21 Best Italian Restaurants near Lewes

“The manicotti and salad was tres bien But what I like best is how well the staff works together and how much they seem to enjoy their jobs. Muchisima gratia“

“Went there for dinner last night, eaten there many times in the past 15 yrs. Food was excellent as usual, but service was not great, our waitress totally ignored us from the beginning from taking our order to checking on us and seeing if our food was ok or if we needed another drink. We had to stop other waitresses to ask for help in getting my husband another beer to getting takeout boxes and to even asking for our check. Very disappointed because that's the first time we had bad service.“

“If you are a lover of fine food, excellent wine and amazing music, I highly recommend this one of a kind experience.“

“outstanding pizza, loved the ground sausage,and cheesesteaks amazing!“

“Looks like they remodeled recently. It's really nice. We were a group after a funeral viewing and our waitress was amazing. I wish I could remember her name but I do remember a tattoo on her leg. Whatever her name is. She was super sweet and very attentive to us. The pizza was great. It made a very challenging situation. Much more pleasant. Thank you guys for everything.

Vegetarian options: I'm married to a vegetarian and it looked to have a good selection of toppings. It's mainly a pizza restaurant. I don't know if they had any vegan choices.“

“Take it from a North Jersey guy; the best pizza I've tried in Slower Lower. Specialty pizzas are great too. Try the cheesesteak pie or Grandma pie. Awesome sandwiches also, and the Texas fries are cheesy-bacony goodness.“

“My wife and I had dinner on Friday night. We did have reservations and glad we did because it was packed. I had the seafood diavolo and my wife had chicken cacciatore. Food was hot, perfectly done, and great presentation. Portions are generous. The past is freshly made and cooked perfectly!! Enjoyed talking with Vincenzo, the owner. We will return.“

“Had the butternut squash tortellini and it was delicious ❤️. I love this restaurant and highly recommend 🥰“

“We had a fantastic meal tonight with excellent service from Chris! This was our first time eating here but definitely not our last!“

“The calamari was the best I’ve had, the portion was huge and could have been a main course. The outside dining was awesome and the service was outstanding. Very accommodating to my wife’s garlic allergy. Would recommend this place to everyone. Thank you“

“I would drive all the way from Pittsburgh just to get this pizza again! Not only is it hands down the best pizza I have ever had the staff is incredible and makes you feel like an old friend when you walk in. We loved it so much we multiple times here during our trip. Food, service, pricing everything was top notch!
And the buy by the slice was perfect so everyone was happy with their toppings!“

“Great food and excellent service.“

“We’ve been customers of Grandpa Mac since they were on Baltimore Avenue years ago. Each time we are in Rehoboth or Ocean City, we make time to stop and get our favorite, The Fun Guy, with sausage. The portions are huge, the cheese sauce is delicious, and we always leave happy and full. Our favorite place to stop and eat. Highly recommend!“

“Great service great pizza“

“Great cheesesteak subs! Cash only. Very small seating area with a couple of pinballs and arcade games.“

“This place is so very good and recommend it if you are not from here.“

“If you think Red,White & Basil is just an Italian restaurant, try their new menu...the New York strip was delicious!!!“

“Detroit pizza is so light and fluffy. Fantastic“

“Yes!! A true pizza spot here in Rehoboth. New owner truly cares about the product and is a pizza enthusiast to the core. Crust has great crunch and doesn't bloat the belly. If you know great pizza, give this spot a go! Very very happy to have found you!“

“GO SEE NICO best bartender and waiter ever! Mama Maria's is part of our family crawl every year and we are pleasantly supremely to have Nico as our bartender year after year!
Pizza slices are 10/10 thin slice pepperoni and cheese and buffalo chicken slices are great!
Thank you nico for being awesome!“

“Grotto Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers! The moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a great meal. Their signature swirl pizza is not only unique but incredibly delicious, with a perfect blend of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and a crispy crust that hits all the right notes. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic favorites to creative specialty pizzas, ensuring there's something for everyone.

The staff at Grotto Pizza are friendly and efficient, making the dining experience even better. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or ordering for delivery, the quality is consistently top-notch. It’s a great spot for families, friends, or anyone craving a satisfying, flavorful pizza. Five stars!“