Lost Key Tap Restaurant
$$ • Salad, Burgers, New American Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Lost Key Tap Restaurant
Customers' Favorites
BERR Battered Walleye Dinner
Macadamia Nut Crusted Walleye
Brussels Sprouts Appetizer
Parmesan Crusted Walleye
Macadamia Crusted Walleye
Seasonal Salad
Grilled Salmon
Grilled Chicken
Salmon Cakes
Filet Mignon
Lost Key Tap Restaurant Reviews
I went there last night. The bar is very big and cozy, with great staff! I had the filet and risotto, both were incredible- I went with chef Kurt’s recommendation- glad I did! You can also buy the kitchen staff a drink- great idea! Danny , the owner was there also- great people!! Danny explained some of the vintage whiskey he had there- great knowledge!! Be back there forsure!!
5 stars to Lost Key Tap! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with outstanding service, fantastic cocktails, and a menu that truly delivers. The appetizers were incredible, calamari, bone marrow, ahi tuna, and Brussels sprouts, all packed with flavor and beautifully presented.
For entrées, we enjoyed the salmon, walleye, pork chops, and risotto, and every dish was absolutely delicious. The presentation was just as impressive as the taste.
What really...read full review
For entrées, we enjoyed the salmon, walleye, pork chops, and risotto, and every dish was absolutely delicious. The presentation was just as impressive as the taste.
What really...read full review
A hidden gem close tucked between Green Bay and Appleton. Worth the short detour for the amazing food!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:30 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4:30 - 9PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Lost Key Tap Restaurant offers a memorable dining experience with a welcoming atmosphere and exceptional food. Guests are greeted with top-tier service from friendly hosts and waitresses. The atmosphere is outstanding, creating a perfect setting for a quiet night out or special occasions. The restaurant features a beautiful, large bar area where guests can enjoy drinks and even eat if they cannot get a reservation.
The menu includes a variety of dishes that impress diners. Highlights include the burger with truffle fries, walleye, risotto, salmon, and gnocchi, all beautifully presented and delicious. The arepa starter is highly recommended, with the curtido being tender and perfectly balanced in flavor. The meat is smoky and tender, with a crispy masa outside that complements the filling. Other popular choices include the Beet Salad, NY Strip, and desserts, which add to the overall positive experience. The Colombian Arepas, Ahi Tuna, and feature cheesecake are tremendous, with made in house flavors. The flour less chocolate cake is so good.
Live music with acoustic guitar adds to the enjoyable atmosphere. Although some items like the bolognese may differ from expectations, the overall quality and service make Lost Key Tap Restaurant a hidden gem worth visiting. It is a great place for great food, good drinks, and a very clean, inviting environment.