The Mill Supper Club
$$ • Family, American, German
Hours:
4128 State Highway 42, WI-57, Sturgeon Bay
(920) 743-5044
About The Mill Supper Club
Customers' Favorites
The Mill Supper Club Reviews
Share your opinion about The Mill Supper Club
Excellent food and service for our group on a busy Sat., Oct 25th-2025. We had 2 long tables and our server did a great job, food was delicious. Thank you Cory! Your server needs a thank you!!
After going to the Mill for 20 years as a family tradition,celebrating August Birthdays, we are VERY disappointed. The food was horrible and we all got sick immediately after the meal. Please bring back to family style meal nights and good quality food.
We had dinner Saturday night, started out at the bar with cocktails, the bartender was fabulous for our big group, then to our table for our meal, the salad bar was excellent, wine at the table, everyone’s meal was perfect. I had scallops and they were cooked perfectly. Our waitress was wonderful,very helpful as we brought in a cake for a birthday. Then back to the bar for after dinner drinks. We had a great time and we will be back . Highly recommend !
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4 - 8PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 8PM |
People in Sturgeon Bay Also Viewed
.jpg)
The Mill Supper Club is a well-loved spot in Egg Harbor that serves up delicious dishes. Their Friday fish fry, featuring perch, remains a standout, paired with perfect fries and a tasty wild rice chicken soup. The restaurant makes many items in-house, including ranch dressing, which adds to the freshness and flavor of their offerings. The kid-friendly menu is a bonus for families. The supper club also provides a cozy atmosphere, with a friendly bartender and great service. Recent reviews mention the delicious deviled eggs and the lemon risotto, which is perfect for lemon lovers. Diners praise the top-notch food, amazing bartenders and servers, and the nostalgic yet modern feel of the establishment. While some found the salad bar basic and certain dishes too salty, the overall experience remains positive, with the "Supper Club" atmosphere and excellent service enhancing the visit.