. I would eat here once a week if I lived here. This is take out pizza only. But the Irish pub next door is a great place to bring your pizza grab some beers and eat. Great folks at the pub.“

“We ordered Valeo’s pizza in Bloomington tonight because we had received a coupon in the mail from them. Honestly, before we received the coupon, I had no idea where they were even located. They will definitely be our go to for pizza from now on tho! Everything about the Valeo’s special pizza was excellent! The two men working tonight were both very friendly and efficient. Definitely recommend if you’re looking for a great tasting pizza!“

“Great Italian food, comfortable atmosphere“

“Best tacos in Kenosha! �“

“Great place, Awesome food and Milo loved it too.“

“Food is ALWAYS � tasty! They deliver right to our sites making it so convenient for our customers too!“

“Rosatis food and service are outstanding !!! The crew at Rosatis care about their customers so they always make sure the food they serve is something they can be proud of. If you haven't had the delicious food from Rosatis yet what are you waiting for you don't know what you're missing. My all time fav is their Monster Pizza?⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“We came in at 12:40 am. After a concert in Chicago. Our waiter was attentive even though it was taking the girls some time to decide what to eat. Food was fast hot. Perfect night cap to a concert. I think we all decided that Derangos is the spot now.“

“We do take out here quite often and like their stuffed pizza. We have been disappointed however more often than should occur when they under cook the pizza and the upper dough is not done. It’s not the cheese either. Otherwise it is always ready on time when I order online.“

“Always a great meal here!“