Fenwick Ice Cream Co.
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
910 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook
(860) 943-3009
About Fenwick Ice Cream Co.
Fenwick Ice Cream Co. Reviews
Exceptional. Kids loved it as did us
Soo good! S’mores and Chocolate Mousse are my favorite combo!!
If my eyes were shut I wouldn’t have known I was eating coconut ice cream. All 4 of us adults were disappointed with the flavor... or lack of.
Menu
People in Old Saybrook Also Viewed
Fenwick Ice Cream Co. is a charming ice cream shop with a small storefront and picnic tables outside. The service is friendly and quick, and the ice cream is creamy and flavorful, handmade by them. The shop offers a variety of flavors, including unique options like toasted almond, mint chip, and creamsicle. Customers can enjoy their treats at one of the outdoor picnic tables, surrounded by pleasant music and a cozy, retro atmosphere. With a clean bathroom, nice and clean tables, and a convenient location, Fenwick Ice Cream Co. is a must-visit destination for ice cream lovers. The staff is amazing and fast, suggesting popular flavors like toasted almond, and serving perfect combos like a small flurry topped with fresh strawberry and walnuts. It’s a cute, casual spot where customers indulge in classics like the banana split with all the toppings. Many plan to return after enjoying lunch or dinner nearby.