12 Best American Restaurants in Old Saybrook

Rosemary & Sage American • $$
1080 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich with Mozzarella Crisp Fries Coleslaw
Caprese Salad with Panko Crusted Chicken
Pear Salad with Blackened Scallops
Chicken a La Paz a House Speciality
Tomato and Roasted Garlic
Cabernet Sauvignon
Blackened Salmon
Broiled Scallops
Chicken Piccata
Garlic Butter

“This is a 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ restaurant for sure from the Food which was mouth watering to the service and atmosphere a fantastic place to eat! You won't find a better steak around. I can't say enough about how pleased I was tonight with everything . Hats off to Jack and Nancy I highly recommend it“

4.5 Superb60 Reviews
Paperback Cafe American • $
210 Main St #8, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Norwegian Salmon on a Bagel with Cream Cheese Red Onion Tomato and Capers
Berry Berry French Toast
Poached Eggs Monterrey
Salvadorian Scramble
The Big Breakfast
Yogurt Parfait
Paleo Pancakes
Avocado Toast
Paleo Waffles
Hash Browns

“Always loved this place. Food and service amazing! Always stop here on my way through town.“

4.4 Superb74 Reviews
Aspen Restaurant American • $$$
2 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Bomb
New England Clam Chowder
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Side Fettucine Pasta
Warm Toffee Pudding
Lobster Bolognese
Flank Steak Meal
Pan Seared Salmon
Grilled Octopus
Crispy Calamari

“My husband and I went to Aspen the other night for our wedding anniversary. We had our rehearsal dinner there 4 years ago and were blown away by the food.. well, once again, they nailed it! It was delicious!! Not only was the food good, but our waiter, Joe M (funny, same name as my husband 😅), was wonderful! We will definitely be back again!!“

4.3 Superb121 Reviews
Little Pub Old Saybrook American • $$
1231 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

South by Southwest Egg Rolls
Pan Roasted Brussels Sprouts
Ladder Company Hot Wings
Salt and Pepper Calamari
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Little Pub Big Pretzel
Dragon Roll Burrito
Chicken and Waffles
Buffalo Cauliflower
Pulled Pork Sandwich

“Amazing service from the moment I walked through the doors. I had a table of 7 booked for my birthday meal and couldn’t have wished for better service! Food was amazing as always and the atmosphere was great! 😊 Thank you little pub!“

4.3 Superb182 Reviews
Comfort Café LLC American • $
90 Essex Rd, Old Saybrook

“The drink prices were very reasonable. There's karaoke 🎤 which is always fun to watch/listen to even if don't participate. First time visit and had a great time. Will definitely visit again when in area.“

4.1 Good14 Reviews
Liv's Oyster Bar & Restaurant Seafood • $$
166 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Cut Fries Truffle Parmesan Fries
Fava Bean Falafel Appitizer
Shrimp and Cod Curry
Pan Seared Scallops
Special Noodle Bowl
Happy Hour Calamari
Crusted Tuna Steak
Seafood Fried Rice
Eggnog Creme Brulee
Oyster of the Day

“Such great service but even more so, the chefs are incredible with their creativity and delivery of unique and delicious food. Liv's is an oasis away from home....they do so much to make dinner special every time. Thank you all.“

4.6 Superb174 Reviews
Wayback Burgers Hamburger • $
1657 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken - Craft Your Own
Kids Meal - Kids' Cheeseburger
The Nine Patty Burger
Bourbon Bacon Burger
Double Bacon Burger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Chili Cheese Fries
Single Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheese Fries
Full Cheese Fries

“Food is awesome and the staff is great! Food is cooked fresh and worth the wait! Lori is amazing!! I highly recommend!!“

4.5 Superb94 Reviews
Penny Lane Pub Pubs • $$
150 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries with a Side of Chipotle Aioli
Beer Flight Is a Great Way to Sample
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
New England Clam Chowder
Jumbo Coconut Shrimp
French Onion Soup
Penny Lane Burger
Corned Beef Hash
Steak Au Poivre
Basket of Fries

“I had the bison burger with sweet potato fries. The dipping sauce for the fries was amazing. My server Jackie was great about never letting our glasses become empty and making sure to help out with my daughter’s allergies!“

4.4 Superb139 Reviews
Otter Cove Restaurant & Bar Gastropubs • $$
99 Essex Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Seared Scallops
Cheesecake Slice of Cake
Salmon with Broccoli
Chocolate Cake
Steak Tacos
Calamari

“Had the special - Chicken Cordon bleu… didn’t expect anything amazing but it was amazing. Surprisingly, but beautifully, crispy on the outside with a slight sweet flavor. Chicken was perfectly cooked, not dry, with appropriate proportions of cheese/ham. Service was extraordinarily friendly. Topped it off with a nice Port wine and they had a decent selection available. Will be back.“

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
Jack Rabbit's Burgers, Wings and Things Fast Food • $
254 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Onion Rings French Onion Dressing
Hot Pepper Relish and Chili
Original Shack Sliders
Sweet Potato Fries
New Yorker Hot Dog
Chicken Wings
Boston Burger
French Fries
Buffalo Bill
Buffalo Wings

“great beer selection and bar food is unique and creative“

4.4 Superb40 Reviews
Fresh Salt Seafood • $$$
2 Bridge St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Sea Scallops with Risotto with Lobster and Asparagus and a Red Pepper Drizzle
Traditional Sauteed Lobster on Toasted New England Roll
Grilled Atlantic Swordfish Sandwich
Saybrook Point's Clam Chowder
Chilled Summer Melon Soup
Traditional Calamari
Sweet Potato Fries
Seared Sea Scallop
Sriracha Calamari
Mushroom Risotto

“Sunday brunch was amazing! So many choices: beef, ham, bacon, sausage, shrimp, cod, salmon. Tables full of baked goods, salads, sides, an omelet station, loaded dessert table...just more than I can name. Lovely setting, beautiful views. Clean, quiet, well decorated. Would highly recommend for a special birthday or anniversary.“

4.1 Good354 Reviews
Monkey Farm Bar & Grill • $
571 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Fried Shrimp and Scallops Crisp Fries and Homemade Coleslaw
Hot Lobster Roll with French Fries and Homemade Cole Slaw
Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich and Fries
Fried Whole Belly Clams
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Beef Melt Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Hot Lobster Rolls
Mahi Mahi Tacos

“Great food; relax atmosphere“

3.9 Good132 Reviews