14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Castle Rock

“We just had a fantastic lunch at The Old North End, the owner waited on us and we enjoyed every minute of it. The Calzones are huge and delicious! We had the fried mushroom starter, loved them. I highly recommend this restaurant and the staff!“

“Very good pizza, a little,pricey, but good. Great service and staff! Worth it 😋“

“Pro's: 1. Fast service from ordering online, our fresh pie and (mildly) hot wings finished when quoted. 2. The hot wings were freshly made with a surprisingly ? perfect spice if you have any acid reflex (you should be able to handle it just fine). 3. Fast and friendly service up until ppu when I already had paid online...then see below. 4. Absolutely delightful pizza pie, there's was no grease. 5 stars for taste. I wish they offered an extra large and more chewy center pie. It was ? delicious! Con's: 1. It would have been 5 stars if the cashier hadn't looked at me with judgment on what I tipped. It really down graded my experience since I was a first time customer here. Idk if I should bother returning if it's just greed looking at the numbers. It was disrespectful.“

“Fabulous dinner! Staff was so on point and fun! Our server Angelina was wonderful loved all the suggestions!!! We will be back. Booked our next reservation! PS - Holiday is the best at Scileppi’s!“

“Thank you Kimber for always having a smile on your face and giving the best service. The food and service was great!“

“Great pizza and wings! Great service!“

“We love this place for bigger family gatherings because everyone can eat what they prefer and everyone pays for their own meal, (no issues with splitting the bill with family).
The thicker crust pizza was good for a change. We all sit outside on the covered porch and the kids can run around in the adjacent plaza while the adults visit. It makes it a lot easier to spend a longer time as a big family since the kids are outside and able to move around.“

“We had a ladies’ brunch here and the drinks were fantastic, wait staff top notch and friendly, and the food delicious. This isn’t the Irish coffee talking but it was yummy. We will definitely go there again. Try it out for yourself!“

“I have had many orders here and they are inconsistent at best. Sometimes the crust seems old. My last visit our pizza crust was so thin that it burned but the rest wasn’t even cooked.Now all that being this time our pizza was perfect. They cooked beautifully and tasted great. If this is the new normal we will be back.“

“We love the food and the service. We eat here a lot. A few times, something has been missing from our to-go order and they go above and beyond to fix the mistake. Chris, the manager, is awesome has been wonderful to us. Definitely recommend for some yummy food!“

“Had the best pizzas we have ever had in our life! When I called Anthony’s Pizza to tell them how fantastic it was she told me they have a new chef on Friday, Saturday & Sunday. His name is Gerardo and I’m telling you they were the best pizza’s we have ever had. We’ve been to New York, Chicago and San Francisco and none of them make better pizza than Gerardo at Anthony’s in Castle Pines, Colorado.“

“Yes. It is a Little Caesars. Yes. It is just take out. But the crew was kind, hard working and communicative. While I waited for my order, everyone I saw walked out with a smile. My food was finished faster than the commitment they made to me and it was tasty. What else could you ask for??“

“y there,

I just wanted to share a really wonderful experience I had with a guy from Domino’s in Castle Rock, Colorado. His name was Ramaj, and honestly, he did such an excellent job that I really felt like I needed to let someone know. He was so thoughtful, and you could tell he genuinely cared about making everything perfect. I think he definitely deserves a shot at a manager role or some kind of promotion because he really stands out.“

“Almost every Wednesday night I order a pizza from this location on my way home and Evan is always there working. He has such a wonderful attitude and friendly demeanor. Not to mention he always makes my pizza to perfection!! Evan needs to be promoted to a regional trainer. I order Domino's very frequently from several locations and this is always the best!“