The Cookie Plug
CLOSED
About The Cookie Plug
The Cookie Plug Reviews
23 ratings
Cookies hit the spot. Great store front!
It took me four visits to the Cookie Plug in order to develop this review– each visit was as harrowing as the last, but the fourth drove me away. While the cookies were amazing, the ambience was what frightened me. Each time that I attended this humble cookie joint, there was different staff present, but one manager always present. The manager was an older man, with clear signs of aging on his face and hands. Each rotating staff member always had a monotone voice and seemed...read full review
You know you wanna be my girl
The Cookie Plug is a delightful bakery that offers an array of delicious cookies. The atmosphere is described as "very welcoming," with a 7-year-old customer being in "awe" of the cool pictures and paintings on the walls. The staff is praised for being friendly and helpful, explaining the menu options and prices.
The cookies are the star of the show, with reviewers describing them as "YYYUM" and "delicious." The cookies are noted to be on the "gooey side, fairly bulky, and ~$5 each," with flavors like Snickerdoodle, Cookies and cream, chocolate chip/walnut, and S'mores. Customers can request them to be warmed up if they prefer a warm cookie.
Reviewers mention that the cookies are "balanced without being overly sweet," and they offer a variety of sizes, including "Plug Poppers" which are mini cookies. The interior is described as "very cool," and the service is generally praised, although some customers wish for more seating and amenities like napkins and utensils.
Overall, The Cookie Plug seems to be a fantastic bakery that offers a welcoming atmosphere and a wide variety of high-quality, delicious cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.