Prince Street Pizza

$ • Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian

Hours today·

About Prince Street Pizza

Prince Street Pizza is a beloved local spot known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious pizza. Upon entering, guests are greeted by the wonderful aroma of freshly baked pies. The menu offers many options, with standout recommendations including the Naughty Pie, featuring spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, and ricotta, the Sunset, known for its sweet tomato sauce and generous cheese, and the Spicy Spring. The crusts are remarkably light, thick yet airy, and not heavy at all, ensuring something for everyone.

Customers appreciate the friendly and attentive staff, who provide excellent service and create a warm, homey vibe. The ambiance, historic walls, and retro look are loved, and visitors commend the quality of the food, noting that it stands out from typical neighborhood pizza places, especially praising the white cheese pizzas. Desserts like cheesecake and giant chocolate chunk cookies add to the delightful experience, often accompanied by generous extras from the staff.

While some find the pizza slightly sweet or under-seasoned at times, the overall consensus is that Prince Street Pizza delivers great taste and value, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. With quick service and a welcoming environment, diners often leave eager to return.

Menu

Add a Menu
Prince Street Pizza Menu
Prince Street Pizza Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Prince Street Pizza
Prince Street Pizza
View All Photos

Prince Street Pizza Reviews

4.3
138 ratings
5
80%
4
3%
3
1%
2
5%
1
11%
Food
4.5
Atmosphere
4.5
Service
4.6

Share your opinion about Prince Street Pizza

Felt compelled to write a review because the food was superb and the service was even better. The ambiance, the historic walls, and the retro look, love it. The manager Leonard even hooked me up with a hat after I asked him about how the dough is made. My wife and I really enjoyed ending date night here. Oh and a free HUGE cookie we got if you sign up for their rewards
The pizza is amazing! The hours are perfect and PATRICK IS AWESOME!! He’s so good working with all the customers that come in! Pure energy and personality. Just like New York!
Great pizza. Really friendly staff.

Read All Reviews(138)

Hours

Monday 11AM - 11PM
Tuesday 11AM - 11PM
Wednesday 11AM - 11PM
Thursday 11AM - 11PM
Friday 11AM - 1AM
Saturday 11AM - 1AM
Sunday 10AM - 11PM
Updated on: