19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Greeley

Fonta's Pizza Restaurant Pizza • $
2400 8th Ave, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Custom Gyro Meat and Feta
Sausage and Mushrooms
Meatball Sandwich
Mozzarella Sticks
Meat Lovers Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Jalapeno Popper
American Pizza
The Med Pizza

“I am 68 years old, a Colorado Greeley native. I have been eating at Fanta since high school when it was downtown. I love bringing new friends who moved to Greeley into the restaurant. They are always impressed and love the pizza! Best ever Pizza in Greeley!!“

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
Blackjack Pizza & Salads Pizza Delivery • $
3810 W 10th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Caesar Salad
Build Your Own Pizza
Garlic Buffalo Sauce
Traditional Wings
Pepperoni Passion
Pepperoni Pizza
Honey Sriracha
Hawaiian Pizza
Cheese Bread
Breadsticks

“November 23rd, we ordered 3 pizzas & breadsticks around 10 pm, after a great Elvis tribute concert at UCCC. We picked up the food at the 16th Street store, got home, and started eating our Jackpot, Hawaiian & Pepperoni pizzas. It was the absolute best pizza we've had in years! My family has bought pizzas from this location since the late 80s and have NEVER been disappointed.“

4.3 Superb62 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza • $
4365 Centerplace Dr Suite 300, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Meat Pizza with Pineapple and Pesto Sauce
Dillon James 11 Inch Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Unlimited Toppings
No Name Cake
DIY Pizza
Mad Dog
Caspian
Salads

“First time visiting this mod. The interaction I had with the person making my pizza was very wholesome. I especially loved all of the drawings posted on the wall and I love how open this mod is. Customer service is excellent and my pizza was delicious 😋“

4.2 Good51 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
6628 W 10th St Suite A, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Chicago-Style Stuffed Pizza Baking Required
Create Your Own Crustless Keto Friendly
Papa's All Meat Pizza Baking Required
Pepperoni & Mozzarella Calzone
Scratch-Made 5-Cheese Bread
Herb Chicken Mediterranean
Chicken Bacon Artichoke
Cheesy Pepperoni Pizza
Murphy's Combo Pizza
5 Meat Stuffed Pizza

“Great Location, employees were friendly and service was fast. They have a crustless option for any of you KETO folks out there. I do miss the free cookie dough option after taking a survey though lol :)
Try the Gourmet Chicken & Garlic...you'll thank me later! Big Murphy Stuffed or the Cowboy are also solid choices.“

4.1 Good69 Reviews
Pinocchios Incredible Italian Italian • $$
905 16th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Carrot Cake with Lemon Cream Cheese Frosting
Our Signature Carbonara
Best of Both Worlds
Angelhair Pomodoro
Fettucini Alfredo
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Chicken Parmesana
Pinocchio Sticks
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Ravioli

“What an amazing evening we had at Pinocchio Prime! We celebrated my husband’s 60th surprise birthday dinner there, and everything was absolutely perfect. Annie, Cecil, Forest, and the entire staff were outstanding — their service was truly above and beyond. The prime rib was the best we’ve ever had — you simply can’t find it any better! We had such a wonderful time and are so grateful for your incredible hospitality. Thank you for making it a night to remember!“

4.6 Superb83 Reviews
Santeramo's Pizza House and Italian Food Italian • $
1229 10th Ave, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Green Pepper Calzone
Baked Manicotti & Baked Chicken Alfredo
Side of Santeramo's Signature Sauce
Baked Chicken Parmesan w Alfredo
Santeramo's Meat Lasagna
Half Order Italian Nacho
Tortellini with Sausage
Pepperoni Cheese Bread
Lasagna with Sausage
Baked Shrimp Alfredo

“I gave a dinner here for my extended family of eleven (age 2 months to 97 years) in their private dining room. Everything was perfect. The handsome room had a large round table so everybody could talk and have eye contact with everyone else. Our server was a sharp pleasant college student. We served nachos to everyone, best I've ever had. My lasagna was delicious. I think everyone enjoyed what they ordered. The prices for the food and drinks were fair and reasonable so the bill didn't break my bank. I'd never been to Santeramos before. I just picked them from their website. I thank them for a perfect evening.“

4.4 Superb107 Reviews
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Pizza • $
2349 W 29th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Chicken Wings Tall
Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls
BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
Farmer's Daughter Pizza
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Italian Grinder Pizza
Parmesan Garlic Fries
Buffalo Chicken Rolls
Chicken Carbonara
Chicago 7 Calzone

“Stopped in today mid afternoon. A party of about 20 of us. One waitress did everything and she was SUPER. She did a great job. Food was warm, drinks were cold, and she was sporting a smile the whole time. Hope to be back next time we're in the area.“

3.7 Good127 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $$
2309 Greeley Mall, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

A Topping to Your Large Pizza for 2
Chuck E Cheese Meal
Unicorn Churros
Cakes
X

“Akanes 3 birthday she loves coming and playing with his big brother“

3.8 Good51 Reviews
Bravos Philly's & Pizza Greek • $
1635 8th Ave, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Single Cheeseburger Combo
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Gyro with Tzatziki Sauce
Bacon Cheese Burger XL
Beer and Buffalo Wings
Greek Gyro with Fries
Traditional Gyro Pita
Double Cheeseburger
Philly Cheese Steak

“The best gyros, pitas are pillow soft. Fries are perfect. The young man at the counter is so sweet and friendly.“

4.3 Superb79 Reviews
Blackjack Pizza & Salads Pizza Delivery • $
814 16th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Giant Calzone I Know Right
Large Specialty Pizza
Crazy Hawaiian Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
Fresh Made Salads
Traditional Wings
Pizza Meat Lovers
Pepperoni Passion
Pepperoni Pizza
Calzone with

“November 23rd, we ordered 3 pizzas & breadsticks around 10 pm, after a great Elvis tribute concert at UCCC. We picked up the food at the 16th Street store, got home, and started eating our Jackpot, Hawaiian & Pepperoni pizzas. It was the absolute best pizza we've had in years! My family has bought pizzas from this location since the late 80s and have NEVER been disappointed.“

3.6 Good73 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
2000 35th Ave, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Medium Build Your Own Pizza
Pepperoni Magnifico
Meat Lovers Pizza
All Meat Pizza
Pepperoni Melt
Deluxe Pizza
Deluxe

“In town and stuck in a hotel. After several calls to every competitor they were the only establishment that accepted cash for delivery. The woman that answered the phone was a super sweetheart. Very helpful and knowledgeable about the menu. I ordered the deluxe calzone. DELICIOUS! Thank you. I will be back and I will order feom you.“

3.6 Good66 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
4731 W 10th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Extra Large New York Style Pizza
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
Bacon Cheddar Cheesesticks
Double Cheeseburger Pizza
3 Topping NY Style Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cinna Pull Apart
8 Cookie Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Pizzas Wings

“Food and service was excellent 🏆 I didnt have a chance to actually go to the store I got mine delivered. Phone ordering was good no issues my order was delivered on time driver had no issues finding my address. Much cheaper to order over the phone than by website.“

3.6 Good38 Reviews
Pizza Hut Express Pizza • $
4400 Centerplace Dr, Greeley

“My Altis Tek son loves pizza Hut pizza“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Donatos Pizza Pizza • $$
4514 Centerplace Dr, Greeley
3.5 Good4 Reviews
Bulldog Pub & Grub Bar & Grill • $
1815 65th Ave, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

The Meatlovers Paradise Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Ultimate Club Sandwich
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Cinnamon Breadsticks
The Bulldog Pizza
Pepperoni Madness
Reuben Sandwich
Italian Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza

“Bulldog refers to the nickname of the nearby Highschool. So depending on the day or time be ready for a bunch of young people! Their decor is pretty much Star Wars and Marvel Comic. Several life size characters. Lots to look at!

Dietary restrictions: I assume you only have to ask but since we are lucky enough not to have any issues I can't really say.

Kid-friendliness: Older kids love it. Not sure there have been small children there on any of our visits

Wheelchair accessibility: Flat lot, ground floor entrance. Seems maneuvering a wheelchair might be a bit tough but pretty sure the staff would find a way to accommodate you.“

4 Good77 Reviews
Roma West Pizza • $
5750 W 10th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Cheese Bread
Side of Dressing
Meatball Sliders
Pepperoni Pizza
Family Salad
Garlic Toast
Small Pizza
Calzone
Lasagna

“I absolutely LOVE everything about this place from the food, the workers and the beautiful atmosphere!! I came into dine yesterday afternoon and haven’t forgot about the savory flavors that entered my mouth. Roma west is definitely a place I will always recommend!! If you’re looking for an AMAZING Italian restaurant, this is the place for you.🍕🍕“

3.4 Good52 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $$
11701 W 24th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Pizza

“Jessica Saint is always a pleasure to see whenever we order papa John’s.. I know that if she is working I will get my pizza or whatever I order fast and it will be hot and fresh.. I hope EVERYONE who orders from this papa John’s gets to meet this amazing girl she’s so nice and friendly!!“

3 Average4 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
2412 8th Ave, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Deluxe Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Lava Cake
Pretzel

“best pizza ever!! they have amazing customer service <3“

3.3 Good40 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
3521 W 10th St, Greeley

Customers` Favorites

Spinach and Roasted Peppers
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“Today is May 24, 2025 - after getting a price of $37.80 from the store just south of this one about 3 miles we decided not to get those two medium pizzas because it was too high. We then called the store and spoke with Wesley, who is an amazing person. In the end, the same thing here was only $24.06. It’s amazing to me that there’s a $13 difference from stores that are only 5 miles apart.
If you’re reading this, you’re probably wondering if you should go here or not and the answer is definitely yes
The bench is very comfortable inside and my son wanted to sleep there even ha ha ha he also has electric vehicle chargers on the side of the building and a real easy In-N-Out if you’re gonna do the carry out
I’ve taken pictures of the store hours and the store and I would definitely recommend this place to anyone who’s hungry and wants a fair price for a great pizza“

3.3 Good42 Reviews

You May Also Like