The Cookie Plug

Name: The Cookie Plug
Address: 6193 Jarvis Ave, Newark, California, 94560, US
Telephone: (510) 894-1320
Rating: 3.6

Bakery

Hours:
6193 Jarvis Ave, Newark
(510) 894-1320

Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery

take-out

The Cookie Plug Reviews

3.6 (42)

Write a review

February 2024

I have hear about this place forever and seen it all over the socials and was super excited to hear that we were going to get one in the bay area!! so I finally got to check them out after some time. I thought I would go crazy and get each flavor but I did so great and got just a handful of them my first try. The staff was super nice and friendly, and was able to help answer all the questions I had for each flavor since it was my first visit. I ended up getting the smores, strawberry...read full review

February 2024

Super friendly staff upon entering, and they were more than helpful explaining what they have and prices (not posted). The decor fits in well with the theme. I would have liked to see some seating though, but I'm sure they can get away with fewer staff and trash accumulation with a bare bones crew so it's understandable. I can't say if they're always this way, but the cookies are definitely on the gooey side, fairly bulky, and ~$5 each as of 2/1/24. We tried 4 varieties: Snickerdoodle,...read full review

January 2024

I actually liked this place a lot more than I thought I did! The interior is filled with nicely graffiti-ed walls of art that you can tell is inspired by the Bay Area. The place itself isn't super big but the lack of furniture kind of made the shop appear bigger than it is. There were a large variety of cookies and they even have pup cookies! I got one for my dog and decided to also try the red velvet and the s'mores cookies. They were super thick and each one could almost count...read full review

More Reviews(42)