Top NYC Restaurants for an Unforgettable New Year’s Eve Celebration

As 2025 approaches, it’s time to start planning how to close the year with a celebration to remember. New Year’s Eve isn’t just about resolutions—it’s also about indulging in one final feast. Whether you prefer a relaxed evening at home or an unforgettable night out, these top restaurants in New York City offer exceptional dining options to mark the end of 2024 in style. Here’s your guide to some of the best places to celebrate.

If you’re an early sleeper, Williamsburg’s Le Crocodile is the perfect choice. This sophisticated French restaurant at the Wythe Hotel offers a four-course menu priced at $163 per person. Available from 5-10pm, dishes include steak tartare with black truffle, winter vegetable Wellington, and lobster risotto. It’s an excellent spot to enjoy a refined meal before turning in early.

For a laid-back yet festive experience, head to The Fly in Bed-Stuy. Known for its “Tinis and Weenies” New Year’s Eve event, this spot serves up pigs in a blanket every hour and a martini toast at midnight. The $60 per person reservation is available for groups of 8-12. It’s the perfect way to celebrate with friends over chicken and cocktails in a lively setting.

Looking for a loud and lively New Year’s Eve? Gus and Marty’s in Williamsburg has you covered with a $200 prix fixe menu featuring Greek favorites like feta saganaki and crispy shrimp. The evening includes a champagne toast, a dance party, and the option to splurge on caviar service. The single 9:30pm seating promises a festive celebration to ring in 2025.

Get a classic steakhouse experience at Delmonico’s in FiDi. This iconic red meat establishment also offers a $225 prix fixe menu starting at 9pm. Dishes include Caesar salad, Maine crab cakes, creamed spinach, and their famous baked Alaska. Paired with plenty of martinis, this meal is perfect for those seeking an indulgent New Year’s Eve.

Seafood lovers should consider Cervo’s on the Lower East Side. The restaurant’s four-course Seafood Feast includes scallops, oysters on the half shell, sea urchin, and a halibut and crab stew, all for $125 per person. With seatings available throughout the night, it’s a delicious and budget-friendly option to celebrate the holiday.

For those who prefer a seated dining experience, Claud in the East Village offers a $250 multi-course menu. Available with early (6pm) or late (9pm) reservations, the menu includes wagyu short rib, chocolate bundt cake, and ample Champagne. This intimate wine bar provides a cozy yet elegant way to close out the year.

SEA in Chelsea is ideal for those who love family-style dining. For $145 per person, you can enjoy a Southeast Asian-inspired menu featuring crab curry, truffle noodles, and prime ribeye. While the restaurant closes at 11pm, it’s a fantastic spot for groups to gather and share dishes before continuing their celebrations elsewhere.

Photo Credit: instagram.com/penny_newyork/

For a more casual celebration, check out the standing-room-only New Year’s Eve party at Penny in the East Village. The seafood-focused event includes a raw bar buffet and passed snacks like lobster rolls and crab rangoon. Early bird tickets are $150, while the ball drop session is $195. It’s a great opportunity to enjoy top-notch seafood.

Smithereens, a seafood restaurant with a unique ambiance, is taking a surf-and-turf approach to New Year’s Eve. Their six-course menu includes lobster, beef sirloin, and Champagne served from magnums. Reserve the $225 second seating after 9pm to enjoy a midnight toast in this stylish East Village venue.

End the year on a jazzy note at Cecchi’s in the West Village. The $250 five-course prix fixe menu features options like crab cocktail, turtle soup, and surf and turf. Accompanied by live jazz and served in an Art Deco-inspired space, this dining experience is both elegant and lively. Late-night reservations are available for those wanting to toast the New Year in style.