15 Best Italian Restaurants near Kearneysville

“Just stay away from this place. Their food is absolutely amazing, service wonderful, great people and even better food. All you transplant, self entitled people stay away because you will just mess up a perfect thing. Their food is absolutely perfect, they are beyond professional.

Fantastic 5 stars...but if you're a local you already know this.“

“Huge menu with something for everyone. I have never had a bad meal there. Take out is awesome too. I recommend them to everyone. Plus, the garlic rolls are amazing.“

“SUMMARY: Tito's is a Mexican (read: Latin American) restaurant that also makes decent pizza and great wings.

I've been to Tito's many times over the past year and have never had an issue. I prefer Tito's pizza, my wife prefers Anthony's, but we both agree that Tito's is THE place for buffalo wings.

We've only ever done take-out. I can affirm that the dining room is dark as other reviewers have mentioned. I can't speak to any service beyond counter-service, which has always been great. The staff is friendly and seems genuinely excited to sell what they see as a quality product.

I see negative reviews on the pasta, and I can't speak to those either way. I've never tried it. What I can speak to is the unexpected delight that is the "Mexican Originals" portion of the menu.

Never mind that some of the items are actually Salvadoran, Colombian, or Dominican. You're not reading this review for a geography lesson (side note: food anthropology is FASCINATING). You're here to know whether the food is worth your cash. It is.

I've tried the pupusas, special burrito, and fried yuca. It's been a minute, but I remember thinking, "I should get this again." Particularly the pupusas, which come with pickled carrots & cabbage.

The calzone and stromboli are also solid choices. They were on par with any I've had in NJ and NY.

Parking: Tito's is in a strip mall with plenty of free parking.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp from the front door into the dining room, but the turn to get from the door to the ramp is tight. The ramp is one long run with no turns.“

“We brought 5 grandkids ages 6-12 with us this evening for dinner. Two of us ordered lasagna, which was piping hot on the plates. One grandkid loved the cheese pizza and fries. One grandkid had fettuccine and another one ordered mac and cheese, which they liked. One grandkid ordered spaghetti that came out only slightly warm. Pappy ordered chicken and broccoli fettuccine, which for some reason came out way later after we were pretty much done eating and cold. We have never had problems here before as usually food and service are good here. The manager did come by and made it right by taking off the two dishes that were cold and late. The manager was following up with the district manager, who happened to be helping in the kitchen to double check the equipment they used for making the noodles to make sure it was working properly. We will still go to this restaurant as it is normally good service and food.

Kid-friendliness: They have kid friendly menus and crayons 🖍 for them.“

“I'm craving a delicious sub sandwich right now! 😋 Italian sausage sounds amazing, and meatballs are always a classic. It's great to find a place with consistently good food, no matter what you order. Choosing is always the hardest part! Guess I'll have to try both the sausage and meatball subs next time. 🤔 #SubLove #Foodie #ItalianFood“

“Great service and tasty food!“

“Great Mozz sticks! Amazing thin crust pizza as well!“

“Kings is by far the beat pizza and Italian place in the whole area. You can tell the owners care about the food that they put into their customers bellies. When I want pizza or Italian, I think of King's.

Vegetarian options: They have meatless options.

Dietary restrictions: They have always made accommodations for my Step father who I'll only eat fish as a source of protein, and they don't skimp on anything.

Parking: It's easy to park there.

Kid-friendliness: This is a family-friendly restaurant.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes.“

“great service great food and a great price highly recommend.“

“Absolutely my favorite pizza and Italian food!
Everything has excellent flavor and quality. The pizza crust is always freshly made and you can tell! I have always been very pleased with the generous portions and affordable price.
Anthony’s is my family’s go to pizza!“

“Kings was awesome to work with! We traveled from PA to WV for a baseball game. They were responsive and accommodating to our changing times and days! I would highly recommend them to anyone who needs a large order to go!“

“Food court with several options, burgers & fries, pizza, Chinese, baked goods, etc. Most everything is cooked to order, so there will be a little wait time after you order. They also have a full bar in the center. Average prices. Friendly employees.“

“Great food and friendly service. Restaurant was very clean. Kris our server was on top of everything. We will definitely go back“

“I’ve been eating here since I was 16 years old over 40 years now and it is even more special to me now since this is the last place I had lunch with my son before he passed away. I live in Florida now for over 15 years but every time I come home to visit family. I always come here sit in the same booth that Jeff and I sat at for that last lunch over 4 years ago now.“

“I love the thin crust it was very well done and tasted great not so much a fan of the tomato sauce as it was sweeter than I would like I understand many people prefer it that way but it's just not my cup of tea overall food was excellent service was outstanding nice place to go to eat“