Paradise Pizzeria & Ice Creamery
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$ •
About Paradise Pizzeria & Ice Creamery
Recent Reviews
Probably the best small
Town pizzeria experience I’ve ever had. Service, food quality, from server to management blew me away in every aspect. Definitely a do not miss location for an absolute dining experience.
Amazing staff, great pizza - flavorful and crispy crust. Vibes are always on point and great to hang with friends or family. I read Nelson Greene's review and he's on the money.
The food took forever to come, and was decent when it finally arrived. It had ok flavor. The servers were always nowhere to be found, and when asked to bring something, they would always forget. The extra wings we ordered never arrived, so we ended up canceling the order. I recommend going to a pizza place outside this resort if you're looking for great pizza and service.
Paradise Pizzeria & Ice Creamery offers friendly service, despite some inconsistencies in food quality. The pizza is often described as "bad" or "bellow average," though some visitors find the pizza, especially the supreme pizza, to be "perfection." The restaurant also serves good salad and boneless options, which are praised by customers. The atmosphere could benefit from renovation, with one reviewer mentioning a 1970s vibe. Food at the base of the mountain is generally considered pretty good, with the pizza tasting fresh and flavorful, though a bit oilier than some prefer. The staff are "super nice" and the restaurant features a nice patio. Parking can be challenging, with one customer comparing the lot to purgatory resort. Overall, the restaurant remains a popular spot for visitors, with some appreciating its table service and friendly atmosphere.