32 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fayetteville

“The pizza here is really good! Only have been in for lunch, but the lunch special is fantastic. If you haven’t tried this place, you should.“

“we always love our food and the atmosphere is tip top! thanks for working so hard to make the experience wonderful!“

“My fiancé & I moved to NWA in January (2024), and we’ve been having trouble finding a pizza spot that we love. Well, we found it today! A friend recommended this spot, and we love it. The food was excellent. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, and we were impressed with the size and quality for the cost! We’ll definitely be back for more. ?“

“My second time eating here had great waiter and great great service friendly people clean clean bathrooms clean clean place“

“Everything from the service to the amazing food at Marleys Pizza is well worth the visit . Thank you to Carmen and the Marleys crew for making it such a wonderful dining experience. 🍕🥰♥️“

“Seriously the best pizza I've ever had! Tried the hand tossed Meatza and the thin crust BBQ Chicken.. I will NEVER get pizza somewhere else. ALSO, the Caprese Breadsticks were amazing! Imagine a really good marinara dipping sauce that you have tried and multiple the taste by 1000 and you're maybe half way to how good theirs is.. 100% recommend giving this place a try! 🍕“

“Good food and good company are sure finds at Waystone.“

“Great service and Awesome pizza“

“Wings are great. They saved the experience. 6 in an order and the mojo sauce was good. They came out fast. Pizza is ok. Nothing to make it special. Took FOREVER to get them and there were very few people there. No drink specials on the weekend. Service was ok. Im sure there are better pizza and wing places in town. If you just want wings, they are very good, though.“

“we always love our food and the atmosphere is tip top! thanks for working so hard to make the experience wonderful!“

“The food is beyond delicious, and Joy is one of the best servers we have ever had. Make sure to get the spicy chicken alfredo or the creamy pesto spaghetti w/meatballs.“

“Great service and Awesome pizza“

“I live just around the corner from this place and have eaten here since i was a child. It's never not been good and i'll continue to eat here until it's bad. It's perfect for takeout on your way home from work for either yourself or the family and they make it extremely fast. Staff inside is always nice and helpful.“

“Pulled up at midnight with a Pappa Johns craving. The guys working this place were such a delight and hooked up with some great pizza. And at this time of night, to have such a great attitude serving pizza! What more can I ask for? Didn’t get their names, but shoutout to the dudes working tonight“

“I have ordered twice now to have food delivered and both times the order was messed up. First they forgot the sandwich sauce and the 2nd time they forgot the main item the pizza. The first time I let it go and this time I called to try and get the pizza delivered. I spoke with GM Joseph and all he did was blame it on he delivery service. I PAID YOU for my order not the delivery service and you are responsible for making sure everything is in my order. You try to act like you're doing me a favor by making a fresh pizza. Sir there is no pizza you are just now making it. At the very least you should've reimbursed me for the pizza. If I pay you for my food YOU are RESPONSIBLE to make sure I get my food and that all of the order is picked up. After reading all of the comments I should've known that you have a problem with customer service. I pray people read this and stop coming to your restaurant until it is under better management. TAKE RESPONSIBLTY AND STOP BLAMING A DELIVERY SERVICE.“

“Well we just had a super bad experience we ordered a 75.00 order and paid on the phone we pull up and had a 3.00 up charge they made Karen come and get her wallet to pay so Gusanos you just lost big customers over 3 .00 wow not good business“

“I was picking up a DoorDash order and the guy working was so incredibly friendly and nice and I’ve never smelled a supreme pizza that smelled so good. My car smells heavenly. I don’t know what you guys put in your pizza, but it smells so good.“

“We had pizza from Domino's at Crossover Rd. last night. The pizza was great and the service was excellent!!!! It is my favorite Domino's. Thank you for the brownies, so good!!!!“

“A meal swipe for an entire pepperoni pizza is the reason for obesity in America. Not complaining or anything. Eureka Pizza and the Sewage system remind me of a Prime Shaq and Kobe on the Lakers. Dynamic duo.

Kid-friendliness: They took my 5 year old son. Help me.“

“We were in town visiting. We needed to leave before we could get a pizza to my aunt in her assisted living center. I called early on the chance someone would answer-He did. The pizza was delivered as promised and it was piping hot! The delivery driver was very efficient and it blessed my aunt who is confined to bed! I’m sure we’ll order for her again. Highly recommend this business!“

“Easily ordered with the app and my pizzas were ready and waiting. There are unique and different options available here, and baking at home ensures they are so hot you have to wait to eat them - much better than bring home cooked pizza.

Vegetarian options: I ordered the gourmet vegetarian pizza with the garlic cream sauce. Very delicious!“

“went here on lunch break. store clean. friendly staff, but can we go without touching someone's food bare handed after it's been oit of the oven and have better presemtstion...maybe not use a rocker insteqd use pizza cutter.“

“Staff was very helpful and friendly. Kids had a great time.“

“Their staff and management are perfectly courteous and helpful. Hot, fresh, and delicious.“

“Those employees deserve a raise! Including the manager. The manager limping hurting still doing her job. The cooks were still pleasant taking new request 15 minutes before close. I'll say it again the night shift deserves a raise .. $1.50 hr“

“There's no other fast food pizza that offers fresh ingredients. They even offer gluten-free pizza dough. Under new management, this Marcos got out pizza quicker than expected. It was hot when we received it. The Magnifico Pizza had tons of pepperoni on it. The White Cheesy was a family favorite with tomato, 4 cheeses feta, bacon, and onions. The cheesy bread was delicious, too. It's worth the price and convenience of not having to cook. Be sure to ask about their specials.“

“Just had the new crust tonight & it is so yum. Delicious � �“

“First, for BO6 fans, use the code in your email receipt! I used the app to order. Very easy to use and was able to make my pizza exactly like I wanted. Also ordered crazy puffs which are very good. My food was ready when I got there and I was in and out in less than 5 mins. The employee at the front was very nice and helpful. I would recommend this pizza place to anyone.“

“So I was totally impressed. I was super hungry in a hurry and thought I'd try Little Ceasars. It was really good. I should have stuck with those little crazy puffs. Quite filling.

Vegetarian options: They have a veggie pizza“

“great subs! never disappoint!“

“For years I have ranted and raved about how great their pizza is. It's kinda gone down hill lately though. Not sure why. Pizza was comparable to chuck cheese and service was no good. Took forever to order, never checked up on us, then had to find a different person to help get us the bill so we could leave. Hopefully it's just a new crew and they get back to how they use to be. Still giving 4 stars just because I know how awesome they usually have been“

“They were super busy so food was a little slow! But oh my everything was delicious and worth the wait and the staff was great and always checking in with us keeping us informed! We will definitely be back . Thanks so much for our wonderful anniversary dinner“