16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Altamonte Springs

“Nick's Pizza in Altamonte Springs is a hidden gem for fresh, delicious pizza that’s both flavorful and satisfying. The outdoor seating is simple and functional, featuring wrought iron tables with benches, similar to what you’d find in a park. While the seating is limited, the friendly and attentive service more than makes up for it, ensuring a pleasant and efficient experience. Whether you’re grabbing take out or enjoying your meal outdoors, Nick’s Pizza is a must-visit for quality pizza lovers.“

“Everything is made fresh and in-house with great quality ingredients. They have a nice market selection also for take-home items like fresh pasta and desserts.“

“Absolutely the best pizza I’ve ever had !! I will forever be a regular 😊 If you haven’t been here you are missing out !!“

“The best tasting Italian pizza in Florida. Have been searching for many’s years since moving from New York City and I found my pizza!! Great service. Family and friendly oriented. Just like home.“

“Friendly fast service and a really great tasting FRESH pizza! Hidden gem!“

“My wife and I were in town staying at a local hotel. I asked the check in rep if there were any good pizza places close by. He gave me a flyer to this place. We looked it over and thought "what the hell". We called and gave them our order: 1 Medium Pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onions, ham & hot peppers 1 Antipasto salad 1 order of Meatballs The food arrived to the hotel pretty quickly. It was all hot (except the salad) and fresh. We couldn't wait to dig in. The pizza looked so good I didn't want to eat it Everything was very good. I would order from them again if I was in the area. ***They only get 4 stars though. I would have given them 5 stars but they did not have any silverware for my wife to enjoy her salad and meatballs. When delivering to hotels, they need to be aware to have silverware available to their customers“

“I'm updating my review to a 5 because this place has become my go-to for takeout pizza.

The Value:
The specific ratings are food, service and atmosphere but the criteria I weigh most heavily is how much I feel that the price was worth the total package. I've been coming a long time, but more frequently lately as prices of lower quality pizzas have risen to the point where I've made an intentional decision to grab pizza slightly less frequently, but when I do I go ahead and get a quality pie from Anthony's.

The Place:
As I mentioned, I don't live far away and have always come here occasionally. It is a smaller place with just a few small tables and a couple of booths but is a nice sit in restaurant where someone can order a pasta while I order a slice. It is a casual atmosphere but a nice and cozy one. There's usually a few older guys working in the back with a girl running the counter. I don't know if they're family, but some of them very well could be. Then again, I've never heard those loud arguments in the back so maybe they're not family. Anyway, it feels like a nice family atmosphere.

The Service:
I usually pick up my pizza after calling ahead and have never had any issue. I usually speak to a polite younger woman both on the phone and when I pick up.

The Pizza:
The crust is very good, like real fresh dough. All of the ingredients are real and fresh and it really comes through. I usually get a Hawaiian and a specialty pizza called "The Boss" with meat and green peppers and things. Really good stuff. And it reheats well the next day, so much better than the delivery chains both fresh and next day.“

“The pizza was great, service was quick and friendly. It seems like the new management has fixed it up alot. I definitely recommend!“

“A friend living nearby recommended Terramia for a get together of several guys. Was greeted warmly and seated by Tiffany who was hostess and bartending. Jenae was our server and between the two of them was made to feel at home. Atmosphere was very comfortable and intimate like a neighborhood gathering spot. The food was attractively plated and delicious. I had the Pasta Primavera with bread and soup and enjoyed it immensely. Will definitely be back with more friends. Thanks everyone !!!“

“The pizza, sub and salad we ordered were all very good. Thank you.“

“Lots of birthday and the children enjoy“

“Incredible! The pizza is fresh, full of flavor, and has a light, crispy crust. The place is perfect for a quick break between shopping, but still just as delicious. The service is excellent, and the atmosphere is ideal for enjoying a meal without rushing. Perfect for enjoying alone or with friends. I’ll definitely be back.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ **Outstanding Service from Billy!**

I had the pleasure of being served by Billy during my visit, and I must say, he made the entire dining experience exceptional! From the moment we were seated, Billy was attentive, courteous, and had a warm, welcoming demeanor that immediately put us at ease. He had an impressive knowledge of the menu, offering thoughtful recommendations and making sure our dietary preferences were accommodated without any issues.

What stood out most was his attention to detail—he anticipated our needs before we even had to ask! Drinks were always refilled on time, and he checked in with us at the perfect moments, without being intrusive. Billy’s friendly personality, combined with his professionalism, truly elevated our experience. You can tell he genuinely cares about his customers and enjoys what he does.

If you're lucky enough to have Billy as your server, you're in for a fantastic experience. He is a true asset to the team, and we will definitely be returning—partly because of the great food, but mostly because of Billy’s outstanding service!“

“I’ve been a Little Caesars customer for years, but this time was definitely one of the best. The pizza was ready right when I arrived, and using the heated self-serve box with my code made the whole process super easy. My pizzas stayed hot and fresh, which was awesome. The thin crust was perfect, and the filled cheesy breadsticks were absolutely delicious. I’ll definitely be back for more!“

“Super friendly and very amazing staff went in there for a pickup order and add it on something while I waited came out super quick! Thank you for the cinnamon twists!!!! They were very busy only had two staff members and still were able to make it happen Good job!“

“Amazing food , good family oriented bar with pool tables“