50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mystic

“Mystic Pizza has by far, some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. the staff was great and very friendly. Ask for Alex, she was wonderful.“

“went to pick up a pizza a few weekends ago. i swear to god, the guy behind the counter must have been a magician because i watch him check out FOUR different pick up orders at the same time. i had to wait a bit for my order, but they were obviously insanely busy so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ i asked counter guy his name bc i wanted to include it in this review, but i've since forgotten (maybe nick?). regardless, 11/10“

“Nice place , food is good o“

“I was staying in town and thought I'd give their pizza a try so I placed an order online, with an estimated delivery time of an hour. An hour and 10mins goes by and I call to see where my pizza is , and Erin tells me their driver isn't there anymore and they don't know what to do . they told me they'd have a manager call me the following day to make it right, which I had no issue with. I then told them I'd gladly take my pizza the following night and I'd be happy. Guess what, no phone call from the manager, no pizza delivered the following day, yet they still took my $32 via credit card. I definitely don't recommend this place unless you have lots of $$ to just toss in the wind.....“

“Absolutely hands down the BEST pizza in the area!!!!! The sourdough crust is amazing! Tried for the first time today and can't wait to return! Only downside is parking lot isn't big enough for the amount of customers they have! Hope they expand to a bigger better location one day, but don't keep it from letting you try this awesome place! There is parking in the lot next to them so it worked for me! Definitely give this a try you won't be disappointed!!!!“

“The service was great, drinks were delicious and the pork chop….perfection!“

“Have been a customer of Golden Pizza for over 20 years. It's hard to see that it's even there if you don't know it. They are great people, and the food is delicious. They always have special's on the board and great soup!“

“Would love to have ordered dinner, but can barely see the photo of the menu due to the angle. Please put a regular menu list on website…thanks“

“I got the Fish and Chips last night 09/03/2024. Everything was cooked perfectly and the portions were quite big. I usually don’t get to have seafood because I moved down south near Asheville, NC but this place made one of my favorite meals (that I don’t get to have too often anymore) perfectly even the fries were cooked perfectly. Thank you very much!!“

“Amazing people, wonderful food. They make you feel like family“

“This is our faaaaavorite pizza place! It's been providing pizza for my kids for years now and doesn't disappoint. Between the easy location and gracious staff, it's a go-to in town. If you're lucky, once in a while on a slow down, they'll give you a free sample of what they're experimenting with. I recommend anything with their homemade garlic dressing. The spud pizza is a comfort food for my family. Who knew a loaded potato with their garlic dressing would make for a good pizza?“

“Ordered delivery on a taco pizza, pepperoni pizza, onion rings and a lb. of chicken tenders. Everything was made with fresh ingredients and tasted delicious. Delivery was fast. Highly recommend!“

“Great pizza, friendly service, 2 NY Slice Pizza Slices and a drink for 8 bucks, you can't beat that. Best Pizza Around!“

“Hilltop is like going to your grandma's kitchen each time. The food is so amazing. Anytime I want some good home cooking that I don't want to cook,hilltop is where I go. The soupy pizza is one that dave portnoy would give a 10 to without question. The French onion soup is my favorite,especially on a rainy day! The staff is like family and it's always a welcoming atmosphere“

“My first time here. Walked in and was greeted by several friendly ppl. Ordered a grilled cheese with tomatoes and fries (extra crispy pls). Took my order home and proceeded to eat it. Let me tell you something- that grilled cheese was DELICIOUS. It had been made with thick bread, nice and buttery with the perfect crunch when you take a bite ? grilled
to perfection! To boot, the fries where cooked perfectly! I’m looking forward to trying out the other food!“

“The atmosphere at Village Pizza is great but the service is what keeps me coming back. The owner knows his customers by name and order, and you can tell he takes pride in his restaurant. You can find him not only at the front counter but in the kitchen as well when needed whipping up pizzas, grinders, gyros and more. I highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza!“

“Best Eggplant Grinder I have ever had. I had it on the sesame roll. I totally recommend.“

“Great eats highly recommend“

“Best pizza I have had. The staff was amazing, pizza even better. Highly recommend The Rolling Tomato.“

“Been coming here for years. The margherita pizza is my favorite. Definitely worth the hour drive ❤️“

“Pepperoni and the salad!!“

“The question is, what would I NOT recommend!!!! This is a favorite of mine and it NEVER disappoints!! Friendly staff, great atmosphere and amazing food! The complimentary shot of homemade limoncello at the end of every meal is just an added bonus! From pizza to piccata, every dish feels like you’re family!!!“

“Absolutely amazing experience! Planning a secret 80th birthday celebration for my father from 200 miles away in NJ, they made this event memorable in many ways. Jerry, Alyssa, and the whole family and staff went over the top. They provided us with a dedicated area and servers that didn’t miss a step. The texture, temperature, and seasoning of each dish were delectable and authentic. Jerry’s meatballs were all that. Cannoli’s the best we’ve had. Great ambiance, great service, and sumptuous authentic Italian food. This is easily one of, if not, the best meals we’ve ever eaten. I cannot recommend this place enough! Assolutamente favoloso!“

“We want to give a huge shout out to Solis Pizza. They graciously donated pizza for our Vacation Bible School at Anchor Baptist Church. It was delicious and so very much appreciated. Please stop in and enjoy the food.“

“Salt and pepper shakers were sticky and nasty to touch. Food is good otherwise. They need waitresses or waiters. Not the dude with a hoodie on all the time.“

“great food great customer service“

“The food was delicious and was made in a timely manner I ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and it was delicious“

“I order from College pretty regular, the food is great and consistent and the staff is out of this world. But today I ordered a cheese pizza and let me tell you it was just about perfect. Making pizza is like making eggs, if you can’t do the basics perfect, you can’t do anything. This pizza today was a masterpiece, spot on cheese to sauce ratio, crust crispy, but with a great chew and expertly cooked. If you’re looking for some crazy, California inspired pizza with truffles and gold flakes, this isn’t the place for you. But great food, done right, by a friendly staff? College Pizza is a must try.“

“Best Pizza Around Maplewood Large Servings and Ninos a Cool Dude!!“

“Excellent pizza, one of the best in town!“

“Love it! Casual, comfortable with great food and waitstaff Eggplant panini is the best ever! Hope they leave it on the menu. Seafood is always fresh and our favorites“

“Pre-ordered my 4 medium pizzas at 9 am for a 5:45 pm pickup for my mother's 80th birthday celebration. Had to wait an additional 15 minutes because they weren't ready and they said they messed up an order. Due to this, they offered to add an additional cheese pizza at no charge.
Kitchen and prep station looked clean.
Parking area is a bit tight if you have an SUV.“

“Ate there recently and had a great meal! And our server Lisa was so sweet and the service was perfect.“

“Great food, daily specials, classic Italian.“

“Ordered a couple pizzas and enjoyed a beer at the bar while waiting. Staff was great, and the pizza is the best. Will go back often!“

“Rachel was very rude and unwilling to fulfill the needs of the customer. I used to work for Dominos and always gave the best service possible to fulfill all customers needs, worst service ever.“

“Love it here, best cocktails, fun vibes. Great bartenders, family friendly, just feels good!“

“I have been stopping here since 2006 and I always have great experience! AJ makes delicious pizza!“

“Went to a party for the beginning of summer at my son and daughter-in-law’s and The Bridge Market came and made pizzas. They were fabulous, I love the Zoe Bear and Karen didn’t disappoint. All the pizzas were amazing! They must have made somewhere around 75 if not more. People didn’t have to wait long once they got going. Everyone raved about the pizzas and what a great job. I highly recommend Karen for your next activity. As my grandson said “the pizzas were made with love, that’s why they were so good.” Maryellen“

“1st time ever ordering here. Ordered a house special for take out. Order was ready when they said it would be, absolutely delicious, prices are pretty good too. Didn't eat there but appeared clean overall. Am definitely ordering again?“

“They’re plenty of good things to say about Fireside. The service, the food, even the music! Fireside easily became one of my favorite places to dine at. It’s such a beautiful establishment with amazing owners. Even the servers are amazing. The days i’ve been I was served by 2 amazing ladies. Patricia and Chloe. Extraordinary servers and their patience was amazing. Truly a great experience all around. The food is exactly what you’d want. In my opinion the crisp is the New Haven staple. Great restaurant.“

“muy deliciosas sus pizzas...especialmente la hawaiana !! saludos !! que sigan los éxitos !!“

“One of our favorite places to grab a burger or pizza! I’ve never had a bad meal, or been disappointed with the food! Great bar too“

“My husband and I live in Chesterfield VA (Rich)
Every year we come up to CT and have to come to our favorite Pizza place. I get spaghetti w extra meatballs and cheese. My husband always a grinder. The best is the rice pudding. Omgoodness the very best. We love the owner. He always has a big hug and the whole staff is wonderful. We always have a cooler full from Midway Pizza.
Bob & Tammy“

“I love watching Gordon Ramsay shows and have to try his restaurant.. I was not let down. Just the experience with the quality of the food, the service was outstanding and the atmosphere was like no other. The beef Wellington came with potato pure and it was so delicious. Seared scallops and wagyu meatballs were out of this world. I will definitely be going back.“

“Great service. Love the app.“

“I work at another café in town and come to Nana's for lattes on days that we're closed.
I have also seen the owners and their staff many times at ours - they are super kind and supportive of their neighboring businesses.

The white pizza wasn't exactly what I thought it would be but I enjoyed it and appreciated knowing that it was healthier than what I was looking for. I've enjoyed everything I've eaten here and I love that they care about organic, local and sustainable sources. If you haven't checked out the page on their website about the team's backgrounds, you should go get impressed.“

“cool comfortable. and the music is usually pretty good“

“The food is great and my family and I go at least once a week. All so the people that work there are great to. Love that place.“

“Absolutely delicious ice cream! Love this new shop in the heart of Stonington borough. The same owners from Noah’s Restaurant opened this great new business next door. Service is excellent and the menu items are creative and fun!“