10 Best Bakeries in Newark

“Best pié ever especially the caramel apple and the key lime also the chocolate and the pocket pies ( my personal favorite is the chicken pot pie ((not the one with bacon)) I give this pie place 5 stars!! Go early or you will find them sold out for the day!!“

“Visited here in may 2026 later in the afternoon and she was stocked up on all the Samoan staples you would expect in a Samoan suppa (plate). We pretty much got one of everything on the menu and they were all delicious. Being from Australia and Polynesian it was interesting to try out how American polys take on Samoan dishes and I can safely say this place was on point! Standouts for me were the sapa sui, the bbq mamoe (lamb) and the oka ia (raw fish). Service was also great Juanita was friendly, warm and welcoming. Great job 👍🏾“

“This place was SO GOOD! We just moved here and I’ll definitely be back. The bakery was amazing (and very fresh, not dry, just everything you want a piece of bakery to be but often isn’t). The coffee is good, the staff is very friendly and helpful, and major bonus points for being open early.“

“👍 Highly recommended My whole family loves it🥰 definitely will order again“

“I didn’t get want anything from the bakery at the moment since I had a pastry early morning, but I decided to give this place a try and try one of their milk teas. Milk Tea is alright, but some Ube didn’t blend in with the drink.

It seems like that the place is still renovating since there are no TVs turned on and that there are rarely any decorations. Some stuff I’m seeing should be put at the backend. I also saw pictures of a large grey teddy bear sitting on the chair, which is quite nice.

I’ll max this rating up for four stars at the time being since I didn’t get anything from the bakery. I’m hoping that this place improves soon. Also, some items I see from online such as cakes are not displayed at the display boxes. Perhaps, they are sold out? Remains a mystery at the moment.“

“A wonderful pasty store I found accidentally. I got chicken dumplings and beef and onions stuffed pancakes from the frozen section to make at home. They also have ready made food you can enjoy immediately.
If you have any questions, don’t be afraid to ask. The place is very friendly.“

“We couldn’t believe this super delicious cakes had was actually eggless!

It was my son’s birthday, and since he has an egg allergy, I was looking for a bakery that offered eggless cakes and came across Amia Bakery. We decided to give it a try and ordered a 6-inch raspberry chocolate cake.

We were honestly so impressed. The chocolate cake was soft, moist, and delicious, and the whipped cream was light and just the right amount of sweet without being too rich. Everyone at the party loved it and kept saying how good it was.

The staff were also very friendly and helpful. I asked if they could make the cake less sweet, and they were able to accommodate my request, which I really appreciated.

We’re so happy we found Amia Bakery. It’s not easy to find a great eggless cake, and this one exceeded our expectations. We’ll definitely be ordering from them again!“

“All items are very yummy & staff are really nice…“

“I've been here plenty of times for the delicious mexican pastries(pan dulce) but never tried the food from the restaurant before. Today I tried the birria de chivo with homemade tortillas. So delicious! I will definitely be back more often for the birria again and plan to also try other menu items. The service was excellent as well.“

“I ordered a cake from this shop for my daughter’s birthday and had such a great experience. The staff was incredibly kind and helpful throughout the process. The cake turned out beautiful—exactly what I wanted—and it tasted amazing. Everyone at the party loved it. I’m so happy with everything and will definitely order again!”“