Mystic Pizza
$ • Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian
Hours:
56 W Main St, Mystic
(860) 536-3700
About Mystic Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Mystic Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Mystic Pizza
Absolutely horrible people, especially the manager. Discrimination at it’s finest. You must be inbred like ALL of Fahey’s family & friends.
Sorry their pizza is not for me.
🗓️July 18, 2025-
*WRITTEN REVIEW
Big Al’s Reel Reviews EP.139
📍 Mystic Pizza 👎🏾
Downtown Mystic, CT
They made a movie about it in ‘88.
But today, I walked in as the food critic they’ve really been waiting on. 🎬🍕
Right in the heart of downtown Mystic, this spot is legendary. It was packed inside, full of energy, and the decor was absolutely beautiful. The vibe? Movie-worthy. The crowd? Out in full force.
I was greeted...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 11PM |
People in Mystic Also Viewed
Mystic Pizza offers an enjoyable culinary experience in a lovely setting with professional and kind hospitality. The menu features delicious thin crust pizzas, such as the house special pizza, and unique dishes like pickled cucumber slices fried in batter. Salads, like the one with balsamic dressing, are also refreshing and wonderful. The pizza has a good overall flavor and a nice crunch of the crust, with excellent cheese and flavorful sauce. Toppings on the small Mediterranean pizza are generous, easily feeding two people with no exposed crust. The atmosphere is fun and filled with memorabilia on the walls, highlighting its fame from the 1980s movie "Mystic Pizza." The place has plenty of space upstairs and downstairs for dining, as well as a bar and takeout counter for those who prefer to stay nearby. The service is very attentive, making the overall experience even better. With great food, a lively atmosphere, and a connection to the classic film, Mystic Pizza is a popular spot for visitors in Mystic.