39 Best Pizza Restaurants near East Lyme

“What a great place, fantastic food and prices are awesome!! on a getaway trip with the hubby and we've been here twice already!!! service is A++++“

“Very good food, every time. House special pizza is great! Very good salads. Reasonable prices.“

“Ate here a few days ago! Everything was excellent! The Pomodoro Caprese Salad was good and the Veal Parmesan was excellent! Would definitely order it again! Raspberry Sorbet was amazing!!!! Staff is very friendly and wonderful! Definitely will eat here again! Great first time experience! ❤️❤️❤️“

“Highly recommend!! Best Italian food around! Waitstaff is amazing as well, which makes for an even better dining experience! You won’t be disappointed!!“

“Our family loves going to celebrate after games, report cards, etc and our son usually picks The Plum Tomato, East Lyme. Great pizza by the slice - old school pizza shop with limited dine-in seating.

Kid-friendliness: Great place for kids! Small birthday party location too“

“By far one of our favorite places to grab a pizza. Always fresh and tasty. Have also had the wings and other dishes. All have been amazing. If you have not gone - GO!“

“honestly the best pizza / Italian food I've had in a long time. Thank you for many wonderful meals this summer, and I'll see you in a few months.“

“Very clean and friendly staff“

“Not only is the food fantastic but they’re so hospitable friendly but they don’t invade when you’re eating just kind hearted people their love shows in their food please visit I try something different every time“

“The food is decent. We got a small pizza, foot long hotdog and a chicken sandwich. Pizza was good. Hotdog is a hotdog. Chicken sandwich was huge, but the waitress was older with no personality. Borderline unfriendly.
Worth a second trip if someone else waits on us.“

“Supreme Pizza has been around a long time and for good reason. They are out to please the customers. Everything is prepared well and the portions are excellent. You can get a sandwich and eat half for dinner and take the other half for lunch or you can share. Prices are about average but the quality and quantity make this one of our Go-To places to order takeout. Two thumbs up 👍👍“

“Pizza is great they are very friendly“

“I have ordered delivery from Boardwalk many, many times. I have always placed my order quickly and had friendly service. Not today! I ordered 2 dinners with appetizers and spoke with someone who seemed new. They wouldn't make one of the dinners I ordered, so I chose something else. When asked if I was paying cash or card, I said card. After some discussion with his " boss", I was told I couldn't use a credit card, cash. What?? Always use my card. Something very shady going on over there. Never again“

“Possibly the best pizza I've EVER eaten! 🍕“

“Black point pizza is always my go to when I want an absolutely amazing pizza. for me I have the cooks keep it in the oven a bit longer so it stands up when you pick it up to eat. the sauce is to die for also. if you like your pizza a little more firm just ask and the cooks are happy to make your food exactly as you like. minor the owner is a stand up guy and really did good with this recipe. the salads and his homemade balsamic dressing is the best I've had from anywhere. if you have not come out to black point you are really missing out. I promise you won't be disappointed 🍕 #gettotheoint #Blackpoint #thebestpizza #soooyummy #greatcustometservice“

“This place is a gem. A local secret. Even pizza places in Concord, mass are trying to copy this wonderful place!“

“Pizza is the best. A big thank you for supporting Closer To Free Cancer Fund Raiser Ride at Lou & Janes today“

“Had the Solis Special tonight. Fantastic!“

“The food is always good and the staff always friendly and accommodating!“

“Great food and prices fresh food.😃“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve had in southeast ct. In a high traffic area they could’ve slacked on quality- this isn’t the case at all. You can tell they take pride in the pizza.“

“Had lunch with a friend on Thursday 4/18/2024. 2 brothers reminded me of Cheers where everyone knows your name❣️ but since it was our first time not so much . The service was great,the pizza we tried was delicious and the beer which our waitress gave me a shot of to try was also tasty. Will be going back for sure.“

“fantastic food!! fantastic staff, and owners. it is the best place to stop for great food in a mom & pop restaurant Thank You guys 😎“

“Seriously the CLEANEST kitchen I have ever seen in my life … even on the most miserable hot days these guys had no food on the floor, every counter was perfectly shiny clean and they were wicked busy all day!!
Also their food is delicious!! The fries are amazing and their pizza is delicious… warning : if you say “large calzone” you need like 2-3 people to finish it!! It’s HUGE ! My favorite place to eat!! Love you guys!“

“Ate there recently and had a great meal! And our server Lisa was so sweet and the service was perfect.“

“Just ate here for the first time today. Excellent pizza. Even got $10 off for joining their rewards program. Definitely recommend 👍“

“01.03.25 Can you find Healing at The Recovery Room in the ❤️City of New London, CT❤️ This place earned two 💣💣!! My Hunger was healed and tamed at The Recovery Room Restaurant located at: 445 Ocean Ave. New London, CT ❤️ 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' Keeping it Real to Reel! ☝🏾❤️ -Big Al Mayo“

“So good � the food is so good & it’s like home made healthy quality not like fast food quality �“

“Ninos provides amazing food and customer service. We are regulars when it comes to their pizza, grinders and pasta. Last night they catered for our gender reveal party and we had assorted pizzas, a 3 foot long steak and cheese grinder, garlic knots and focaccia bread. Everything was great and our guests really enjoyed the food!“

“Real good!“

“its dominos, you go here if you want pizza late. dont be unreasonable and expect s five star gourmet authentic Italian pizza. check yourself and look at the prices. That being said, usually cooked well and made as requested, no complaints. slightly above mid.“

“Ordered a couple pizzas and enjoyed a beer at the bar while waiting. Staff was great, and the pizza is the best. Will go back often!“

“I can really only give this a four out of five cause while I do like Papa John’s, there are some things that need to be pointed out. First time I ordered them was the day after 4th of July last year and I had no problems, but I recently ordered from them on DoorDash yesterday since they were nearby my girl’s place.

I ordered a garlic stuffed crust pizza and some wings for me, and a regular stuffed crust pizza with some breadsticks for my girlfriend. She had no problems with her food, but when I took the first three slices of my garlic stuffed crust, I don’t know if it was something with the pizza or not but my stomach felt a little weird. Every time I take slices of the garlic one, I always can’t help but wash my hands afterwards, which I could give a shit less about.

I later decided to eat my wings, and while they are decently enjoyable, they need to be tossed in more sauce. I had to grab BBQ sauce from my girl’s fridge and apply it to my wings, could give a shit less about that too, and it was a bit better. But these guys gotta toss their wings in more sauce. No one wants a dry wing.

On another note, when I ordered from them at the beginning of the year, I got the Chicken Parm Bites, which were ok, and the pizza sauce that came with them had a slight sweet tang, like lemon or something, which I honestly wasn’t fond of. And I don’t know if that’s the same sauce they also give with the breadsticks or not, but come on. We don’t want a sweet sauce with the breadsticks.

Will it be my last time ordering from them again? I don’t know, but for now, this gets a 4/5. (Subscribe to Doughtoli and DoughJoe)“

“Osmino’s Grill is a gem of New London! The food is amazing, take out is always easy, the owners are the sweetest, and there is always something on the menu for everyone! Their pizza is awesome. I can’t say enough amazing things about this restaurant! 20/10 recommend!“

“Everything about them is AMAZING!…..We’re proud that they’re all called extended family!…l THANK YOU FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART FOR ALL YOU DO!“

“great food, great staff! Only pizza we ever get!“

“Easy location between New London and Waterford. Love ordering online and using pick up window. Never leave my car. Great for this busy mom. Food is always good. If not they make it fix it when I call. A+ service.“

“The food is great and my family and I go at least once a week. All so the people that work there are great to. Love that place.“

“I stayed @ Mohegan for 3 days prior to brain surgery which of course no one knows trying to relive some happy times and taking my mind off the what if’s of this upcoming ordeal.The 3 staff members Tyler , Sage and I cannot remember the other young lady's name I apologize , all helped me on different days they all are extremely kind , patient and passionate people. I asked questions about the menu because my eyesight has been effected and not knowing I’m already disabled and have this tumor their demeanor and way of handling the line of people was outstanding!All 3 of these Exceptional employees deserve recognition in today’s day and age.Please take a minute as I did to thank them personally it will make their day !!A healthy tip always helps tooCheers“