16 Best Sandwich Shops in Fayetteville

“The food was amazing, and our server, Grace, was great. However the music inside was really unsettling, it sounded like screaming and like hammontrees was being haunted(?). Definitely was off putting and put just a bit of a damper on our experience. Otherwise everything else was amazing. Love the partnership with NWA food bank.“

“That was the best sammich I’ve ever had. Thank you!“

“We have always enjoyed this establishment, although our most recent visit did not meet the usual standard. I contacted customer service to address the issues we experienced, and I later received a return call from the owner, Melissa.

I sincerely appreciate her professionalism in listening to my concerns, offering a genuine apology, and taking steps to make things right. I understand that mistakes can occur and certain details may occasionally be overlooked, but I felt it was important to bring the situation to their attention as a learning opportunity for the staff.

Melissa’s prompt response and offer to replace the meal were greatly appreciated and reflect a strong commitment to customer satisfaction.“

“Great place to enjoy a sub“

“Great place to eat at clean bathrooms clean place friendly people“

“Never eating fast food breakfast after trying this place. Great portions and prices plus the food is made with locally sourced fresh ingredients. yumm!!“

“I had my best experience at Subway due to Josephine and Sebastian! They were both very personable! Sebastian created a personalized sauce for me based on my preferences and it was great. I have been coming here and will recommend people to come to this location.“

“great subs! never disappoint!“

“John made me a meatball sub today. He went above and beyond to make sure I was happy with my order. Wow was it delicious. The provolone cheese was melted perfectly over the meatballs. He also looked very professional and made every one of my needs met. Not to mention he is a very good looking worker. I will definitely be returning for that meat ball sub soon“

“This food was great! The people were friendly and I would totally go back!!! 😊“

“😀outstanding service hip atmosphere tasting menus“

“I frequently visit this Subway location because I work right down the street. I am always so impressed with how friendly, fast, and clean this location is. I always order using the app, and the staff remembers my order (and even remembers the flavor of cookie I get on occasion). Today, I ordered a sandwich for my boyfriend as well, who has multiple allergies, and the staff handed me my order letting me know they were extra careful in preparing the sandwich after they saw the note I put. I highly recommend this Subway over any other location in Fayetteville!“

“Spectacular Service, absolutely delicious sandwiches, Textures, and flavors are amazing. 10 years ago, I came into this very same shop and ordered a Pastrami on Black Russian Rye, with the works and cucumbers. From then on I would introduce anyone I was with to such a great mass of flavors. I return to this store 10 years later and they have pulled the rye bread out of the choices. I understand there is not much call for it with the younger generations. I compensated with sourdough which is every bit as amazing, or as I like to say, "Ahhhhmazing!" I had the opportunity to speak with an incredible and extremely professional person at the counter named Matthew. An outstanding employee to say the least. Very courteous and polite. The other gentleman in the back was a large man. He was speedy and pleasant as well as quickly accomodating as Matthew. I could not have asked for better service nor personalities. Outstanding. A pure pleasure to have met such fine people. I will gladly return. I will not wait 10 years to do so either. Thank you very much for the fine work gentlemen. Sincerely, C. Redline NRP“

“Thank you JJ's of Fayetteville for the samples. #4 Turkey is delicious!“

“I visit this subway often. So often, that the kind ladies working know my order by heart, even when the app is running special deals like bogo. The app recently removed the box that has special requests and these ladies have gone the extra mile. Even without the box, my sandwiches were both perfect and just the way I like. I am so thankful for these ladies going the extra mile even when no one asked 💖“

“The sandwiches there are awesome and what makes it great is the people they have manners like yes sir no sir. Yes ma'am. No ma'am, that is so sweet to hear these days and they are patient with your order and they have nice smiling faces“