Custom Cakes near West Allis, WI

Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
2935 South 108th Street, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
Apple Pie a La Cold Stone - Freezer
Create Your Own Ice Cream Cake
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
Oreo Overload
Oreos

“Great service great people the girls that work here are awesome and are the reason I keep coming back. They are polite and exceptional at what they do. I have one suggestion and that’s to put butterscotch as an optional topping. Otherwise thank you for your consistency on the service and attitude.“

3.1 Average225 Reviews
Joney Cafe Cafe • $
Shaker House Building, 17700 West Capitol Drive Suite 20, Suite 3, Brookfield - 8.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Empanadas with Dipping Sauce
Beef and Cheese Empanadas
Traditional Chilean Soup
Completo Chilean Hot Dog
Americano Sandwich
1000 Layer Cake
1 000 Layer Cake
Chilean Donut
Italiano
Caprese

“I recommend a visit to the Barn. I opened a new shop April 3rd of 2024 a month before the makers mart event in May of this year. What a wonderful opportunity for my new business to get introduced. It’s been a wonderful experience so far and my neighbors have been very welcoming. My new business is called MoeChic the barn shops which is located in the barn on the grounds of Stone wood Village. I’m so excited to be here and I’m loving it. Come visit the shop and meet myself and my greeter, Buddy who is my lovable Burnedoodle. The shop includes a gallery area with unique handmade items created by local artists. Another area is set up as a boutique with women’s clothing, handmade from a several countries purchase through fair trade, a shoe line and many accessories and jewelry. All handmade, artistic and cultural in fashion. And of course the upper level is layed out with vintage, re-purpose an upcycled items mixed with vintage and current artwork. Come visit and see what treasures you can find here.“

4.9 Superb126 Reviews
Tiffany’s Dessert Bar Bakery • $
460 W Silver Spring Dr, Glendale - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesecake Jar

“Tiffany’s treats are not only delicious and beautiful but the team is always thoughtful and efficient! They always get me the exact right special treat just in time. Tiffany is my go to dessert expert in Milwaukee. ❤️🎂🧁“

5 Superb44 Reviews
The Cake Lady Bakery • $$$
3561 South Kinnickinnic Avenue, Saint Francis - 6.96 miles

“Our wedding cake and cupcakes were absolutely incredible! Not only was it beautiful and exactly what we had envisioned, but it tasted even better than we could have imagined. Every detail was so thoughtfully done, and the cake looked absolutely perfect on our wedding day. We were able to have multiple flavors, which for people who do like sweets is amazing to have a variety.

Our guests couldn’t stop talking about how delicious it was. We are so grateful for the time, care, and creativity that went into making our cake so special. It was the perfect addition to our celebration, and we couldn’t recommend them more!“

4.8 Superb60 Reviews
Cakes by Caryn Bakery • $$
1505 S Coachlight Dr, New Berlin - 5.5 miles

“Belated review…Caryn made chocolate cupcakes for my daughter’s 3rd/4th grade birthday treat. All the kids LOVED them!! And they looked so pretty! Healthy and food allergy friendly was a plus too 😍“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Greige Pâtisserie Bakery • $$
408 West Florida Street, Milwaukee - 4.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

White Chocolate Cheesecake
Opera Cake and Macarons
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Black Tie Torte
Wedding Cake
Cookie Bag
Pastries
Cookies
Bakery
Bars

“We used the Greige Patisserie for our November 2023 wedding in Oconomowoc, WI. They did our personal cutting cake and dessert bar. We mainly communicated with Miranda, who was very responsive, professional and helpful. The dessert tasting appointment was really fun to try out some of the more popular treats. They delivered and set-up all the desserts on wedding day and it looked perfect. The cake was absolutely beautiful and exactly like the inspo pictures we shared. The dessert bar was a hit and we had multiple guests talking about how good all the treats were all weekend. We had s’mores shooters, strawberry shortcake shooters, lemon bars, salted caramel tarts, snickerdoodle cookies and macarons. We would definitely recommend the Greige Patisserie to future couples. Thank you!!“

4.7 Superb122 Reviews
La Nueva Bakery Bakery • $
500 West Lincoln Avenue, Milwaukee - 4.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rebanada de Tres Leches Tres Leches Cake Slice
Jamón Y Queso Ham And Cheese
Sandwich de Jamon Y Queso
Tamales Pollo Y Puerco
Sandwich De Pernil
Sandwich Criollo
Sandwich Cubano
Cubano Cuban
Pernil Pork

“Lo mejores sándwich de todo Milwaukee se lo recomiendo no se van arrepentir“

4.6 Superb41 Reviews
Babes Ice Cream & Dessert Ice Cream Shop • $
2264 South Kinnickinnic Avenue, Milwaukee - 5.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Best Brownie Sundae Ever
Mint Avalanche Ice Cream
Vegan Flavors
Banana Split
Waffle Cone
Hot Fudge

“Ice cream is the best thing ever!!!!“

4.5 Superb190 Reviews
Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $$
203 N Broadway, Milwaukee - 5.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Freshly Baked Waffle Cone in a Ben \u0026 Jerry's Ice Cream Shop
Array of Ben \u0026 Jerry's Freshly Baked Waffle Cones
Berry Berry Extraordinary Sorbet
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Coffee Coffee Buzzbuzzbuzz
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Milk \u0026 Cookies
Impretzively Fudged
Chocolate Therapy
Hot Fudge Sundae

“Awesome ice cream, friendly staff and a beautiful shop!! Love this place!!“

4.2 Good92 Reviews

Taste More Cuisines In West Allis