Bagelicious II
$ • Coffee Shops, Bagels, BakeryAbout Bagelicious II
Customers' Favorites
Ham Egg and Cheese
Nova Lox Bagel
Egg Sandwich
Sandwiches
Fresh Baked
Bagels
Bagelicious II Reviews
215 ratings
Share your opinion about Bagelicious II
They make delicious breakfast sandwiches here! I always get a sausage egg & cheese on a bagel, and they usually have salt bagels which are my favorite kind!
Sometimes it's worth the wait! The bagels are always fresh and the coffee is good. Great place for bagels! Good prices as well.
Bagelicious sells the tastiest bagels in CT!! They are delicious and they even sell them by the dozen so you can make your own at home. The quality is impossible to beat.
However, I highly recommend getting there earlier than 11am to avoid the crowds and they usually start running out of bagel options by then. Isn’t that weird since they are open until 2pm?? All the good bagels run out by 11am. After years and years of business you’d think they would have increased...read full review
However, I highly recommend getting there earlier than 11am to avoid the crowds and they usually start running out of bagel options by then. Isn’t that weird since they are open until 2pm?? All the good bagels run out by 11am. After years and years of business you’d think they would have increased...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 2PM |
Bagelicious II is a popular spot for bagel lovers. The owner and staff are known for their friendly and efficient service, but some customers have experienced slow service and mistakes with their orders. The bagels themselves are a highlight, with great flavors and a good value when buying in bulk. They also freeze well and toast up nicely. While parking is easy, the bagel-making process could be improved to reduce wait times. The bagels are made fresh on location, offering a variety of flavors that many customers consider the best in the Greater New Haven area, rivaled only by a few other local spots. Customers often find the wait long, especially during busy times, but find that the quality of the bagels makes it worth it. The staff and owner are always helpful and friendly, making the overall experience positive despite occasional delays. Some customers have noted that the building can be hot, possibly due to air conditioning issues, and there have been observations about hygiene practices, such as handling bagels with bare hands, which could be improved. Overall, Bagelicious II remains a favorite for those seeking fresh, flavorful bagels and good service.