12 Best Bakeries in Pueblo

1 Sweet Ella's Bakery

4.9 Superb 173 Reviews

110 South Union Avenue, Pueblo

• Take-Out

“Clean ingredients and quality you can taste! We had a Cookcake, 2 Mini Cupcakes, and then got a Cupcake to go. The carrot cake was absolutely divine. My daughter annihilated her vanilla mini before I could even blink. My son loved the Cookcake and I thoroughly enjoyed "helping" him eat the cream cheese icing. I appreciated the smaller kids table and chairs with the bookshelf behind it - definitely a thoughtful touch! And the lemon cupcake? So refreshing. It was my son's birthday and our to-go bag had the cutest birthday sticker! Totally enjoyed. Highly recommend. Will be back.”

2 Cakes Plus

4.8 Superb 162 Reviews

524 North Main Street, Pueblo

• Delivery

“We got a gluten free, lemon/raspberry cake for a birthday party and it was amazing. One of the best cakes I have ever had!!!”

3 Crumbl

4.7 Superb 286 Reviews

1617 US-50 Ste 160, Pueblo

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Purchased cookies here for the first time! Staff was very helpful and friendly! Cookies were beyond amazing! I purchased some as a thank you and of course had to purchase some for myself! Great for a treat, and if you’re looking for a personal touch gift, why not Crumbl?”

4 Mauro Farms & Bakery

4.6 Superb 289 Reviews

936 36th Lane, Pueblo

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I can not recommend Mauro farm enough. they are the sweetest people ever. we moved from pueblo to south carolina and ordered chilis to be shipped and they were very helpful i will always recommend them.”

5 Hopscotch Bakery

4.6 Superb 232 Reviews

333 South Union Avenue Suite 3429, Pueblo

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“What an awesome local bakery! Everything we’ve tried has been fresh, delicious, and made with care. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and truly makes you feel appreciated. You can tell they take pride in what they do. We love supporting local businesses like this, and we’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend stopping in if you’re looking for amazing baked goods and great customer service! 🥐🍪”

6 Zoelsmann's Bakery & Deli

4.5 Superb 117 Reviews

912 East Abriendo Avenue, Pueblo

• Take-Out

“Went a few days ago and got 2 dozen frosted sugar cookies. It was my first time there and OMG!! BEST COOKIES EVER!!”

7 Banquet Schusters Bakery

4.4 Superb 289 Reviews

115 East Abriendo Avenue, Pueblo

• Take-Out

“good donuts, terrible customer service. They definitely made myself and my son with special needs feel uncomfortable.”

8 Little Bite of Heaven

4.2 Good 47 Reviews

138 West B Street, Pueblo

• Delivery

“AWESOME ATMOSPHERE, FANTASTIC FOOD & SUPER SERVICE!!”

9 Blazin' Bagels

4.3 Superb 79 Reviews

1706 Santa Fe Dr, Pueblo

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I go every week/biweekly at least! I love the Chicano, my fiancé always gets the turkey popper on a cheddar bagel with a cheddar cheese. He always gets the piña colada boba and I typically get an iced caramel crème latte. Today I decided to get the honeydew boba with oat milk and it is absolutely delightful. He said “now I only want that” it’s one of the things I look forward too the most!”

10 A Piece of Cake

3.8 Good 18 Reviews

4710 Eagleridge Circle Suite 230, Pueblo

• Take-Out

“My wedding cake was exactly what I envisioned and delicious! During our meeting, I showed Stephanie pictures of what I was wanting and she also had great suggestions. I just had to buy the colored ribbon and artificial flowers I wanted and take it to her. The many different options for cake tasting was also nice to know exactly how the cake would taste. I have also ordered a cake for my parents anniversary and had the same great experience. Everyone was asking where the cake was from and complemented the great taste. Definitely would recommend using them for any special occasion.”

11 Aileen's Cake Decor

4.2 Good 75 Reviews

1000 West 6th Street Suite North, Pueblo

“I want to take a moment to say a huge THANK YOU to Aileen’s Cake Decor for doing such an OUTSTANDING job on making my daughter’s 1st birthday cake! From the decor of the cake to the flavor was out of this world! AMAZING😊🍓👏🍰 I will be back that’s for sure😋”

12 Marie's

4.6 Superb 275 Reviews

297 East Joe Martinez Boulevard, Pueblo

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Absolutely love Marie she did it again and made me a wonderful cake for my mother's birthday. She did a wonderful job with my dad's Beatles cake and now she helped my mom's birthday that much better with a beautiful 50 theme.”