50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lake Mary

“Always Absolutely Fantastic Pizza! We only go to Bronx House for our pizza cravings!“

“visited on 1/2/26 an hour before close. ZA our server was absolutely amazing and the pizza cook (sorry forgot his name) was great as well. They provided us with exceptional service and because of them we will definitely be back.“

“Our table had cheesy garlic knots, bruschetta, mozzarella sticks , Margherita flatbread and pizza, arugula salad with crispy chicken and the boss lady flatbread. Aryanna was our server and she was fantastic! Food came out pretty quick too. 4 out of 5 people took food home. Very cozy family spot!😘👌🏼“

“Awesome service. Great food. Best prices.“

“Nothing..got a Pizza from them last night that was missing the mushrooms and black olives..pizza was dry and hard. Their only fix was a 30 day credit. I don’t even order pizza once a month. And they told me they’d be eating steak and lobster without my business. How’s that for a good business manager? They want to put themselves out of business“

“Absolutely amazing. The customer service at the Lake Mary location was so great. Last week we wanted pizza and someone recommended Filomena’s to me so I ordered online. When I ordered it told me it would be delivered within an hour which was perfect. A few moments later I got a text message saying it was going to be 2 hours. Because of this I called to cancel and spoke with Justine. She was great and canceled the order for me. About 20 minutes later she called back to let me know that they deliver in house vs using DoorDash when using the website and that next time we should call to order to skip the third party. The fact that she called me back to tell me this is such great customer service. She needs to be given all the praise or a raise 👀🤣. Fast forward to tonight when I called to place a deliver order, she remembered me and was so great again. Even called the manager to see if they would deliver a little farther out of their radius. I seriously could not recommend you guys enough.“

“Pizza Hut was my quick pizza of choice for years. Until they recently decided to change their crust from hand tossed to cardboard. This sent me in a pursuit of a new quick option…. I’m so glad it did! I had no idea Domino’s had such great pizza! Of all the pizza options out there I think they have the best hand tossed crust! Be sure to order it with the crust seasoning!“

“Food is fantastic. It’s a small place so you may have to wait for a little while, but I promise It’s worth the wait.“

“We love ordering from this Papa John’s. Pizza is always delicious and timely, but tonight I bit into a piece of plastic in my pizza 😕“

“Best lasagna i had all month, homemade soup & salad, garlic knots to die for with a side of peach tea and 2 glasses of cabernet with backgrouond sights and sounds of Italy to dine by....what more can i say.....“

“Amazing pizza today! Thank you from The Artistic Hand Gallery!“

“Food was excellent,server was excellent.“

“Amazing pizza and exceptional staff. Great location. Restraunt was stylish, comfortable and clean.“

“Nick's Pizza in Altamonte Springs is a hidden gem for fresh, delicious pizza that’s both flavorful and satisfying. The outdoor seating is simple and functional, featuring wrought iron tables with benches, similar to what you’d find in a park. While the seating is limited, the friendly and attentive service more than makes up for it, ensuring a pleasant and efficient experience. Whether you’re grabbing take out or enjoying your meal outdoors, Nick’s Pizza is a must-visit for quality pizza lovers.“

“My girlfriend brought some pizza from this place back to our home in NC. She got it 4 days ago, kept it cool and just now heated it up. BEST PIZZA EVER! I can only imagine it fresh. Sooooo good!“

“Came here per our son’s request for his birthday dinner and everything was fabulous and the staff were amazing! What a gem!“

“This is one of the best pizza places in the area. I got the Brooklyn pie with pepperoni and it was phenomenal. The crust crispy but not too hard. The cheese hit different in a way I haven’t experienced in years since being in NYC. Definitely try it out.“

“In town for a business event and happened to find this gem of a restaurant. I was lucky to be seated quickly because 85% of the tables were reserved. The staff was the most friendly and eager to please. Alexa in particular was dealing with some rather demanding customers, and she did it with a smile and grace. The six formaggi pizza was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had- the crust was stuffed with ricotta and I was in heaven. The Gorgonzola was a very forward flavor, so if bleu cheeses aren’t your favorite I’d make the pizza a five formaggi instead. The chocolate mousse was also light and delicate. I will go out of my way to return on future trips to the area.“

“The best pizza and wings in town! Ask for the extra hot garlic wings, a m a z i n g!!! Deliveries are always fast and the drivers are always friendly!“

“Definitely not what the reviews say. Paper thin pizza with no taste. Barely a crust. Expensive for what you get. 2 stars because I'm being nice. I don't like Pizza Hut but I would give them 5 stars over Roma Pizza any day. Save your money. Garlic knots are not knots just weird rolls with a watery sauce.“

“Moved here from Brooklyn and have tried all the pizza spots in the area tomasinos in winter springs is the best pizza in central Florida hands down and their meatballs are excellent their lunch specials are great as well Jose is very personable and every time me and my husband go in we feel like we are back home their pizza crust is on point and the cheese and sauce is great quality that says a lot because I am very picky with my red sauce five stars across the board“

“Growing up in Trenton NJ I had amazing pizza. Since I been down here in Florida haven’t found good pizza till tonight. I closed my eyes and felt like I was home. Highly recommend this place. This is now my go to pizza restaurant.“

“I've been in Orlando for a couple years... when my wife and I moved here, we lusted after the best slice we could find. We found it with ButterCrust. We've been ordering relentlessly for a while now and have never been disappointed. Today, we ordered our last pie because we're moving to Montana. It was just as delicious as the first one. There's a remarkable amount of consistency to their work. The ingredients are ALWAYS fresh. The pie is ALWAYS good. The crust, ingredients and final product are always worth EVERY. SINGLE. PENNY. If you take anything away from this review, know that it's world class pizza and it's handled with care.“

“My son wanted Five Star Pizza for his birthday dinner and it was great! BIG pizzas, great prices, and the staff was super nice!“

“Best pizza in the Orlando area. Always delicious and consistent.“

“Been there first time great food great service The staff is very friendly decently not my last visit“

“Absolutely the best pizza I’ve ever had !! I will forever be a regular 😊 If you haven’t been here you are missing out !!“

“Friendly fast service and a really great tasting FRESH pizza! Hidden gem!“

“I’m from New York and know good pizza I’ve been living in Orlando for over 30 years and tried several different pizza restaurants Torino’s is by far the best pizza place I’ve tasted in Orlando I won’t be going back to any other pizza restaurant but Torino’s from now on“

“We love Stefanos. We have never had a bad dish and the service is always on point. They’re amazing at accommodating large groups. Stefanos is my very picky Italian mom’s favorite spots to hit when she visits. :)“

“Hands down the best New York style hand tossed pie around! My buddy and I just got a large cheese and killed it in like 20 minutes.😁 Oh and definitely ask for a side of garlic oil, trust me!“

“There is one server there I don't know her name she worked today most pleasant person I ever met. wow“

“As a Green Bay Packers fan… I love this place! Somehow, they keep replaying the 2025 wildcard game against the Bears when I’m here, but I’ll let it slide. Food and service are amazing. The husband and wife duo are so sweet and awesome. Give this place a visit!“

“Mila was our server and she was very kind, professional, efficient and poised. She took great care of our group. Our food…amazing. The servings were HUGE and flavorful. A big plus: Darryl (host) was so kind and fun as he volunteered to take many pics of our group in front of the ristorante. He and Mila are great ambassadors of your business. We will return. Grazie !! 🇮🇹“

“Nice clean Restaurant 👌, great customer service, my mom and I really enjoyed the crispy crust, pepperoni and sausage pizza was scrumptious! Mama had sausage, we've never tasted a pizza so delicious, the crust is different and delicious 😋“

“5 stars. Had 2 pizzas, wings, calamari, lobster bisque, chicken parm and ceaser salad. Everything was on point!!! Really fair prices and great portions. I can’t wait to come back. Our server Brinson was ON POINT, as well. Highly recommend“

“The best tasting Italian pizza in Florida. Have been searching for many’s years since moving from New York City and I found my pizza!! Great service. Family and friendly oriented. Just like home.“

“Best pizza in Central Florida. Highly recommend.“

“My wife and I were in town staying at a local hotel. I asked the check in rep if there were any good pizza places close by. He gave me a flyer to this place. We looked it over and thought "what the hell". We called and gave them our order: 1 Medium Pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onions, ham & hot peppers 1 Antipasto salad 1 order of Meatballs The food arrived to the hotel pretty quickly. It was all hot (except the salad) and fresh. We couldn't wait to dig in. The pizza looked so good I didn't want to eat it Everything was very good. I would order from them again if I was in the area. ***They only get 4 stars though. I would have given them 5 stars but they did not have any silverware for my wife to enjoy her salad and meatballs. When delivering to hotels, they need to be aware to have silverware available to their customers“

“Hard to beat the value of the online $8.99 1 topping pizza. Garlic knots were a good price and included 8 instead of 6 like most places, as well as a large container of sauce. Food was ready fast and tasted fresh. Definitely a good option for low cost take out pizza.“

“The food was amazing and Alberto was the person who help me navigate a the info there and was really useful.“

“best Detroit deep dish in Florida!! I wish we had one near the Villages or Ocala.“

“Fantastic pizza!!! Love the ‘twist’!“

“Got some pizza and garlic rolls my second night after moving to Deltona and this is hands down the best pizza I have had in over a decade this is the ONLY pizza place I will be eating from now on. If you haven't eaten here yet you are missing out big time“

“My husband and I are New Yorkers and arrived in Orlando in March of this year, we thought that never again we would find a good Italian restaurant with real NY food and exceptional pizza and calzones. We’ve had our share of flops and bad food experiences in Italian eateries that were supposed to be good….I won’t mention any names.
Well today we found the most delicious and best italian eatery!
NY anthony’s pizza
OH MY GOD I AM A DEMANDING PERSON AND A STICKLER FOR PIZZA
WELL THIS PIZZA WAS AMAZING
I had the regular and my husband had the Sicilian!!! SO GOOD.
But this place is also a restaurant
They have table service and real dishes. No paper nonsense
The sodas come in large glasses with tons of ice! So refreshing in the hot Orlando weather!!
The servers are lovely so clean such a nice atmosphere and you can’t beat the prices. My husband brought home a delicious ginormous calzone and a cannoli that is to die for delicious . Now this is not just a pizzeria, it’s a full fledged italian restaurant with an extensive and delicious menu of pastas and other dishes.
WE WENT THERE TODAY AND WE WILL BE BACK!!
We highly recommend this delicious establishment. My husband is a retired corporate chef for IBM and he knows good food when he sees it.
WE PROMISE YOUNG WONT BE DISAPPOINTED.
Tony & Elizabeth“

“Pupusas were so good and fresh! I definitely recommend 👌“

“Come here all the time with my kids. They are so basic so we normally just get cheese slices. Today, me and my son decided on a canzone due to his infatuation with stuffed crust.. I was a little weary that he wouldn't like it. The canzone was literally spilling over with cheese. Jonas, the cook told me he would make another but we could keep the messed up one. When I tell you.. me and him tore that thang up! And thanks to Jonas we had an extra one to take home! He really didnt have to.. but everything he did required me to make this 5 star review. We never have any complaints with this place, but today we definitely have an accolade. Also shout out to the pretty girl who was working the floor.. her name is Stella. She was awesome. Yall Will keep seeing us!“

“Best pizza in Central Florida! Jets Detroit style is incredible for me, well worth the 30 minute drive.“

“Amazing food, great staff, and reasonable prices.“

“We come weekly and my husband didn’t like the new NY pizza a shift manager Jacob went above and beyond to replace it he is truly a brilliant young man that deserves to be a true manager ! I am a manager of sales and so taken back on how he was such a wonderful professional manager! I am giving my business to Jacob weekly ! Truly made my whole day Thank you Jacob for being you don’t change“