6 Best Italian Restaurants near Athens

“Lil Mazzara’s Italian is a local favorite for delicious, authentic Italian food and warm, welcoming service. Perfect for client dinners or casual team outings—we love supporting this amazing spot in our community!“

“Almost didn't stop because I couldn't see in but so glad we did! The staff is amazing and they have AMAZING food! My Philly cheesesteak sandwich came out and I asked where was the cheese and the young man said it's in there.....and oh boy was it! The baguette type hoagie roll held a concoction of meat, peppers and onions and this delicious, cheesy sauce....SOOOO GOOD!!! The bottom of the bread was slightly soft from the melted cheeses and the bun was light and crispy. The house calzone was HUGE! Although you may want to request extra ham but it is overloaded with ricotta, mozzarella and an awesome crust! Go in and eat now!
I also noticed people coming in for carry out pizza every few minutes.

What a hidden treasure!“

“I remember having my one of my first teen birthday dinners at Terranova's in Huntsville. It was also where I had dinner before my first prom. Later in life, at the first Athens location, I had my first date with my now husband. While we were unable to have Terranova’s cater our wedding due to their move from Huntsville to Athens, it is still a special place to me.

We always receive phenomenal service, our food is always fresh and delicious, and the decor is beautiful and unique as always. The strawberry tiramisu remains one of the best desserts I’ve ever had. While I’ve eaten at several other Italian places over the years, Terranova’s will always hold a special place in my heart.“

“Best pizza anywhere!!! Sooo gooood!!“

“Outstanding pizza! Simply the best!“

“Best pizza is Huntsville! My family and I are regular diners at the wood fire grill and the pizza is consistently AMAZING!!! We ordered pizza tonight for movie night and the kids were so excited. Jessie is a breath of fresh air. She runs the restaurant extremely well. Not only does she have strong managerial skills, but she always remembers our names and asks about our babies. ☺️ She really makes the place special.“