9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sistersville

“The Fort Pizza is one of a kind! First time diner, lifetime customer. This restaurant is a throwback to a time when pizza was a whole experience instead a cardboard box of slop. It blows big chain stores outta the water like Battleship. The dough is made from scratch, the options for specialty pies is phenomenal, and the whole atmosphere is total kitsch. It is western themed with hand painted murals and copper tile painted ceilings. The staff is friendly and accommodating. If you're in the Sistersville area this is a must. It is tucked away, but worth the drive. 5 stars will return ASAP!!!“

“Excellent food and staff! Pepperoni rolls are incredibly tasty. I will definitely be back to try their other menu items.“

“I loved this place. Huge amount of cheese curds for the price of $5.99. I mean like huge. Awesome. And their HOMEMADE buttermilk ranch dressing.. It's awesome. I also had the cheese steak in pizza dough bread... Even half was plenty enough for me. In fact I'm STILL eating the leftovers. I think overall including a large sweet iced tea... it came to roughly $ 14. Which is about average price for Tyler county. Ill DEFINATELY be returning to this place. The ladies there are very sweet and friendly. Its a must STOP if you want SOMETHING good to eat. Just saying. Gotta TRY this PLACE!! You won't regret it.“

“Let’s start with this. I love pizza just about any type of pizza. I ordered from Pasco‘s and got their works medium pizza . It’s an eight slice versus their XX large, which is a 16 cut. What a value with all those toppings and it is fabulous. I really enjoyed it. You can’t go wrong getting pizza from the shop. It’s been here a while from what I understand and hopefully it’ll be here a lot longer. The last time I had it was 10 years ago and to me it hasn’t changed from what I can recall. Staff were awesome. And the atmosphere is your classic mom and Pop old-school pizza shop.“

“The best pizza in New Martinsville!“

“fantastic little spot with great friendly staff. highly recommended“

“Great pizza,great service. We will definitely continue ordering from here“

“Great pizza! The heart shape made for a nice touch ☺️“

“They have good customer service and they are vary nice and the new boss is a nice person to work for“