New York Pizza

$$ • Pizza

665 W Tennyson Rd, Hayward
(510) 786-3165


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for New York Pizza

Halaal New York style pizza?? I never knew we had that in the Bay Area! The pizza here was really good, the service was amazing. I was worried that the meat would be too salty, but I was proven wrong. I got the King Kong size which served my family of 6 perfectly. Will be back here every time I can!

I called in to place order on Valentine day, I ask guy on phone if he could make into heartshape pizza he said they dont but they would cut it into hearthshape pizza. I grabbed pizza and was round. Clearly they didnt follow instructions or lied to me. Ruined my valentine day :(

I've just about had it with incompetent people in the Bay Area. I called in and ordered a pizza here and specifically asked for a heart shaped pizza due to vday. The guy took about no more than 5 minutes to get the order and stated it would be ready in less than 20 minutes. Went down there, picked it up, came back home and opened the box and it was a regular round pizza. Yea on a normal day that would have been fine but I specifically started heart shaped. Not to mentioned full review

More Reviews(151)


Monday 10AM - 11PM
Tuesday 10AM - 11PM
Wednesday 10AM - 11PM
Thursday 10AM - 11PM
Friday 10AM - 12AM
Saturday 10AM - 12AM
Sunday 10AM - 11PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.