13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Altamonte Springs

“Nick's Pizza in Altamonte Springs is a hidden gem for fresh, delicious pizza that’s both flavorful and satisfying. The outdoor seating is simple and functional, featuring wrought iron tables with benches, similar to what you’d find in a park. While the seating is limited, the friendly and attentive service more than makes up for it, ensuring a pleasant and efficient experience. Whether you’re grabbing take out or enjoying your meal outdoors, Nick’s Pizza is a must-visit for quality pizza lovers.“

“Absolutely the best pizza I’ve ever had !! I will forever be a regular 😊 If you haven’t been here you are missing out !!“

“Friendly fast service and a really great tasting FRESH pizza! Hidden gem!“

“The best tasting Italian pizza in Florida. Have been searching for many’s years since moving from New York City and I found my pizza!! Great service. Family and friendly oriented. Just like home.“

“Antica Pizzeria Paul and Pam have an amazing ristorante…wonderful people from New Hampshire. Tim was [server] was top notch and customer focused. Eric is the pizzaiolo and he got real SKILLS 🍕 We had the pesto sampler-appetizer, Rigatoni IDA and the Angry Goat pizza. ALL of it was fresh, flavorful and high quality. Go today!!“

“My wife and I were in town staying at a local hotel. I asked the check in rep if there were any good pizza places close by. He gave me a flyer to this place. We looked it over and thought "what the hell". We called and gave them our order: 1 Medium Pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onions, ham & hot peppers 1 Antipasto salad 1 order of Meatballs The food arrived to the hotel pretty quickly. It was all hot (except the salad) and fresh. We couldn't wait to dig in. The pizza looked so good I didn't want to eat it Everything was very good. I would order from them again if I was in the area. ***They only get 4 stars though. I would have given them 5 stars but they did not have any silverware for my wife to enjoy her salad and meatballs. When delivering to hotels, they need to be aware to have silverware available to their customers“

“Anthony’s pizza has been our pizza place since it opened. It’s the best New York style pizza since coming from New York City.
My granddaughter loves it and she says this is our tradition to go eat after church. The food is delicious and the service is amazing. Yes sometimes they’re very busy but it’s only because they’re very good. It’s worth the wait. Reason I’m reviewing now is because my granddaughter Said we have to review and give them a 5 star.“

“My family had my grandsons birthday party at what i call Rosarios!!! It was being home again with his welcome and also his entire staff . Had not been there in a while . OMG He put out a antipasti fit for a king. All the entrees where all served Big Al style. Big Al is my nickname. Thanks for a memory for the entire family . Best food in Seminole County“

“The pizza, sub and salad we ordered were all very good. Thank you.“

“Lots of birthday and the children enjoy“

“Incredible! The pizza is fresh, full of flavor, and has a light, crispy crust. The place is perfect for a quick break between shopping, but still just as delicious. The service is excellent, and the atmosphere is ideal for enjoying a meal without rushing. Perfect for enjoying alone or with friends. I’ll definitely be back.“

“My experience here was absolutely amazing! Our server, Landon, was cool, funny, and always checking in to make sure everything was perfect. The food was incredible, and the portion sizes were unbelievable! Thank you for treating us like family.

Yours truly,
Don Pepperoni 🍕“

“They hardly have enough staff to cover the rush so a 15 minute wait turns into 20-25 min. It's not their fault, they just need more help. So, if you're not in a hurry to get your food and have the patience to wait, then great! 😀 The Crazy Pepperoni Cheese Puffs are amazing! Well worth the wait.“