“The taco supreme pizza is always fantastic here. The other food is good here, too, but I find the taco pizza is the signature item. Have been coming for years. The staff is always friendly and accommodating at well! They have one large back room for parties. They have a small games area for kids. It likely will be at capacity if several families with kids are there, though. Little gem on the east side of Green Bay!Vegetarian options: It is pizza, so make it how you want it. They will customize dishes upon request.Dietary restrictions: They have gluten-free options for pizza, too. They are limited, though.Parking: Parking on both sides of the building.Kid-friendliness: They have kids' games with tickets to get prizes. Could be bigger, but adequate.Wheelchair accessibility: No steps and kind staff to help with seating.“
“OH MY WORD!! One of THE BEST dishes I've ever had! Traveled to many places across the country and this place, just WOW!! Everything we've tried is delicious and made from the heart. Fresh, authentic, ABSOLUTE COMFORT FOOD! Had the honor of meeting the chef amd owners, such genuine passionate people. Folks, you NEED TO EXPERIENCE THIS PLACE!!“
“I decided to stop by this place for lunch since I was visiting the city and saw some good reviews from previous customers. I ordered the Italian beef sandwich and I was not disappointed. It was full of beef and smothered in cheese with a side of au jus. There was seating inside and I was the only customer at the time. The owner was working behind the counter and was very professional and polite. I will be stopping by here again next time I'm in town and will have to try the pizza.“
“We drove past this place when we were house hunting in August and decided not to stop because it was too busy-- big mistake! Big! Huge! It's taken us 6 months to finally try it and we will not go to a chain Italian restaurant again! The ambiance was great; son in law kept saying it felt very "homey". Service was great as well. Interacted with probably 5 different people all of whom were friendly. The food-- SOOO Good! Being our first time here, we tried a variety of items; House Special pizza, Spicy Garlic Marinara pasta and Pesto pasta, as well as brownie cheesecake dessert. NOTHING disappointed! The meatballs on the marinara dish were very flavorful, pasta cooked just right. Same with the pesto pasta-- picky son in law even liked the chicken! My pizza snob husband and daughter were super impressed with the pizza; thin crust with no lack of flavor! We will definitely be back soon!“
“Our table tried several dishes. The Meatballs & Linguine, the Chicken Marsala & the Agnolotti. We also had the Roasted Cauliflower and Mushroom Risotto sides. Everything was fresh, well presented & delicious. We will definitely go back!“
“Definitely had a neighborhood following. Customer flow was steady. Staff made you feel comfortable; like you were a "regular". ? My breakfast was tasty, but greasier than I would prefer. My husband enjoyed his breakfast with no complaints. We enjoyed the staff. ?“
“Our favorite Italian spot in green bay because you can taste and feel the authenticity as soon as you walk in. The staff is personable and knowledge about the entire menu. They will go the extra mile to make sure you enjoy every aspect of your experience with them.“
“We came in on the evening on 3/15 with apx 45 parents and youth wrestlers. I believe her name was Mary at the counter. She was AMAZING!!! She moved us through as quickly as possible for a group our size. Food came out fast and HOT. We are so thankful to all the staff for their hard work and excellent service. They were kind and everyone of them served with a smile!“
“Cranky Pat's Pizzeria (Green Bay) appears to be a local cult following restaurant that everyone should try. In my opinion, it joins Stuc's Pizza (Appleton), Faye's Pizza (Sheboygan), Firehouse Pizza (Sheboygan Falls), and Jim's Place (Slinger) that locals seem to love.From the time we placed our order till the pizza arrived was like 1 hour and 45 minutes. My suggestion would be to call ahead or just enjoy the wait. We each ordered a slice of pizza which is the size of a small pizza and tried the salad/soup bar which was very good. They also offer free premade small ice cream sundaes for customers that dine in.Observations:1) Fun watching these towering pizza's get made and placed in the oven. They certainly don't skimp on any fresh mushrooms for those people that love them.2) Across from the bathroom doors is an employee only glass door which you can watch the pizza oven's mechanical components operating.3) Very large staff works inside Cranky Pat's (Green Bay)My four star review is based solely on wait time. I would encourage others reading this review to give them a try.“
“Great pizza and garlic knots. We were there for lunch & couldn't have had better service. The pizza had lots of cheese & toppings. We definitely left full. The restaurant itself was clean but outdated. Think of any late 90's Italian restaurant with red faux leather chairs & checkered table clothes.“
“Nice place to eat food is decent size, and staff was very attentive to my child. The temperature inside was way too cold for me and my child so we ate what we could then enjoyed our food at home. Overall, it was a great place to dine. Just bring a sweater just in case.“
“Hello!!! I just wanted to take the time to inform you and your management team about our experience at the west side location. We arrived with a party of 15 on Saturday 1/20/24, we were seated immediately and made to feel very comfortable. I would like to express my sincere gratitude to your business but more importantly your staff!!! Our party was not easy to handle. Kids and adults and everyone ordered different items from the menu. That being said your staff rose to the challenge and handled it very well and with amazing professionalism!!! I couldn’t be happier with the service and the food! As we were celebrating my mother’s first birthday without our father …Thank you all so much!!! Everything was great the food was great!! More importantly your staff was amazing!!! Please make sure you give everyone on Saturday’s staff a HUGE round of applause and a pat on the back!!!! Thank you all again so much!!! Tony“
“I love this pizza! The hand tossed classic brings me back to when I was younger and Godfathers was my favorite. Delivery is good but you need to eat this pizza hot to experience it true deliciousness! Melty stretchy cheese,best Italian sausage, sauce is fantastic,perfect amount of veggies! Do yourself a favor and order here!“