New York Pizza

$$ • Pizza

665 W Tennyson Rd, Hayward
(510) 786-3165


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for New York Pizza

We called for delivery 1 mile away. Pizza arrived cold, greasy and disgusting!!We gave driver $11. Tip because we didn’t have change. I called five minutes after delivery telling them the pizza was cold and greasy. They argued with me for 15 minutes and called me a liar!! So RUDE!!! I couldn’t even eat one piece, GROSS COLD AND GREASY! ?I wouldn’t feed their pizza to a dog!!

STOP EATING HERE!!! The worst pizza ever I have been tried. The stingy owner used expired products and low quality. The staff are very unprofessional and not taking hygiene seriously. I waited for my pick up and noticed staff going back && forth to restroom and without washing their hands preparing the orders. Absolutely the worst family business you can find different age of inexperienced staffs and with bad taste ever.....

Their Pizza really is amazing!! Customer service is also excellent. DoorDash made an error and they adjusted my order at no charge which is very uncommon, normally I'm referred to DoorDash for the error when calling the restaurant and then I end up screwed. Thanks for the great service and quality pizza. (I never take the time to do reviews)

More Reviews(121)


Monday 10AM - 11PM
Tuesday 10AM - 11PM
Wednesday 10AM - 11PM
Thursday 10AM - 11PM
Friday 10AM - 12AM
Saturday 10AM - 12AM
Sunday 10AM - 11PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.