Bagels Restaurants near Wauwatosa, WI

“Stopped into Bruegger's Bagels while I was in the area and decided to try something new.

I ordered the Hot Pastrami, I am so glad I did. Great balance, and the everything bagel added the right bite.

The team was efficient and friendly from start to finish. My order came out quickly and everything felt smooth, even with a steady flow of customers.

I will be back next time I'm the area.“

“great food, first time there today. it's like a hidden spot I never knew about on the Eastside. On shift now I know where to grab a quick bagel . I will definitely be back.“

“Ruby’s locations offer the exact same excellent service and delicious bagels!“

“Allie Boys delivers excellence every time. Their bagels are delicious, and everything is made fresh. I always check the specials, because while the classic sandwiches will have you craving them (like the veggie delight with razor-thin sliced veggies) the limited time items will have you dreaming of them well after they go away (like the fried kefir lime bagel with toasted coconut cream cheese, a sticky rice patty and sliced fresh mango).“

“This location delivered a solid overall experience with room to elevate. The dining area was generally clean, and the staff presented themselves as polite and professional. Customer service was responsive—when tomatoes were mistakenly added to my order despite a clear request for none, the issue was corrected quickly and without attitude. That kind of accountability matters.

The food itself was good—well-prepared, satisfying, and consistent with brand expectations. I would return based on flavor alone.

That said, execution separates good from great. Drink service lagged noticeably, which disrupted the flow of the meal. While there were no heavily soiled tables, some surfaces had crumbs and should have been wiped down more proactively. Even during slower moments, clean tables are part of the presentation. Ambience is silent marketing.

One key observation: the young lady preparing our food stepped away from the line to handle another task and returned without changing gloves. In today’s climate, guests are highly aware of sanitation standards. Glove changes aren’t optional—they’re visual reassurance.

Overall, this was a good experience with strong potential. Tighten up drink timing, reinforce glove protocol, and stay sharp on table maintenance, and this location can easily move from good to standout. Fair critique. Respect where it’s due.“

“nice service“

“I think Stone Creek has amazing food and coffee. However their prices are quite frankly ridiculously high. It costs almost 22$ for a coffee and a waffle in my experience. The staff are extremely friendly and there’s a nice outside window for anyone with an animal. I just cannot justify giving 5 stars for what can be assumed as price gouging“

“Ruby’s locations offer the exact same excellent service and delicious bagels!“

“The food & service is so good I’m a regular they know by name now. And I wouldn’t be a regular if one of those were average or subpar. The staff is always warm and welcoming as soon as you walk in the door and the quickness and efficiency in which they work and get orders through is impressive. Highly recommend this location.“

“Friendly service as well!!“

“I love this location, everyone is always really nice and it doesn't take long to for them to remember your name and what you like to order when you come in. It can get busy, but that's to be expected, it's the only bagel shop in bay. I've never waited longer than 10 minutes, even when it's slammed. I'll keep coming back every weekend!“

“If you’re in downtown Milwaukee and want a reliable, friendly coffee stop with plenty of drink options and food to accompany, Biggby Red Arrow Park is a solid choice. Staff are energetic, attentive, and friendly.“