19 Best American Restaurants near Willimantic

“Loves it“

“We love the Farmer’s Cow Calfe!! My husband and I often love to stop by for ice cream or milkshakes. They have all of the classic flavors, but also fun and innovative ones that change with the season. The staff are always friendly and inviting, and it’s also so cute!!“

“The service is wonderful and the food is 💯 great a 10+... the owners are great and humble people...my favorite pizza spot..“

“Great food great beer great staff!“

“5 Stars – A Hidden Gem with Amazing Vibes and Even Better Bartenders!

The Trophy Room in Storrs, CT is hands down one of my favorite spots in town. Whether you’re looking to unwind after a long day or kick off a night out with friends, this place never misses. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between cozy and lively, and the drink selection is always on point.

What really sets Trophy Room apart, though, are the bartenders—especially Olivia and Allison. These two are absolute stars behind the bar. They’re not only incredibly skilled at crafting top-notch cocktails, but they also bring such good energy to the place. Friendly, attentive, and always down for a quick chat or a solid recommendation, they make you feel right at home every time.

Olivia and Allison elevate the whole experience, and honestly, they’re a big reason I keep coming back. If you haven’t checked out Trophy Room yet, do yourself a favor and stop by—just be ready to make it your new go-to spot!“

“Great food that’s affordable and fast!“

“My family and I visited this restaurant during UConn Family Weekend, the place was packed at all times, people coming and going constantly and they had large TVs showing various games. We were hosted/greeted by Ron, who was really nice despite having a full house, and kept a lively attitude. We were served by Faith, who was also kind and checked on us frequently.

We had the giant pretzel which was delicious, soft, and warm. We also had the boneless wings with bourbon sauce and the Baja burger, it was spicy but we like spicy!

Plus: We did witness a satisfying moment, when a drunk privileged group of 5+ people tried to skip the line claiming they had a “reservation” when this restaurant clearly does not take reservations and is first come first serve (they write your name on a list and text you when it’s your time up to the stand), The snobby/pretentious group tried to bribe the hosts with money and as much as they huffed and puffed to be seated “ASAP” they were turned down and for some reason, that made me love this place even more. With that said, be conscious of your group size and if you’re going on a game night, maybe stop in ahead of time to put your name on the list while you walk around the shops in that downtown area.“

“Just wonderful ! The beet salad with red quinoa and blackened chicken is so paleo healthy and the burgers high quality delish. Great cup of coffee too. Everything was cooked perfectly, seasoned perfectly. Gorgeous old house with fireplace. The home made clam chowder is a such a surprise - best we have had since we were children in Mystic !“

“Great place to eat. Wonderful staff and excellent food. highly recommended.“

“I came here last night for the first time after a recommendation and so glad we did cause they did not disappoint. The decor is a little dated however we have the nicest waitress Natasha who made the evening so great. She was very prompt and friendly and really funny. The food portions were a generous size and everything we had was really good. We never once asked for water refills, she just kept them coming. Amazing staff. Amazing food. Will be returning to our new local favorite spot in the very near future and hopefully will get the same amazing waitress.“

“Great atmosphere!! Great food and great drinks!! Love coming here!“

“We don’t eat anywhere else! The food never disappoints and is honestly delicious. Everyone in there is so friendly and really wants to please.“

“went for St Patrick's day dinner ... did not disappoint! food was amazing 😋! can't wait to go back 🙂“

“Top notch friendly service. It was my first time here this weekend and had amazing gluten free options far more than most locations and they tasted AMAZING. The servers were all cheerful, helpful and friendly and the food was 12/10. I'll absolutely be back this is a GEM! the banana chocolate chip muffins are to die for! thanks all!“

“A local and area gem that's not to be overlooked!

Six years later, absolutely thrilled to see how welcoming and phenomenal everything remains.

I did want to update my review after seeing there being a complaint about the prices of food. Seeing how *consistent* their prices are is remarkable, and above and beyond that the value is particularly noteworthy.

Altogether from the quality (and *portions*) of the food, to the amazing staff, definitely a place to come to and make a regular stop.“

“Today was my first time eating here and I'll say right now that I will be back. This place reminds me a bit of a cozy diner.

We took my fiancé's dad here for an early birthday lunch. He was craving their calamari and onion rings and he said they hit the spot today. My fiancé got one of the daily specials (rodeo burger, I think) with sweet potato fries and I got the cheeseburger club plate with onion rings.

Come here with a big appetite, the expectation of a to go box or both! Portions here are very generous! We came home with at least half our rings and fries and I had part of my club sandwich left as well. A good portion of the calamari went into a to go box as well - that will make at least another two meals for my fiance's dad.

My burger club was very good! I wasn't given a choice on the doneness of my burger, but that wasn't a problem for me. My fiancé pronounced his burger as one of the better ones he's had in a while.

This place is very busy on Sundays and they close early (about three p.m. or so.) We did have to wait a little after we were seated for service, but that service was pretty good! Our food was as we wanted it and we got the things we asked for (cocktail sauce, extra cokes, etc.) despite our waitress running herself crazy to and from all her tables.

Prices were pretty decent for what we got (my plate was about $15.95 or so) The menu had a lot of variety - breakfast items, steaks, burgers and sandwiches, and salads. There is also a cabinet full of a variety of cakes at the front of the restaurant and they looked delicious!“

“Great food friendly service“

“Hands down my favorite spot for wings. So many flavors.... dry seasoned or sauce.... whatever mood your in.... youll find wings to match it. Great beer. And a ton of different stuff bottled or on tap. And last but not least their prime rib...... brrrruuuuhhhhh. They have the best prime rib ive eaten at any restaraunti n ct. Do i recommend bidwell...... YES. Stupid question“

“The nostalgia around this place is out of this world. Heard Sue Bird and Diana Turasi brag about it while watching the final four and I can see why. Owners are always working, staff is one of the best in business, food is always warm, and the beer is always cold. What more could you ask for!

* Side note * Been known to see a few celebrities sneaking around the bar from time to time.“