21 Best Italian Restaurants near Pleasant Prairie

“Buona Beef in pleasant Prairie has had a few growing pains, but our family has been faithful to keep ordering. They really turned things around for the better in the last several months. Very communicative, helpful with issues, actually made improvements to the app for ordering specific things like no salt etc. Definitely a family-oriented restaurant that listens to its consumers. Awesome!“

“My group was served by Maya, & she was fantastic. Our experience was dramatically improved by her interactions with our table-- she was considerate, attentive, & incredibly kind! We will definitely be coming back after this experience!!“

“Amazing food and service! Must try!“

“My family of seven enjoyed the atmosphere and friendly people. The pizza was superb! We also had an order of Renzo’s Fries. Everyone agreed these are amazing! My son says the texture is incredible! Renzo’s has made our “Must-Do List”. Oh, and yes, we bought three pizzas so we would have leftovers for tonight. STILL SO GOOD!!! We’ll stop in the next time we make it to Wisconsin.“

“I just have to make a statement that wrote a bad review and her name is Stephanie oberg she is not my blood but related to me through my cousin. It’s so embarrassing that you always have someone in the family that you just can’t make happy and she made a bad statement that Bread was not on the table. They were in the wrong section and rolled eyes at them And the service was bad. Do you know the funny thing is we had my and this was for a funeral for my grandmother a few months before this we had her 98th birthday, which was wonderful caleb even saying happy birthday in Italian to her. They were absolutely amazing and because a lot of my family members, including my grandfather were presidents female and males and been going there since I was young with my grandfather, and I have one of the biggest families in Kenosha, so for someone that is married to my cousin to post this bad review, it’s really hurtful, but I guess you have those kinds of people in the world that can never be happy but let me tell you this when she said to move to another section and they rolled her eyes. That was me because she was in a section that she wasn’t supposed to belong to because all the bread was nice and hot with the oil waiting over there. She open the door and went into a section. She shouldn’t be that’s why there was the door was closed so I helped with so much also because our cousin Crystal blood Cousin was waiting on us. She was wonderful and because I am comfortable with the Italian American because I’ve been there for 50 years through my family I wanted to help I bought freshwater all the time with her. There was hot bread three at every table Crystal was and Caleb and I for my grandmother and family helping the food was excellent as always and she’s gone now, but one thing I can say because that comment that she posted just really hurt me. My grandmother told me she loved the Italian American and my aunt and uncles always had great. You just get so much food that you can bring home and Nancy is an amazing cook. Nancy even came out from the kitchen to say hello to all of us while she was so busy I was even helping giving fresh water and you complain about bread that wasn’t on the table and someone rolled their eyes and you’re lying because it was me your cousin that told you you’re in the wrong section I’m helping you out, dear. Why were you over there? You had no business being there. I was trying to help my family. We’re grieving getting in the right spot on the table fresh out of the oven and I never rolled my eyes. You’re my cousin, but I’m very ashamed of you but I guess you always have that one in the family that is just never happy but I definitely know this is probably going to cause problems in my family, but I’m sticking up for the Italian American and the hard workers that work there so I’m going against my cousin because she’s lying. I love you Italian American Nancy works with you on prices even if you don’t have that much money and you want something nice she truly works with you. They have such great food. Caleb is so wonderful. He’s a wonderful bartender and even his voice he sings. He came in saying three times one in Italian Ave Maria and other songs because I asked him to to my grandmother and she cried on her birthday Crystal hard worker, but the bus boys they came constantly and got stuff off the tables I even helped and I didn’t need to I just wanted to because I love the Italian American so I’m sorry this is so long but I definitely had to say something. I’m very upset because I’m embarrassed that was my cousin. She’s not blood, but that is my cousin and I’m gonna stick up for our great Italian American society.🇮🇹❤️🙏🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹“

“Just finished an incredible Fat Tuesday/early Valentine’s dinner at Sturinos! The eggplant Parmesan was the best I’ve ever had! The eggplant was sautéed and seasoned perfectly with a nice topping of Parmesan and mozzarella. Usually the eggplant has so much breading that you hardly taste the eggplant itself. This was just perfect. My husband had the meatloaf special and loved it. The mashed red-skin potatoes were delicious and the meatloaf was flavorful and moist. Everything is homemade and fresh. One of our favorite restaurants in the area!“

“We were here on Friday and the service and food were amazing. Zachery is a wonderful server and extremely knowledgeable on the food/drinks. We will be back again!“

“Cut Stone pizza is one of my favorites in Kenosha when I want a really thin pizza & wood fired. The thin pizza they prepare allows the sauce and toppings to stand out not being overshot by bready crust. The pizza always has great taste as the cup pepperoni is really good, the sausage has good flavor, and the sauce is good with any toppings. The cheesy breadsticks have some good garlic flavors as well so I recommend grabbing some of those to pair well with your pizza. The lemon blueberry tiramisu isn’t my ultimate favorite as I like a stronger lemon flavor but I would still recommend giving it a try. The fire truck pizza oven is also one I recommend checking out as it takes things to another level. They are certainly not the cheapest in town, but it’s because the pizza is worth it based on the quality so don’t let that deter you at all….you get what you pay for and the certainly deliver on the pizza flavor!“

“Great food and service! The eggplant Parmesan was awesome!“

“I got a coupon for Valeo’s pizza, as we heard great things about this place and we really wanted to check it out! I had a great customer service experience when I called to order the pizza, and when I went to pick it up! I got the pizza home, it was delicious and everyone enjoyed it! Thank you Valeo’s!“

“Saved the Night!!!! All the guys were working under VWs for our Tinker Night...time flew by...then in a panic I call 25 mins before they closed. I said so sorry you can say no as I don't like calling right before close...THEY MADE US 8 LARGE PIZZAS IN A FLASH!!!! Saved the absolute night! Forever grateful! Pizza is beyond good too!!!! Better than the others in town with excellent Service and Slices!!!“

“Amazing I came after hours. They answered the phone. And served me. Just great genuine people. 11/10 !!“

“Enjoyed the Tuesday $4 burger special and was not disappointed! Highly recommend! Total 10/10!“

“Ordered via delivery and the pizza was phenomenal. Highly recommend....support local!“

“Food is ALWAYS � tasty! They deliver right to our sites making it so convenient for our customers too!“

“Great Italian food, comfortable atmosphere“

“I am so grateful to Rosati's Pizza of Antioch for their great food, courteous customer service, and optional delivery. With such responsive service, it's not just the food that tastes better, but the whole dining experience 'tastes' better. The food I have ordered maintains consistent quality for the price. And ordering with any special requests has been rewarding. They have brought on some great delivery people too. Kudos, Rosati's, and thanks!“

“Walked out of this place, hit with scent of drugs being used as I opened the door. No need to spend my money at an establishment who has no regard to regulations.“

“Great place, Awesome food and Milo loved it too.“

“Amazing pizza! I've actually eating here many many times over the year. The pizza is absolutely amazing. My favorite by far is the pan pizza. The pizza is nice and fluffy, really delicious crust. The business itself is on the smaller side. The parking is not great. However, the staff are very friendly and they definitely know how to perfect pizza.“

“We love rosattis, best pizza ever in Kenosha. Today however,pizza was almost raw, crust was not crispy, onions were crunchy and not enough sauce. Will take this as a bad day and hope it’s not a sign of things to come!“