Tony Baloney's
$ • Italian, Sandwich ShopsAbout Tony Baloney's
Customers' Favorites
Spaghetti & Meatballs with Cheese Bread
Pepper Steak Sandwich with Grilled Onions
Ravioli and Meatball
Salami and Cheese
Italian Cold Cut
Hot Sandwiches
Two Meatballs
Chicken Melt
Italian Sub
Green Salad
Tony Baloney's Reviews
Best steak subs I've ever had. Anytime I'm in the area or have an excuse to go to the area, that's where I go for lunch or dinner.
One of the best meatballs sandwiches
Local hole in the wall serving submarines, spaghetti, and pizza since 1963. Somehow it’s stayed relatively under the radar and is primarily a locals spot.
I ordered a large pepper steak sandwich. It’s their signature menu item. Absolutely delicious. Served hot with generous potions of steak and tomatoes with great pepper seasoning. Bread is soft with slight crisp on outside. Served with a bottle of Louisiana hot pepper sauce, which pairs great. You can add cheese...read full review
I ordered a large pepper steak sandwich. It’s their signature menu item. Absolutely delicious. Served hot with generous potions of steak and tomatoes with great pepper seasoning. Bread is soft with slight crisp on outside. Served with a bottle of Louisiana hot pepper sauce, which pairs great. You can add cheese...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 7PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 6PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Tony Baloney's, a local hole in the wall serving submarines, spaghetti, and pizza since 1963, offers a nostalgic old town vibe. The restaurant has a family-friendly, down to earth environment with friendly staff, where a customer has worked for 19 years. Known for their signature pepper-steak sandwiches and scratch-made cannolis, the menu also includes meatball subs, pizza, and spaghetti. Customers recommend the pepper steak sandwich with some of the Carolina sauce on it, which is served hot with generous portions of steak, and the hot pastrami sub. The sub rolls are soft with slight crisp on outside, topped with diced tomatoes, onions, and relish. Many customers have visited for decades and praise the restaurant's warm, home-style atmosphere. The pepper steak sandwich remains a favorite, just as it was many years ago, offering a taste of nostalgia. Despite some recent visitors mentioning they just discovered it, others have been coming since childhood. Be sure to bring cash, as they charge for card transactions. Tony Baloney's has truly become a beloved spot for both regulars and newcomers alike.