Barbeque Restaurants near New Milford

“Summer 2026 Cookout Review:
For the second year in a row, Cowboy Butter catered our end-of-summer cookout, and once again, they absolutely knocked it out of the park! After they blew us away last year, we had sky-high expectations, but Nicole and her incredible staff somehow managed to raise the bar even higher.

From the impossibly tender, melt-in-your-mouth brisket to the perfectly smoked ribs and savory sides, every single dish was a massive hit with the entire team. Before long, everyone was heading back to the buffet line for seconds and thirds! Beyond the incredible food, their catering setup was seamless, professional, and completely stress-free. To top it all off, Nicole and Lisa sweetly packaged up all of the leftovers, not that there was much left! For everyone to bring home.

Cowboy Butter has firmly cemented itself as an absolute cornerstone of our town's culinary scene. If you need catering that will leave your guests talking about the food long after the party ends, look no further. We are already looking forward to next year!

Summer Cookout 2025 Review:
The aroma of wood smoke, a scent both primal and deeply comforting, isn't what you'd expect to smell at a corporate party. Yet, that's exactly what happened at our recent company event, thanks to the incredible food catered by Cowboy Butter. What began as a simple celebration quickly transformed into a culinary revelation, proving that this new spot isn't just a restaurant; it's poised to become a cornerstone of our town's culinary scene.

From the first bite, it was clear this was authentic, southern-style barbecue done with passion and precision. The brisket, the true test of any pitmaster, was a masterpiece of flavor. Each slice was impossibly tender, with a perfect, glistening smoke ring and a bark that was both peppery and crisp. The pulled pork was equally impressive, moist and flavorful, begging to be piled high on a bun with a dollop of their tangy, house-made sauce. The ribs, with their fall-off-the-bone tenderness and sweet, smoky glaze, were a crowd favorite, disappearing almost as soon as they were placed on the table.

But great BBQ is only half the story. Cowboy Butter proved they are masters of the entire feast. The sides were stellar—mac and cheese, a vibrant and crisp coleslaw, spicy creamed corn, and smoky baked beans that were a meal in themselves. The catering service was seamless and professional, from the selecting the menu to the punctuality of the delivery.

This wasn't just a great catered meal, it was a culinary experience. It's rare for a new establishment to make such a grand entrance, and based on the rave reviews from my entire team, it’s safe to say they've already won a loyal following. I have no doubt that they will soon be a go-to destination for anyone in search of truly exceptional food. Their catering was a glimpse of greatness, and I, for one, can’t wait to see what they do next.“

“The burgers and chicken are excellent. I love to mix in some of their homemade extra hot Reaper sauce into their amazing chili 🌶️. it's fantastic,I get a little sweat going, finishing with a great head buzz. and, there HOMEMADE ONION RINGS are fantastic, blowing away the lame frozen kind most all restaurants use. I love this place and the staff&cook are great. real food with a great history behind that back door. OY VAY! I GIVE THIS PLACE AN A! ❤️ +“

“Had been a while since we'd had your BBQ. Got a pound of pulled pork to go, it was excellent! A suggestion: You need more help, one person can't do it all on a Saturday evening. Kudos to the young woman who was womaning the ship.“