13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Altamonte Springs

“Wow! My wife and I have been past this restaurant for years and never thought to come in as we actually thought that they were closed. We realized that we have been making a big mistake and we are already figuring out when to return. Everything that we ordered was phenomenal (Bruschetta, Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina, Carne Trio, and Cannoli.)“

“My husband and I were starving after picking up some items from usps. This is not our normal everyday area so we were googling resturaunts for a bit until I thought of Italian. We had our 2 year old with us and we felt as though we would be under dressed for how nice this place was on the inside so we sat outside. I have to say, they made us feel so welcomed. Robert was super attentive and so sweet. The host came over and talked to us and our 2 year old. It just made the experience so nice for us as its usually hard to go out with our kiddo. Food came out and we were blown away by everything. So happy we stopped by. We are adding it to our revisit list and places to bring family from out of town! Thank you!“

“First and foremost Nick and his wife are absolutely attentive to all your needs. Pizza worth every penny and don't get me started on the Canolli?If you haven't tried, I'm telling you now you won't regret ever trying this place.God bless you on more succes Nick's Pizzeria. Thank you for fresh ingredients everytime!Bacon ranch pizza for the win!!!“

“I stopped eating just to write this review. The wings I ordered was Honey Sriracha and Hot Honey Garlic and blue cheese dipping sauce. I requested extra extra crispy wings and everything was phenomenal. I was given a specific time to pick up I adhered to the time arrived and my food was piping hot. Every sauce was amazing I wonder if they are homemade. I almost ate the bones. My chicken was decent size. I don't have any complaints. I regret not tipping usually I don't when I pick an order up but the cook and whomever put my order together did such an amazing job I will be back with tip in hand. In all honesty, good all around service is so far in between now and days but Jerry's I salute u for giving me everything I ordered and exceeding my expectations. Till next time.“

“Always great pizza…been coming here for almost twenty years. Tonight I had the best service ever! I called to order a pizza for pickup. The employee who took my order was amazing. His name is Adam. What made it so amazing was that you could hear the pride in his voice of what he was doing. I thought for sure he was the owner. When I picked up my pizza I recognized his voice. We made small talk but his passion for his job was clear. Something you don’t always see nowadays. I discovered he is a delivery driver but was helping out making dough, answering the phone and serving customers that walked in. He made my experience the best ever… and that made the pizza even better!! Don’t lose that employee! He’s more than 5 stars! ⭐️“

“For years I’ve been a customer of Papa Joe’s. I’m a New Yorker and know pizza, they not only make the most amazing food but it’s the kind of family ambiance and home feel that you get from visiting family. The food is always on point. I highly recommend anyone that loves Italian food to stop at this little gem of Altamonte Springs. Thank you for what you do in our community Papa Joe’s. ❤️“

“My wife and I were in town staying at a local hotel. I asked the check in rep if there were any good pizza places close by. He gave me a flyer to this place. We looked it over and thought "what the hell". We called and gave them our order: 1 Medium Pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onions, ham & hot peppers 1 Antipasto salad 1 order of Meatballs The food arrived to the hotel pretty quickly. It was all hot (except the salad) and fresh. We couldn't wait to dig in. The pizza looked so good I didn't want to eat it Everything was very good. I would order from them again if I was in the area. ***They only get 4 stars though. I would have given them 5 stars but they did not have any silverware for my wife to enjoy her salad and meatballs. When delivering to hotels, they need to be aware to have silverware available to their customers“

“Everything was incredible-just got off a cruise and was craving Anthony's Coal Fire wings and meat balls. Wonderful service by Halle and conversation with David. Heard about the New Kitchen Chef but he was not working and all the food came out just it always does-Thanks Again for a Great Experience! Matt and Dot!“

“All staff and pizza makers are talented and food is delicious. Our server Gabby was above and beyond in service, friendliness and kindness. She suggested some tweaks to our dinner that really made it stand out. Delicious pizza, I especially like the Spinach and tomato with mushrooms.“

“New Yorker here. Pizza was great compared to many in the area. Fried calamari was great size but wish the portion was larger. Cesar Salad was nothing special. Pizza took a while to come out but server was polite and help serve pizza.Kid-friendliness: Offers kids a menu with crayons. Pizza is always a kid friendly option“

“This has been my go to pizza place since I moved cross town. They have always been spot on and even before they used delivery apps the staff who delivered were friendly , and approachable, Now for the pizza- the sauce is perfect , not too much tomato', no tomato chunks and a great crust . Cannoli is SO good.“

“We had a blast, it's an hour drive from my house, the workers were great, clean bathrooms, helpful workers, not to many people there was a plus,my only issue is they took out so many of the games & you don't get coins an tickets no more you get a card an your points go on the card!! I understand the card ordeal part of my childhood core memory was the tickets an coins..“

“Was supposed to meet up with friends & we somehow got directions messed up and ended up at the apopka location while my friends were here... long story short Kim, our server was GREAT! she didn't give me dirty looks when I walked in with my plastic bag with food from the other froggers' location. Kim, THANK YOU! not to mention it was literally 20min before close.“