New York New York Sandwiches
$ • Sandwich Shops, Bagels, VegetarianAbout New York New York Sandwiches
Customers' Favorites
Egg on a Bagel with Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese
Pastrami Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito
Breakfast Bagel
Egg and Cheese
Reuben
Chips
Recent Reviews
157 ratings
Share your opinion about New York New York Sandwiches
Born and raised New Yorker here visiting for a wedding, I love this spot! Jim is a very friendly dude, very old school New Yorker with old school New Yorker sandwiches and they’re extremely well made, they also have a taste of Palo Alto in them, with the fresh ingredients and native water being used.
Amazing service and food. This is my go-to breakfast spot before heading to the train station for my daily commutes. Generous and kind owner, and a great little hole in the wall spot. I highly recommend getting an egg and cheese on a bagel, or the Jumbo Hot Dog for its generous portion!
okay look, this is delicious. it's a little old place, it definitely gives old corner deli aka yea it's not the cleanest place in the world but the old man is making the Sammiches, I got the pastrami with cheese hot so it cost a little extra and then I got a cold corned beef with cheese for my husband, I ate mine before I got home and I was pleasantly surprised, it made my mouth water I devoured it in 2 minutes no breaks bahahahahah, skip the line at sweet maple and come here,...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Tuesday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 6AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 2PM |
New York New York Sandwiches is a charming place known for its fantastic sandwiches and more. The staff is very friendly, and the food offers a variety of options including fresh juice, coffee, and beers. Vegetarian choices are available, such as the vegetarian cheesesteak, falafel in a pita wrap, roasted portobello mushroom sandwich, and buffalo mozzarella sandwich, all priced at $15 each. The NY genuine pastrami sandwich is also a popular choice. Customers appreciate the cozy atmosphere and the quality of the food, which justifies the slightly higher prices. The owner’s friendly attitude makes it a great spot to support local business and impress visitors. Recent reviews highlight the welcoming service, especially noting the generous portions of lox on the NYC bagels and the overall positive experience. The small shop is conveniently located on university, just after Starbucks, and offers a nice variety of tasty options worth trying, even if some find the prices a bit higher than other places nearby.