28 Best Pizza Restaurants near Plumas Lake

“Great place for a quick and satisfying meal. The pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor, with a perfectly baked crust. The staff was friendly, and the service was fast. A reliable spot when you’re craving delicious pizza and a comfortable dining experience.“

“We stopped in after a long day at the lake. The food was amazing and the service was even better. They were so loving and kind to my 3 yr old. I just can’t say enough good things. I’m excited we live right around the corner!“

“friendly staff, tasty treats“

“Pizza Guys on Lincoln Ave in Yuba City is the only place we order from! Their Pepperoni Pizza, Artichoke Fiesta, Boneless Chicken, and Pesto Chicken Pasta are among our favorites. Every order is taken respectfully and patiently even when we're not sure what to choose. Delivery is always fast and arrives within the time they indicated. The food comes hot, well-package, and deliver right to our door. We're very happy with their service!“

“Dropped off Hank the Go-Getter at old Charlie Weavers spread so he batten down the hatchs afore winter hits, as Charlie would say. But...We had to stop at the Pop's U-Bake Pizza for one of those world famous pizzas! It was outa the way, but well worth the extra effort. Pop's U-Bake Pizza is every bit a 5 star experience! ☆☆☆☆☆“

“If you’re in the Yuba City area and haven’t tried Celestino's Pizza, let me save you some time — just go. 🍕 We ordered two pizzas — one giant regular crust, and one gluten-free — and both were absolute perfection. The crust was cooked just right: crisp on the bottom, soft on the inside, and not too thick or too thin. That magical “just right” balance. The toppings? Loaded. Not skimpy. Not scattered. LOADED. Every bite had melty, gooey cheese and generous toppings that made it completely worth every calorie. And let’s talk about that gluten-free crust — because sometimes that can be hit or miss — but this one? Nailed it. Same crisp bottom, same cheesy goodness, same satisfying bite. This is officially our new favorite place to indulge in a calorie-consuming, totally-worth-it pizza night. Honestly, my life is better with this pizza in it. If loving this pizza is wrong, I don’t want to be right. 😄🍕“

“This is my 1st time here and Victoria and her staff are great. The food was so delicious and the atmosphere was exactly what I needed after a difficult day!! This is my new favorite spot“

“I had the all meat pizza made to order, garlic fries, a salad with their specialty ranch dressing, and a drink. I also dipped my pizza in it. Very good comfort food. You could have beer, but I chose a fountain drink. They have TV screens showing cable news. You can ask to watch sports, like the World Cup and they will accommodate. There is a party room. It's family owned and usually students from Wheatland that work there.“

“We had Chicago Pizza for the first time tonight. We have been missing out! We enjoyed a half cheese/half pepperoni for the kids and a butter chicken pizza for ourselves. Ingredients were fresh, pizza was hot, flavor was outstanding, and the crust was perfect! The owners and employees are super friendly. Look forward to supporting this business for years to come!! Support this local business!“

“Great pizza and love the Dynamite bread sticks. So good!“

“Thank you, Dancing Tomato Caffé, for such an easy and enjoyable collaboration. We’re looking forward to working with you again soon!“

“We ALWAYS love our experiences at Papa Murphy's! The woman- I don't know her name- but she is always there, always smiling, always friendly and ALWAYS professional! This store is usually where we go because the store is always clean, the food is always good, and the prices are still reasonable.“

“Best pizza and even better service.

I work in EMS and had ordered food before getting sent out on a call. By the time I was done, the restaurant had closed. Instead of canceling it, Bryan went out of his way to bring the pizza to the hospital to make sure I still got it.

That kind of service is rare and genuinely appreciated after a long shift.

Pizza was great — hot, fresh, and exactly what I needed.

I’ll definitely be ordering from them again.“

“Great pizza and even better service! Was hosting a large gathering in town and was looking to find a place that I could order ahead. After some bad vibes calling some local competitors I gave Sylvio's a call and their customer service was great! (Note if you're ordering more than 10 pizzas you may need to call in instead of doing it all on their website). The manager Steve hooked me up for my 12 XL pizza order and even gave me an unprompted discount. The pizza was amazing, they put the sauce all the way to the edge and fold the edges up so it almost seems like stuffed crust pizza (without being the obnoxious kind some places make that ooze out the sides). The sourdough crust was amazing!! The Home Run special is my personal favorite if you like meat but we had some vegetarian eaters in our group that loved the Healthy Harvest and even the cheese pizza. Super awesome place, please give them a try over the chain pizza places in the area. I haven't been to the physical location but the service from there and delivery were fantastic. My new favorite pizza place in Yuba City!“

“Can’t say enough good things about this place. The atmosphere and service are great. One of the few restaurants in yuba city that still feel small town and personal. We came in for a graduation party and they were kind enough to let us decorate our table and the waitress even helped us. The food and drinks are amazing as well, I highly recommend the spicy artichoke dip! 10/10“

“Like any good teenage mutant ninja turtle, we eat here at least 4 times a week for lunch. Cant beat the price, and the pizza is great. Best crust/ sauce combo ive had“

“Best Pizza! Jim and his staff are great and also every knowledgeable on their ingredients and pizzas offered. They also have a few new varieties.“

“The absolute cutest cakepops. Hello Kitty. Kuromi even super heros. They are so good. Definitely stop by and get yourself ine.“

“Fun venue for girls night out“

“Went in ordered a pizza this last Sunday and was trying to ask some questions in regard to kinds of pizza and the deals and this lady with the Torie I believe was so rude and out of line it's like if you don't want to work at round table then don't because know this I will never step foot back into this round table because of her“

“This location works hard to keep the pizza fresh, warm and tasty! My only complaint is that it takes awhile to go through the drive thru sometimes...which is generally how I pick up my pizzas for the convenience of not having to carry out of the store.“

“We’ve been going to a different pizza place for years, but since they were closed, we tried Pizza Guys for the first time. We were really impressed with the quality of the pepperoni pizza and cheesy garlic bread. It was a good meal for a decent price, and we will definitely be trying different menu items in the near future.“

“I absolutely demolished my food that I got at Domino's Pizza in Yuba city California. This was my first time ever trying there sandwiches and wings and may I say I was not disappointed at all, I ordered the Chicken bacon ranch sandwich, as well as the plain boneless chicken wings and for desert I ordered chocolate lava cake. That entire Meal was absolutely so good 1000% recommend“

“We order pizza every couple weeks! it is always consistently perfect! everyone that we cone in contact with while ordering and delivering are so so nice! Love this place!“

“This franchise is amazing! They care so much about how their company is perceived by customers. They ask how my day was. They gave me friendly updates. I go here often have never had a bad experience. They maintain a clean environment while not slowing production and their location is lakeside so it’s a task with different weather but year round they seem to be prepared. Wish I had posted this sooner.“

“Working very good and fast👍“

“place has a medium selection of arcade games.
laser tag arena dark, but not to the extend that you would hurt yourself, but the damp floors in it would.
mini gold course fun.
certain spots make good nostalgic photos.
restaurant usually not open due to the few people running it.
fun piano in the corner.
note: the go karts are gasoline powered and need in-person consent forms to be signed due to that fact. i'm pretty sure it is the same with axe-throwing. not the gasoline powered part, but the consent forms.“

“Had a pair of dogs, dined on the patio. Was just cool enough to do this. Ordered a patty to split between the dogs, got some water for them. Food was as expected, the steak salad was particularly stand out. They were out of some of the wines on the menu, the beer was cold. Menu prices are pretty California, little surprise these days. Overall, has a good time, will likely be back.“