39 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fenwick Island

“Excellent homemade ice cream!“

“We came on Saturday night(6/4/22) and it was very busy, but the girls working were amazing!! They were so fast and efficient and kept the line moving. I was so impressed with these two ladies and as always the ice cream was great!!!“

“If you're like me (an ice cream lover), PopCe is the perfect place for you!. The ice cream is very creamy and delicious, I'm so in love with this store. By the way, don’t forget to choose waffle cones, they’re a 20/10!“

“Best Ice cream at the beach!“

“Came all the way from Georgia to stay in ocean city for a spring vacation. Wanted something sweet to eat and ended up here . This bubble waffle cone with salted caramel ice cream , strawberries , banana, Oreos , KitKat and Nutella drizzle was TO DIE FOR !!!! 10/10 on presentation and fast service“

“Just tried Peanut Butter Ripple for the first time at the Millville Fire Dept. for The Fire and Ice Festival. It was amazing. It’s the creamiest ice cream I have ever tasted.“

“The ice cream and shaved ice was great. I had the brownie extreme, my son had chocolate and my husband had egg custard. They were really friendly and nice too. We will be coming back whenever we want cool treats again. Thank you!“

“Every year when we go to the beach we get Dumser’s Ice Cream at least 3 times. Best ice cream ever!“

“Best ice cream in OC and lots of flavors!“

“Great lunch/dinner food family friendly. They need to update prices on their menu - bill was a but more than advertised“

“I got a strawberry rolled ice cream with whip and it was pretty good I would get this again

Dietary restrictions: They have there own gluten free ice cream plate thing and they can help look for stuff in ingredients for you if u ask“

“it tastes grea we love it !!“

“Every year when we go to the beach we get Dumser’s Ice Cream at least 3 times. Best ice cream ever!“

“Loved since we moved to PA in 2002, near the Stewartstown area, back when it was Summer’s. Young people, high school & college age, work there. They are very nice. When I order my milkshake extra thick, they listen. Soooo, yummy. Our kids, grandkids, my mom, and dog love it. Bubby always orders the Puppy Cup, even though he’s 12 now. Rita’s and Baskin Robbin’s are good, but nothing beats Bonkey’s.“

“I’m not sure who loves Bonkey’s more…. Me or my dog 😂 Stopped in to the Red Lion location tonight and she devoured her pup cup…. Check out the comments for the pictures 😂“

“Good quality ice cream with many options. They also have Nerds!!!“

“Large scoops for the price!!“

“I was immediately greeted me as soon as I walked in. Carter was very nice and knowledgeable on items. My elderly grandmother is not the easiest customer and he handled it perfectly and with the upmost respect! Highly recommend for ice cream in Bethany!“

“Stopped Wednesday 8/14 and got some Cannolis to go. They were delicious!“

“The coolest guy I’ve ever met Jun“

“Unique texture and flavor unlike most custard ice creams go here every year and it's amazing chocolate cone is my go to

Parking: Park at the main entrance for board walk there's many of these through the boardwalk though

Kid-friendliness: Yes it's ice cream and it's on the boardwalk

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it's good and you can have them on boardwalk“

“Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is incredibly delicious!!!! Will be back again and again!!“

“Chocolate peanut butter swirl“

“Cute spot, cool treats! Great place to stop!“

“Their frozen custard is the best. I especially recommend the creamsicle swirl!“

“The coolest guy I’ve ever met Jun“

“Everything I’ve had there is delicious! Coffee is amazing! Come every year for a açaí bowl! Friendly staff!“

“Stopped in for no sugar added ice cream one day as it was mentioned on their website. They had none. I FB messaged and got quick response. They went out of their way to go to St Michaels to get some! Stopped right in and it was amazing! BTW I cannot have sugars much and this is one of very few places that offers no sugar added - another plus!“

“Great selection great place to stop for a cone or anything from Dunkin Donut as well“

“Variety of cool treats from frozen bars for kids to smoothies to shaved ice.“

“I stopped in for breakfast and got the Summer Berry Crepe, it was amazing. The food choices are so varied that I plan on visiting again this trip, which usually I don't eat at the same place on vacation but the menu is good and varied. 10/10
no complaints, good food, atmosphere as best as can be.“

“The ice cream tastes amazing, the flavors are rich and high quality, and the portions are really satisfying. The staff were also super friendly and welcoming. The whole place has such a sweet and cozy vibe 💖
Definitely coming back again highly recommend!“

“Went two days in a row on Wednesday and Thursday this week and it was great! I would say the best part about it was the customer service and the speed they served. They worked through a long line incredibly fast. I feel horrible I didn’t catch the girl with glasses name to get credit for her hard work, but her and Dimp (was his nickname) did a great job! They both worked the two same shifts. Super hard workers and very nice people.

I’m sure my review won’t do much for them in reality, but if management does see this I hope they get commended for it.“

“Best drinks and treats in town - you won’t be disappointed!“

“Best custard around Ocean City.“

“Workers should go up north to learn how to move their butts, 12 minutes for a coffee and a wrap is a bit ridiculous alot of employees and it wasn't even that busy“

“Stopped in on a nice Wednesday morning around 11 or so and instantly was greeted with a refreshing and cool atmosphere. After we decided on flavors from the many options, the lady behind the counter got to work grabbing our dots and mixing our shake. The dots were so cold they practically stuck to my tongue! (refreshingly) And the peanut butter milkshake had loads of peanut butter in it. Very good stuff, I'll be back for a slushie!“