29 Best Pizza Restaurants near South Windham

“Very friendly atmosphere!! My favorite place to go with my family and friends ♥️“

“Loves it“

“amazing service and great pizza for a worthy price! my top favorite pizza place...try the bacon jalapeno popper pizza it's one of my favorites!“

“Hands down the best pizza sandwhich money can buy. Get the turkinator! This is hands down one of my alltime fave places in the world to go.“

“07.29.25 *WRITTEN REVIEW Big Al’s Reel Reviews – EP.144 📍Manny’s Pizza Plus 💎 City of Norwich, CT Sometimes, the best food isn’t just about flavor—it’s about familiarity. This review wasn’t just another stop. This was a return. Six years ago, I used to walk these streets every day. I lived right around the corner at 17 Russell Road, and when I wanted a hot meal—whether it was lunch, dinner, or just a craving—Manny’s Pizza Plus was the move. It wasn’t just close… it was comfort. So for Episode 144, I did something different. I went back to where it all started. I parked the car. Looked at my old house. And I walked… just like I used to… straight to Manny’s. And what I found? Same warmth. Same heart. And yeah… still delicious. Let’s break it down: --- 1. French Onion Soup & Turkey Sandwich Combo – $8.99 💣 This combo hit hard. The French onion soup came out rich, cheesy, and full of flavor—the kind of bowl that slows you down and makes you appreciate the moment. The turkey sandwich? Toasted rye bread, stacked with turkey, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and honey Dijon mustard. That combo was excellent. A perfect pairing that brought everything full circle. --- 2. Fried Shrimp Lunch Plate – $13.50💣 Six crispy shrimp, fried just right—crunchy outside, soft and juicy inside. Real good. So good, I ate the tails. No lie. The French fries were on point—crispy, golden, hot. Coleslaw wasn’t bad, but not for me. Just a side that didn’t hit the same. --- 3. Small Cheese Pizza – $6.99 💣 That classic Greek-style pizza that Manny’s is known for—soft, sweet sauce, cheese that melts beautifully, and a crust that’s golden on the outside and soft on the inside. This was exactly what I remembered. Comfort food at its finest. --- The Atmosphere & Service This was a true B.A.R.R. Gem Spot—not because it’s fancy or flashy, but because it matters to me. The vibe inside is casual, easy, and welcoming. And the service? Absolutely wonderful. My server was Christina, who just so happens to be Manny’s daughter. She took great care of me—friendly, attentive, and full of pride for her family’s place. --- Final Thoughts: Sometimes the past calls you back—not for closure, but for connection. And this trip to Manny’s reminded me why I do what I do. It’s not just about new flavors… it’s about honoring the places that helped shape who we are. And when it comes to taco pizza—I’ll say this loud and clear: Manny’s makes the VERY BEST taco pizza I’ve ever had. Still my go-to whenever that craving hits. So if you’re in Norwich and want a spot that’s real, consistent, and full of heart—pull up to Manny’s Pizza Plus. Make sure you tell 'em Big Al sent you. And if you see that house on Russell Road? Give it a wave for me. ’See you on the Rebound, Peace✌🏾out ☝🏾❤️ – Big Al Mayo“

“Excellent! Delivery was fast, all items hot and well prepared!“

“Best restaurant to occupy this spot in years. Great service and food. Highly recommend the penne alla vodka!“

“Excellent service, fresh and delicious food, definitely the best. I give it a 1000 ah papas pizza 🍕“

“The best pizza for the soul.“

“We have been coming to this pizza joint for five years. We love it. Although they recently started charging for dipping sauce alongside wings. A dollar for 2 ounces. 🤔“

“A personal note expressing our gratitude to Irene's staff. My husband Phil's 80th birthday a huge success! I had ordered tons of food, all arrived on time and was piping hot and ready to serve. Each prepared dish was delicious! We received so many compliments on the food, with many asking for name of catering restaurant. You folks are the best! Many thanks! The Murtha's“

“Eat there often always had good service good food friendly atmosphere everyone has off days but one of the go to spots in willimantic for good pizzas“

“We order from here pretty regularly and historically have had great food! Tonight our pick up order was lacking and not up to the standard that we have grown to expect. A simple phone call and they were quick to replace the order that wasn’t correct to make it right! Thanks!“

“Amazing spot with exceptional food and truly attentive service. The owner, Khaldoun, personally checked in on us and showed genuine interest in our thoughts on the dishes, spices, and overall experience. It’s clear they care deeply about what they do. Definitely a place worth returning to.highly recommended.“

“A local and area gem that's not to be overlooked!

Six years later, absolutely thrilled to see how welcoming and phenomenal everything remains.

I did want to update my review after seeing there being a complaint about the prices of food. Seeing how *consistent* their prices are is remarkable, and above and beyond that the value is particularly noteworthy.

Altogether from the quality (and *portions*) of the food, to the amazing staff, definitely a place to come to and make a regular stop.“

“Food is great and have ordered many times but their delivery driver driving blue Honda civic has almost rear ended me twice…. Once about a month ago after I just picked food up from them almost hit me in my Honda and again today I hate to have to leave this review but is really unsafe and has been inch from hitting me twice…“

“Great pizza and service every time I have ordered, also really great Buffalo wings too! Definitely worth a try if you haven’t had it yet and bonus that they deliver !!“

“The service is wonderful and the food is 💯 great a 10+... the owners are great and humble people...my favorite pizza spot..“

“Great homemade pies. Got the very berry pie was yummy“

“Great food and service… o had stuffed mushrooms, calamari, shepherds pie and my friend had baked flounder and French fries. 😋 sooooo yummy“

“Not sure who exactly made my pizza but it said Tony, but whoever it was saw the vision for sure!! I wanted a chicken parm pizza and got the perfect one. The cheesy bread was also incredible!!! Thank you so much, I know it can be hard sometimes to work at a busy store especially near a college campus, you guys are doing great.“

“Blaze Pizza is hands-down the best spot for a quick, custom pie! The team was outstanding—I walked in, built my pizza, and it was fired and ready in minutes. The prices are very reasonable for the quality and unlimited toppings you get. The crust was perfectly crisp and the ingredients were super fresh. Thanks for the great service and a perfect lunch“

“We had a large group today (25 people kids/adults), they were SO accommodating! The service was amazing, and Vincenzo was helpful setting everything up and checking in on us multiple times. We will 100% go back!“

“Admittedly I have been coming here more often during the late night hours with a friend of mine picking up their late night pizza deals with their sides of bread bites which have been absolutely phenomenal!!!
To be a bit more critical tho the bread bites aren't always the same >_<
It seems that definitely depends on which worker is there, the nights where the bites are heavily buttered and seasoned are phenomenal!! And when they aren't they can be a bit of a let down but are delicious regardless, service is Always great!! Friendly staff and great food!!“

“I like everything I have ever ordered from there except the pizza. it's dry, the toppings and cheese separate from the sauce so it's a congealed cheese hunk with dry toppings stuck in it. the crust is too brown and there's no flavor. just bland, tasteless, dry, awful pizza. I've had the taco pizza lol what a joke that was and steak with sausage, dry and a waste of my money. their onion rings are very good, they used to be more fried and less crumbly coating. generosity has dwindled, too. cheeseburger grinder w bacon is good but I don't appreciate the warm lettuce, they don't take modifications or whatever you call that on doordash site ordering occum pizza. owner boy is clueless. I'll still order from here. Moore pizza I just heard is on doordash now :D I order extra sauces because I know some stuff is going to be dry or flavorless but I DON'T GET THEM!! they put ketchup packets on top of the onion rings GROSS so they don't have to give those rings... they piss me off but I'll still order.“

“I have ordered online for delivery twice in the past two months. my orders were accurate, on time and my driver's were friendly. I also received a surprise free item on this most recent order, so the commercials are real! For inexpensive food, they hit all the marks 👍🏻“

“Turnovers are frequent because of it being a business in a college town. That didn't stop this place from hiring good people! The staff is always attentive and polite when you visit. Below are pictures of one of my nights ordering here!“

“Great experience! If you’re dropping your kid off at UConn for orientation, make sure you stop by. The two ladies and the pizza cook treated us really well. One of them even gave my son, who will be attending UConn in the fall, some helpful advice about campus.

Overall, the pizza was really good! We’re from Philly, but we’ll definitely be back for more. Thank you to Emma, Alyssa, and Nathan!“

“My family was passing through the area and we decided to stop. We were not disappointed. The gluten free pizza was excellent! The veal piccata and penne alla vodka were delicious. The chicken parm sub was cooked perfectly with a lightly toasted roll. And the chick-fil-A quesadillas were tasty with a hint of sweet. We all also took home leftovers for a good price. It was so good that if we are passing through again we will definitely stop here!!“