29 Best Italian Restaurants near Fenwick Island

“Once again we dined at our favorite Italian restaurant in the area. The food and service were excellent as usual. We were seated in the left side of the restaurant and being a gray day it was quite dark inside. So in an effort to “brighten” the situation we raised the window shade. After years as patrons of this fine restaurant we apparently committed the most grevious of sins ….DO NOT, UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES RAISE A WINDOW SHADE! You will quickly suffer the wrath of the general manager……..“

“Jordan was our wonderful server who let us know the deals happening which was very informative, he was funny, and very sweet. We weren't going to say anything but he Overheard we were here for our anniversary and brought us cake at the end! 5 stars thank you!!“

“The garlic bread is the best-crusty on the outside but soft buttery and garlicky in the center. The Greek salad was topped with a luxurious amount of capers. The scratch made dishes were of monster proportions but still were fresh like from your nana's kitchen.“

“THANK YOU Sophia for hosting Restsurant Night for the Women's Club of OP. Everyone enjoyed your hospitality and delicious food. It was nice meeting your family as they assisted you in serving the many tables that attended the evening. The chicken parm was a hit from the menu along with the ceaser and chef's salads.“

“First time dining at this restaurant after having been so delighted by DiFebo's Market. Dinner was fantastic! Our party consisted of three. The braised short-ribs over wild mushroom risotto was amazing. My husband had the calamari fra diavolo (he cleaned his plate). My mother-in-law had Pop's cioppino and LOVED it! We split a tiramasiu...will definitely be going back!! Our waitress, Mindy, was first class fun as was the entire staff.“

“We had dinner here for the first time tonight and everyone was wonderful, from the hostess to our waiter. The food was excellent, we both had veal dishes (the parmesean and marsala) and the owner even stopped by our table to ask how everyone was. We will definitely go back!“

“Their cheesesteaks are one of the best I've had. ? My wife and I split one and have plenty to eat. Great quality ingredients. This is the place to go when we're in the mood for a cheesesteak down in the Bethany area.I hear their pizza is good also. We will be trying that soon.“

“This place is crazy good. Omg! You won't be disappointed. Everything is delicious. They're always packed too. My family went there on a whim and we're hooked. The price is worth the deliciousness. Your fatty senses will thank you“

“While there are many choices for pizza in Ocean City, Meoni’s is an annual tradition for our family with good reason. The food is undefeated in taste, quality and selection. The Sicilian slice is a favorite as is the white pizza and the fried green beans. Never had a bad meal and could not recommend it higher.Kid-friendliness: Fun, casual environment.Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp entry available and ample parking.“

“I wanted to give Mione's another try since it is so popular amongst the locals, and it was an excellent idea to do so! This time, I ordered a pickup for Baked Ziti - 8/10 The pasta was well-cooked, and the combination of ricotta cheese and mozzarella was yummy. I personally like a bit more flavor but it was delicious. especially if you are into more blander tastes.“

“I've been here several times and never had a bad experience. The lasagna is excellent. Papardelle Bolognaise very good. There was so much sauce my companion and I ate all the pasta and between the two of us there was a full quart of sauce left over for us to take home and I froze it for another time. Great value. Service always efficient and friendly.“

“These guys have been around for a very long time and have been serving the best deli, sandwiches and subs that you could probably ever find! If you're looking for a good original Italian sub that's real and made with absolutely incredible ingredients at just the right amount. Not too much and not too less just the way it's supposed to be made then you need to come to DeVitos! Every sub I have had here over the years has been simply delicious!“

“Delicious! Just like when I was a kid!Remains my top choice for Pizza and all Italian food. No place like home!Vegetarian options: Plenty of veggies and Italian Seaford entréesDietary restrictions: Just ask your waitress. Very helpfulParking: Appears every space may be taken but wait 1 minute...and there's a space!Kid-friendliness: Very family oriented. Kids, grandparents, are accommodated with pleasure. My favorite Italian restaurant for family!Wheelchair accessibility: Handicapped parking and wheelchair access thru out.“

“WOW! The chicken parm is the size of a 12" pizza. It was cooked perfectly. The marinara sauce was very tasty. We took half home for Sunday dinner. Hurry up, Sunday. Service was excellent. We will definitely return on our next trip to OC.“

“After a long day with friends etc…we had plans to call another good friend and meet up! We were pooped out and just decided to order carry out! It was a Saturday and very busy however someone did take our phone order and he was very nice!We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni! It’s very good for never having had their pizza before. My husband picked up the pizza and asked for some peppers ….no one was able to even assist in getting any for him.We will certainly return next trip and enjoy a sit down dinner and experience! We do recommend the pizza!“

“Exceptional Pizza & Service!I came across their ad in OC newspaper for Sunday all you can eat for $13! and decided to give it a try. It exceeded our expectations! The brick oven pizza was delicious with a perfect crust. We tried out Quattro Fromaggi, Margarita & Pepperoni pizza, Fettuccini, Spaghetti; for salad both Caesar & Garden salad were fresh. The Onion soup was yummy. The service was outstanding - attentive and friendly. Loved the cozy ambiance , clean bathroom, everything was great & we enjoyed our dining experience! Can’t wait to return for more! A must-visit for pizza lovers!“

“First time for us at Mio Fratello. We dined with friends who have been there numerous times. I chose to try their linguini and clam sauce. I make that dish as well. So I wanted to compare. It was absolutely delicious! The owner was so accommodating , the ambiance was happy, and the drinks delicious!! ( Old Fashioned). Will go back again!!“

“Very few, if any, pizza leaves me speechless. I had this pizza for the first time last night and may have even dreamed about it! I also had the mozzarella sticks. Boy oh boy, never have I had a mozzarella stick like that either! I could have dived into a pool of that dipping sauce! What an incredible meal for my first night at the beach!“

“DELICIOUS, FRESH FOOD! And Rylee was THE BEST SERVER. I will come here EVERY year from now on when we come down for our vacation!Vegetarian options: Enough options and all delicious. I don't feel like I had to order "the one" boring veggie option!Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessibility.“

“The pizza wasn’t my favorite, but that’s just my opinion - I’m not a fan of saucy and crusty pizza. But if you’re a fan of a good crunchy crust and a hearty sauce, then this pizza is definitely for you! And the cheese and pepperoni were really good!“

“Had a great time here this past weekend. Despite seemingly only two people working and the place being very busy, they did a great job and we hardly had to wait long for food or drinks. It’s a great place to watch sports too. We will be back.“

“Our first time at Mio's and it was Great! Jeannie was our bartender and made us feel welcome immediately. The food was perfect and the other guests were fantastic. What a wonderful place for a long afternoon lunch! We will be back often!“

“This place is an absolute staple for my husband every time we are down at the ocean. My husband makes sure that we stop at least once while we are here. but honestly, I am pretty sure that we stop multiple times while we are here. The atmosphere is family oriented; the food is fresh, and the drinks are cold. I personally love the cheesesteak, while my husband enjoys the pizza. We personally could not see ourselves coming to the ocean without stopping and getting our favorite pizza on the boardwalk.“

“Should extend delivery. More than 5 miles. I order a lot and don’t want to go out every time I’m literally 7.5 miles away…. And the cheese for the cheese fries is always cold I have ordered 3 different times and it was cold every time, no bueno besides that everything else is good…the pizza is awesome! Cheesesteaks are one to compete with!“

“Boneless wings were good. Gave me Texas Pete hot sauce. Usually like them doused in buffalo sauce but was still good though! Price was really good for the boneless wings as well! Once I made my mind up and changed my order the first time lol. I'm indecisive at “

“Do you love home made Italian food? This is the joint. Food is delicious, service is friendly yet professional. This is an authentic family restaurant. I highly recommend it, if you know Italian food. If you think pizza hut is Italian food, stay away from this place, as you won't appreciate it.“

“I was having a horrible day and ordered what I thought was a Reuben. It was Reuben-like. Unfortunately it came to the table cold and that was just one more thing I did wrong today. I didn't ask if it was cold/hot when I ordered. So the lady at the front desk offered to help and had it remade toasted with the coleslaw and Russian dressing on the side and it was absolutely astounding! If you're craving delicious subs run don't walk to this place! Great staff and food!“

“We’ve been here several times for eat in. The staff is very pleasant and attentive. We have had the cheesesteak, meatball and Italian subs. We also have had chicken Alfredo and the beef lasagna with salad and garlic bread. All have been very good. I would recommend these and look forward to coming back to try some of their other menu items.“

“The atmosphere here is a bit on the quite side. Despite that I do have to say that the pizza might be my favorite pie in town. I love eating the small square pieces. You kinda just pop em in like tic tac one bite at a time. And they are delicious. Always consistently “